PML N supporters insight on current economical crisis?

[Yaseen1]

Most objective way is to look at key indicators..this isn't magic that you need feel the environment...honestly are you on marijuana ....

Debt has increased to 70% of gdp(in actual terms nearly by 35 billion dollars ) by law it an go up front 60% mushi law
Losses to 1.5 trillion
Exports were 24 billion dollars in PPPP ERA they dropped to 21 billion dollars
Rupee devaluation rafter first overly protective
Education and health dismal situation


Incase if reelection it will be 1998 repetition..My prediction is that either Pakistan will default as 1998 and rupee will drop to 250 like it did than

This will be followed by Nawaz Sharif leaving the country someone saying why. He would say just like his son " I am not a Pakistani but British civilian "

Or marshallaw will come to enforce reforms like has been happening whenever an idiot is repeatedly elected by educated class

this is all due political instability in the form of protest during last 5yrs which was not in ppp tenure and also corruption is deep rooted in our society .not to blame govt for all this alone although they are also responsible for this.the result of cancer which started by ppp govt are long lasting and come more severely in next govts.one you plant corruption in institutions and society it is very difficult to control it .we should check the reasons behind this borrowing which is due to 18 amendment and nfc award which provision state that provincial budget must be greater than previous year and now federal govt has lost grip over economy and provinces are also responsible for economy to great extent.

Most objective way is to look at key indicators..this isn't magic that you need feel the environment...honestly are you on marijuana ....

Debt has increased to 70% of gdp(in actual terms nearly by 35 billion dollars ) by law it an go up front 60% mushi law
Losses to 1.5 trillion
Exports were 24 billion dollars in PPPP ERA they dropped to 21 billion dollars
Rupee devaluation rafter first overly protective
Education and health dismal situation


Incase if reelection it will be 1998 repetition..My prediction is that either Pakistan will default as 1998 and rupee will drop to 250 like it did than

This will be followed by Nawaz Sharif leaving the country someone saying why. He would say just like his son " I am not a Pakistani but British civilian "

Or marshallaw will come to enforce reforms like has been happening whenever an idiot is repeatedly elected by educated class


How the get ***k was exchange kept constant ...last I check it's going to hit 130 its biggest drop in Pakistan history. Just like 1998

What happened was purely created by mismanagement..first they overly protected it i hope that rupee will crash after election but timing was wrong and it crashed before the election..same adhoc measures with productshowing a merely 25% increase was to 110 billion units from 90 billion units

In PPPP era it increased from 70 billion units to 90 billion units

In short with oil prices above 100 Pppp did comparatively better than Pml n (though still pathetic)

No wonder Zardari and showbaz go along so good

my reference to constant exchanges is during dar tenure only.there is no development in sindh during past 10yrs.what hell ppp has done

 

[ziaulislam]

this is all due political instability in the form of protest during last 5yrs which was not in ppp tenure and also corruption is deep rooted in our society .not to blame govt for all this alone although they are also responsible for this.the result of cancer which started by ppp govt are long lasting and come more severely in next govts.one you plant corruption in institutions and society it is very difficult to control it .we should check the reasons behind this borrowing which is due to 18 amendment and nfc award which provision state that provincial budget must be greater than previous year and now federal govt has lost grip over economy and provinces are also responsible for economy to great extent.

You talking non sense.
How does political instability effects more supply, lack of reforms, more corruption in state organizations..if and such demonstrations from opposition decreased the amount of corruption that went into this...
If we start looking for excuse you will always find some..the govt has been very strong and had no problems like PPPP govt which was a very weak coalition ..
18 amendment has to with health and education not with your govt central policies

Probably the grass roots spending due to 18 amendment led to more growth and expansion of lower class

Anyway I have been saying this since 2016 but people were still didn't believe the ominous signs..now that we at default..we are diffusing the blame?

