Saiful Islam
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2013
- Messages
- 2,786
- Reaction score
- -7
- Country
- Location
Lmao you claimed urdu is a islamic language, I just refuted your statements. Islam doesn’t endorse any particular language as Islamic language
And if you want to question someone, go question a linguist who could tell you far better than I or what you claim
True. Qaumi madrasa is a relic of the past far before the days of mutazilites
Wow
I didn’t know the maulana held such views
Arab is not derived from Persian or urdu and vice versa but they’ve influenced each other.
So yes al zakir is on a load of bullshit
if anyone is to say origin of Arabic you could trace it back to semites or basically Hebrew etc... you could trace further back to aramaic
I’ve met people who speak Aramaic as native tongue and I would say Arabic is the furthest language you would think of when hearing it but it’s still more closely related to that than urdu or farsi
Farsi Bhasha is what is known to our people due to several empires and chieftains and people to people contact. Hindustani/Urdu Bhasha history is confined to Dhaka imo, with the Dhaka Nawab's and other small titular families.
The other reason is because of Bollywood and related cinemas and as a result picked up some distorted version of Hindi and all of a sudden we think we can speak Hindi/Urdu when we cannot.