Prime Minister Imran Khan Great Inspirational Speech in Karachi

[PaklovesTurkiye]

Bengalis are still fine...May be....

But Afghanis.........HELL NO

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Prime Minister made a stong point , world wide if you are born there you get citizenship and you pay taxes so for people to illegally live and get exploited is not something we want in Pakistan, they are born / live here help Pakistan by Paying Taxes and help us grow stronger instead of street crime

US gives citizenships to people
UK gives citizenships to people
Europe gives citizenships to people

It is about time Pakistan also modernized it's approach to make a stronger Pakistan , a Tax Paying Pakistan

 

[Lincoln]

Bullshit...BVllshit

I voted for you Khan.....DON'T do that.

Don't give Pakistani citizenship to them

PPP will capitalize on this and will re emerge as savior of Sindh...

Khan, you're just being fool

What should he do then?

How will you track down and remove over two million refugees from the city and be able to remove them without causing harm, increased violence, increasing street crime, anti Pakistan sentiment, increased terrorism as a result and purging your reputation in the process.

It's practically speaking near impossible, and even if we do consider it possible, it will require and unprecedented amount of effort, money, force and time which can be risky, and what do we get in return? Nothing except some parts of Guttersnipes gone. All to force disadvantaged, unprivileged, poor people out of the country and in the process burn through much effort, force and money while achieving increased violence.

You know what's better? Making the best out of it, providing them with education and uplifting them out of poverty along with rest of the poor population of Karachi. It will be more practical as well because both sides will be willing to co-operate, and they would too since it's their welfare. Their welfare means the welfare of the state and city.

 

[Max]

Well this Bengali/Afghani nationality project will not bode well for country or PTI. I expect Sindhi nationalists to be on roads if he don't back off. Maybe GDA can also create pressure.

 

[Desert Fox]

Hogwash:

https://tradingeconomics.com/pakistan/gdp-per-capita-ppp

https://tradingeconomics.com/bangladesh/gdp-per-capita-ppp

Those are 2017 numbers.

My links provides 2018 numbers.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

It is against our religion to give

• 1 Wage for Citizen and then give 30% wage for illegal , just because they did not had ID card or passport even when they lived in country or were born here in Pakistan

When they are born here or have lived 30-40 years in Pakistan , I think the people at that point become connected to Pakistan 100%

 

[Max]

It is against our religion to give

• 1 Wage for Citizen and then give 30% wage for illegal , just because they did not had ID card or passport even when they lived in country or were born here in Pakistan

When they are born here or have lived 30-40 years in Pakistan , I think the people at that point become connected to Pakistan 100%

It's not about wage, Sindhi have reservations about demographic change in Sindh.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

I think it is backward thinking .......in USA you can move from Massachusetts to California and you are viewed only as American you can buy land, start life and pay taxes. Your children can go to school and get same education quality in any state/province

That is the approach we need to adopt

We can't continue with this segregation culture, self imposed quota system

 

[CIS-TRANS]

Karachi have lost its economic charisma for once it known for, instead people are migrating from karachi not to karachi, it will continue to lose its importance from now on and as a karachiite its quite disheartening for me but i think its bound to happen. The era of financial hub for Pakistan is heading towards an end for Karachi.

 

[Desert Fox]

Giving citizenship to those and only to those who are already here and not to refugees which arrive later does not incentivize illegal immigration. Illegal immigration is continuous, he plans to provide citizenship to those who have been here in Pakistan for years, not to any and all illegals entering the country.

Those who are already here arrived illegally and by giving them citizenship you are telling other's that they too can come illegally and wait their turn to get citizenship.

Why is that too hard to comprehend?

But here we have two options, spend an unprecedented amount of effort, money and workforce into finding and forcing out all illegals which are well over two million at least, so practically near impossible, resulting in continued violence, rise of crime and poverty... or we provide basic education, uplift them out of poverty and make this a blessing in disguise, make the best out of it, which is more practical because it is their welfare; they would be more than willing to co-operate for it, and their welfare means the welfare of this city and country.

Or we can make it impossible for them to have a living and thus they will leave at their own choice through the same way they came illegally.

And if your concern is crime then that too can be easily solved by improving security and law enforcement through reduction of bureaucratic corruption.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Karachi is just getting started folks

REBOOTED

• Extra Water Supply with Desalination plant for City

• Factory/Plant to help burn waste and recycle sewage (Create more water for plants/gardens)

• The green Karachi campaign should benefit with extra water supply

• Railways told to extend stops in Karachi

• If METRO project starts in Karachi , the traffic problems will self resolve

 

[PaklovesTurkiye]

What should he do then?

How will you track down and remove over two million refugees from the city and be able to remove them without causing harm, increased violence, increasing street crime, anti Pakistan sentiment, increased terrorism as a result and purging your reputation in the process.

It's practically speaking near impossible, and even if we do consider it possible, it will require and unprecedented amount of effort, money, force and time which can be risky, and what do we get in return? Nothing except some parts of Guttersnipes gone. All to force disadvantaged, unprivileged, poor people out of the country and in the process burn through much effort, force and money while achieving increased violence.

You know what's better? Making the best out of it, providing them with education and uplifting them out of poverty along with rest of the poor population of Karachi. It will be more practical as well because both sides will be willing to co-operate, and they would too since it's their welfare. Their welfare means the welfare of the state and city.

When there is a will there is a way....Khan should not do solo flight here...Adopting Afghans proved to be way painful for us. Learn from history.

Bengalis may be fine but even among them, security risks are present.

 

[Lincoln]

It's not about wage, Sindhi have reservations about demographic change in Sindh.

That is one of the main issues. Instead of issuing Pakistan identity, I feel it would be a good start if the Government issues them some form of identity which allows them to be able to at least achieve same opportunities and be part of any and all programmes to uplift the poor in Karachi

 

[django]

No thats a stupid step kick them out they are not our problem

EVERY SINGLE LAST ONE OF THEM!!!!!!!

 

[Max]

That is one of the main issues. Instead of issuing Pakistan identity, I feel it would be a good start if the Government issues them some form of identity which allows them to be able to at least achieve same opportunities and be part of any and all programmes to uplift the poor in Karachi

Agree.