 

[Yaseen1]

You talking non sense.
How does political instability effects more supply, lack of reforms, more corruption in state organizations..if and such demonstrations from opposition decreased the amount of corruption that went into this...
If we start looking for excuse you will always find some..the govt has been very strong and had no problems like PPPP govt which was a very weak coalition ..
18 amendment has to with health and education not with your govt central policies

Probably the grass roots spending due to 18 amendment led to more growth and expansion of lower class

Anyway I have been saying this since 2016 but people were still didn't believe the ominous signs..now that we at default..we are diffusing the blame?

go and read first provisions of nfc awards and 18 amendment it has given power to provinces to collect taxes which was previously in federal govt hands and they not remit their share of collected taxes to federal govt.pmln is much weaker than ppp as kpk and sindh are not under their control and balochistan govt was also taken away at last year and also army stance towards them is strict unlike gen kyani who very much leneant towatds ppp govt.political instability has negative impact on stock market and it discourage foreign investment so govt has to take more loans to fill gap for time being

 

[ziaulislam]

go and read first provisions of nfc awards and 18 amendment it has given power to provinces to collect taxes which was previously in federal govt hands and they not remit their share of collected taxes to federal govt.pmln is much weaker than ppp as kpk and sindh are not under their control and balochistan govt was also taken away at last year and also army stance towards them is strict unlike gen kyani who very much leneant towatds ppp govt.political instability has negative impact on stock market and it discourage foreign investment so govt has to take more loans to fill gap for time being

I have read the 18 amendment..simply the provincial govt getting 60% of taxes(not revenues, they still get less than 50%) how does that has anything to do with anything..
Deal was provinces get more money but in take care of health and education..??
Sawal aik hey aur jawan dosra???
Federal govt still has more money and larger budget than provincial govt combined @

Look if you want to blindly support Nawaz Shah go ahead but don't invent things

Stock market has nothing to do with policies it's the other way around for God sake!!

Overly taxing the exports, overly protecting the rupee and lack ease of doing business going down destroyed the exports ..mean while steel mills pia power sector acculmated 2.5 trillion rupees lost due to lack of serious attitude by the govt..thus a dominio effect

 

[Yaseen1]

I have read the 18 amendment..simply the provincial govt getting 60% of taxes(not revenues, they still get less than 50%) how does that has anything to do with anything..
Deal was provinces get more money but in take care of health and education..??
Sawal aik hey aur jawan dosra???
Federal govt still has more money and larger budget than provincial govt combined @

Look if you want to blindly support Nawaz Shah go ahead but don't invent things

Stock market has nothing to do with policies it's the other way around for God sake!!

Overly taxing the exports, overly protecting the rupee and lack ease of doing business going down destroyed the exports ..mean while steel mills pia power sector acculmated 2.5 trillion rupees lost due to lack of serious attitude by the govt..thus a dominio effect

i not support pmln .i agree govt did not much better to promote industrial growth.we should not
waste time on comparing two corrupt govts in past . i hope pti win next election and we get rid of pmln and ppp.we should not lose hope.although our economy is very weak but we should try our best to move out of this and make Pakistan strong

 

[ziaulislam]

i not support pmln .i agree govt did not much better to promote industrial growth.we should not
waste time on comparing two corrupt govts in past . i hope pti win next election and we get rid of pmln and ppp.we should not lose hope.although our economy is very weak but we should try our best to move out of this and make Pakistan strong

Point is accountability..I want people to make their leaders accountable..there is no guarantee that if pti does form govt(unlikely) that they will do the right thing..but if they don't educated people should hold them accountable ..as trends in urban areas do effect the country rural uneducated population as well
Last we want is PTI supporters supporting a govt which doesn't deliver..we have 2 extremist, we don't want a third group

 

[pakman12]

PMLN supporters do not care about the bigger picture. They are incapable of critical thinking and are mental slaves.
If they had thought of the whole country rather than whether the local mna can build a road for them then we would not be in such a mess.

 

[ziaulislam]

PMLN supporters do not care about the bigger picture. They are incapable of critical thinking and are mental slaves.
If they had thought of the whole country rather than whether the local mna can build a road for them then we would not be in such a mess.

I doubt that...most of PMLN base comes from highly educated urban areas of northern Punjab

 

[Attock]

QURZA OF PTI FAILED GOVERNMENT

Opening line is:

"The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) has been indebted to a loan of around Rs 3 trillion burdening the people of KP."

https://www.brecorder.com/2018/04/10/410754/pti-govt-drowns-kpk-with-rs-3-trillion-loans/

White elephant of Peshawar Metro. From 14 Billion To 49 Billion To 68 Billion Now and on its track to cross 100 Billion it seems.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1409834

Human Development Situation

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1712742/punjab-ahead-k-p-human-development/

 

[Mr. Aussie]

Munshi Dar is responsible for that, ah where is he now