Professor of Sindh university: why all other nationalities people are allowed to work&trade in Sindh

[TNT]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1258701789181939712

Even the sindhi professors are stupid and dumb. First of all it's not nationalities because we are all supposed to be one nation Pakistan. Second of all this moron should know that no one will stop a sindhi working in Peshawar or lahore, infact the locals will support them, if sikhs can work in tribal areas and Peshawar, why cant sindhis? Is it our fault that sindhis are little cry babies lazy farts? Is it our fault that sindhis are jahil and cant disobey their waderas?? Sindhis cant come out of slavery of waderas, let alone working in other provinces. So this dumb professor should educate her ppl before uttering crap. Saying im not racist doesn't change anything, she is a racist and a stupid n dumb one.

 

[waz]

Now all ‘nationalities’ are rallying to help Sind.

 

[villageidiot]

People in Dubai will go back one day

Here , people won't go back

This is a genuine concern, I agree with her in a sense that we should most certainly have a debate on this issue instead of getting angry

If 50-60% of pakhtunkhwa, Punjab, gilgit becomes non -them


It'll most certainly cause issues, Sindhis have an argument

I suggest a card for new arrivals to seperate them from the Sindhis (including punjabis, Urdu speaker, pakhtun who have been living in Sindh for a long time)

At 3:30

sir, I understand the social issues stemming from large scale immigration of foreigners. What I don't understand is why is always these Sindhi nationalist who have a problem with this. I live deep in the heart of central punjab and there's pathans everywhere. In our villages and cities. They are honest, hardworking and we Punjabis even admire those qualities and admit our lack of work ethic compared to them. Why is there a conspiracy against just sindh. I am not aware of the actual scale of the immigration into sindh, but why it would be any more in sindh (outside of karachi) than it is in punjab escapes me.

 

[Maula Jatt]

sir, I understand the social issues stemming from large scale immigration of foreigners. What I don't understand is why is always these Sindhi nationalist who have a problem with this. I live deep in the heart of central punjab and there's pathans everywhere. In our villages and cities. They are honest, hardworking and we Punjabis even admire those qualities and admit our lack of work ethic compared to them. Why is there a conspiracy against just sindh. I am not aware of the actual scale of the immigration into sindh, but why it would be any more in sindh (outside of karachi) than it is in punjab escapes me.

is Lahore or Faisalabad majority non-punjabi
Is Punjab 40-50% non-Punjabi?

have our demographics changed to this extent? - no, far from it
that's why they're more worried about it than others

 

[Dark-Silence]

This Shit mentality of Jahil Sindhis is destroying Karachi

 

[newb3e]

Karachietes consider their city as some metropolis where only certain "socio economic class" of people should live and work this whole concept is bs the reason why poor sindhis or Balochs or Pashtuns or even Punjabis migrate to Khi is because its a rag tag city its a cheap shit hell hole where they see opportunity the only way Karachi can stop this migration is if we localized law that discourage (not based on some ethnic bs) migration based on high taxation, high cost of living but with all the modern infrastructure etc where only a certain class (again not based on ethnic bs) a educated working class or a investor/manufacturer/trader class can survive (because of high taxation) and live in the city!

until such laws are made Sindhi and Balochs specially will keep migrating to Karachi because they live in a shitter hell hole than Karachi!

 

[villageidiot]

Is Punjab 40-50% non-Punjabi?

Are you saying, outside Karachi, sindh is 40-50% non-sindhi?

 

[Maula Jatt]

Are you saying, outside Karachi, sindh is 40-50% non-sindhi?

is Karachi, Hyderabad not Sindh ...
Its like Faisalabad and Lahore - how can you separate it from Sindh?

 

[villageidiot]

is Karachi, Hyderabad not Sindh ...
Its like Faisalabad and Lahore - how can you separate it from Sindh?

sir, my history is really weak so idk about Hyderabad, but Karachi saw millions of destitute and oppressed Muslims seek refuge from murderous Hindu hordes. So, if sindhis didn't like their heaven on earth getting desecrated by those inferior beings, they should have turned them back there and then.

Punjab also saw mass migration, although they weren't concentrated in one place like karachi is. My whole street in the village I am from is 'muhajirs' mohala. They are significant in number in our village and hold significant power and wealth. Quite the turn around from when my great grandfather gave them land and animals to feed themselves when they came here.

They are part of the usual biradri politics of the village, but absolutely NO ONE labels derides them as being "outsiders".

 

[Dark-Silence]

is Karachi, Hyderabad not Sindh ...
Its like Faisalabad and Lahore - how can you separate it from Sindh?

KHI is always separate from Sindh

 

[MastanKhan]

Punjabis came, worked hard and cultivated Virgin land

added to Sindh by plowing it's fields, fertilizing it's land, and learned the language

Hi,

There is no doubt about that.

 

[Maula Jatt]

KHI is always separate from Sindh

no, it wasn't- it was mostly under Sindh-based dynasties, in most censuses it was a majority Sindhi speaker

it was Sindhi land, that they were kind enough to share with the rest of Pakistan and we in return should respect and acknowledge that

was it distinct from the rest of the Sindh in some ways- hell yeah just like every other big city is

 

[MastanKhan]

sir, I understand the social issues stemming from large scale immigration of foreigners. What I don't understand is why is always these Sindhi nationalist who have a problem with this. I live deep in the heart of central punjab and there's pathans everywhere. In our villages and cities. They are honest, hardworking and we Punjabis even admire those qualities and admit our lack of work ethic compared to them. Why is there a conspiracy against just sindh. I am not aware of the actual scale of the immigration into sindh, but why it would be any more in sindh (outside of karachi) than it is in punjab escapes me.

Hi,

Pathans and Balochis had settlements in punjab before partition.

 

[Zhukov]

Khatam karo ye Angrez era ke Provinces Sindh Punjab Balochistan Frontier bla bla bla. City states banao ab division level pe Baqi developed world ki tarha. With own cirty district governments. Ye Provincial Assembly aur senate wali Khichri ka khatma karo. Pakistan ki Unity pe latki hui Talwaar hai ye Provinces.

 

[SaadH]

is Lahore or Faisalabad majority non-punjabi
Is Punjab 40-50% non-Punjabi?

have our demographics changed to this extent? - no, far from it
that's why they're more worried about it than others

At the time independence Karachi wasn't a Sindhi majority city. Most of the native population on the outskirts of city comprised of Baloch goths not Sindhi goths.

Karachi's demographic was a mix of Parsis, Iranis, Bhoris, Hindus, Baloch, Gujratis and Sindhis. Quaid e Azam, a native born son of Karachi was a bhori, not a Sindhi.

Plus it wasn't a developed metropolis on the magnitude of Lahore. It's development post Independence has been on the back of Mohajirs and other nationalities from other parts of Pakistan, namely Pukhtuns. Sindhis have not contributed an iota to it's development.