Provincial Budget Comparison Fiscal years 2013-2014

[Creder]

Punjab's budget has also been announced

Punjab to present Rs890b budget today - thenews.com.pk

same source different figures

 

[SBD-3]

Budgetary Comparison
Punjab Budget size 871 Billion
KPK 344 Billion

Education
Punjab 210 Billion (24% of total Budget) (43 Billion Development+ salaries etc)
KPK 66 Billion (19% of total budget) (All combined no distinction available)
Health
Punjab 82 Billion (9.4% of total budget)
KPK 22.8 Billion (6.67% of total budget)
Agriculture
Punjab 13 Billion (1.5%)
KPK 2.91 Billion (0.08%)
Law enforcement infrastructure
Punjab 73 Billion (8.38%)
KPK 23 Billion (6.69%)

Sources
http://www.financekpp.gov.pk/FD/attachments/article/236/Budget Speech 2013-14.pdf
Punjab govt unveils Rs 871 billion budget - thenews.com.pk

Punjab to present Rs890b budget today - thenews.com.pk

same source different figures

The news is pre-budget news.

 

[Bratva]

@hasnain0099 sahab, Is Federal and provincial budget are two different entities? Or provincial budget is a subset of federal budget?

 

[SBD-3]

@hasnain0099 sahab, Is Federal and provincial budget are two different entities? Or provincial budget is a subset of federal budget?

Yes they are. Federation is just like the parent which not only manages its own budget but also transfer funds to provinces. Now provinces make their own budget by receiving those transfers and raising taxes domestically.

 

[Jango]

Yes they are. Federation is just like the parent which not only manages its own budget but also transfer funds to provinces. Now provinces make their own budget by receiving those transfers and raising taxes domestically.

But one thing I don't understand.

Federal govt's minimum wage for labourer is different to the provinces. So whose minimum wage will actually be implemented?

 

[SBD-3]

But one thing I don't understand.

Federal govt's minimum wage for labourer is different to the provinces. So whose minimum wage will actually be implemented?

The minimum wage for Federal government will be applicable to federal employees and private sector in Federally administered areas and CT Islamabad.
The minimum wages for provinces will be applicable for provincial territories.

 

[aks18]

Budgetary Comparison
Punjab Budget size 871 Billion
KPK 344 Billion

Education
Punjab 210 Billion (24% of total Budget) (43 Billion Development+ salaries etc)
KPK 66 Billion (19% of total budget) (All combined no distinction available)
Health
Punjab 82 Billion (9.4% of total budget)
KPK 22.8 Billion (6.67% of total budget)
Agriculture
Punjab 13 Billion (1.5%)
KPK 2.91 Billion (0.08%)
Law enforcement infrastructure
Punjab 73 Billion (8.38%)
KPK 23 Billion (6.69%)

Sources
http://www.financekpp.gov.pk/FD/attachments/article/236/Budget Speech 2013-14.pdf
Punjab govt unveils Rs 871 billion budget - thenews.com.pk


The news is pre-budget news.

do consider population of both provinces too

 

[aamerjamal]

do consider population of both provinces too

do consider the security situation too... whatever punjab built remains for 5-10 years not sure about kpk if any school or hospital remains for 5-10 months they have to reconstruct a hospital for 5 times... so instead for lolipop to PTI's internet warrior if they were so serious why they didn't put most of the money on security......
People of this country are dying but some how you PTI kids always find something to laugh on other....
did you know one more MPA from KPK died in bomb blast today and i think he is from PTI.... can you laugh again that they reduced more population (almost 34 people martyred in it) for your stupid laugh and comparison.....

 

[aks18]

do consider the security situation too... whatever punjab built remains for 5-10 years not sure about kpk if any school or hospital remains for 5-10 months they have to reconstruct a hospital for 5 times... so instead for lolipop to PTI's internet warrior if they were so serious why they didn't put most of the money on security......
People of this country are dying but some how you PTI kids always find something to laugh on other....
did you know one more MPA from KPK died in bomb blast today and i think he is from PTI.... can you laugh again that they reduced more population (almost 34 people martyred in it) for your stupid laugh and comparison.....

seedhi tarah bol Security bhi Provinces ka issue hai emotional fool

 

[SBD-3]

seedhi tarah bol Security bhi Provinces ka issue hai emotional fool

After 18th amendment, constitutionally it is. But I guess KPK government didn't know that so they froze the security budget at 23 Billion. And I guess we have started to see the results. Unless a robust security infrastructure is not in place, no economic development will be possible. However it seems that PTI policymakers missed out on that. 2 MPs Killed within a months says a thousand words about the security situation. When MPs are not safe, how could general public be?

 

[aamerjamal]

seedhi tarah bol Security bhi Provinces ka issue hai emotional fool

thanks... your reply shows ur maturity level....

 

[aks18]

After 18th amendment, constitutionally it is. But I guess KPK government didn't know that so they froze the security budget at 23 Billion. And I guess we have started to see the results. Unless a robust security infrastructure is not in place, no economic development will be possible. However it seems that PTI policymakers missed out on that. 2 MPs Killed within a months says a thousand words about the security situation. When MPs are not safe, how could general public be?

18th amendment also allowed provinces to produce electricity and guess what PML N Did Chankana in last 5 years and talking about law and order then why you made responsible rahman malik for security lapse in last 5 years isnt province responsible security lapses

thanks... your reply shows ur maturity level....

chal reply kar dia hai teray maturity level par

 

[Creder]

After 18th amendment, constitutionally it is. But I guess KPK government didn't know that so they froze the security budget at 23 Billion. And I guess we have started to see the results. Unless a robust security infrastructure is not in place, no economic development will be possible. However it seems that PTI policymakers missed out on that. 2 MPs Killed within a months says a thousand words about the security situation. When MPs are not safe, how could general public be?

For N-League and their supporters it is a Federal Issue if something happens in Balochistan and Punjab that is why the Federal Minister himself is involved in constituting the committees that are looking into these incidents. As far as Sindh and KPK security is concerned it is a provincial issue, who cares if pashtuns are dying like dogs out there. Two MPA's dead within three weeks where is chaudhry Nisar ?

 

[aamerjamal]

For N-League and their supporters it is a Federal Issue if something happens in Balochistan and Punjab that is why the Federal Minister himself is involved in constituting the committees that are looking into these incidents. As far as Sindh and KPK security is concerned it is a provincial issue, who cares if pashtuns are dying like dogs out there. Two MPA's dead within three weeks where is chaudhry Nisar ?

abhi tu 5 din howey hain abhi sey fed sey help mangney lag gaey??????????????? tu itni batain kartey ku hoo... History Check ... last 5 years main punjab main jo kuch aisa howa kidnapping, blast, dengue and so on.... did fed provide any assistance NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
abhi tu 1 month howa hai imagine PTI still have almost 4 years and 11 months (2 MPA a month means ????)
baatain TV per achi lagti hai yan net per field per kam karna parta hai......