PLA can be defeated in one Hour in nuclear war by US: Russian Expert

[lonelyman]

You can remain in denial and in fool's paredice. I do not have any remedy.

No worry, your self loving PM Modi just said you hindus mastered aviation, plastic surgery(change elephant head),interstellar travel etc 5000 years ago, all u need to do is find them from archives.

 

[HariPrasad]

Of course, it has to do with India.

Since this thread by an Indian troll by quoting from an anti-China liberal from Russia.

So you should expect the backlash comments against India, since no real Russian member here came here to troll China in this topic.

Your undemocratic mindset is on exhibition. This is an open forum. Here all topics are discussed and not only one hyping china. This is an opinion of russian expert. Similar voices have been raised by chinese experts also.

 

[lonelyman]

Well, we had airdropped our first H-bomb by 1967, which means it must be very small.

Consider that our bomber in the 1960s only had a very small payload. While India's current atomic bomb was still detonated on the ground, and this indicates the clumsiness of your atomic bomb design.

India will never cross to megatons fusion stage. I seriously doubt they even miniatured their 20kt fission bomb.

It's very vey difficult.

It takes France 8 years, they still couldnt figure out. In the end British helped them with American T-U design. USSR stole it through KGB

China's first H-bomb already miniatured and weaponized, dropped by a bomber, thanks to real genious and hero Yu Ming.

It takes US a dozen tests to come to this level.

Yu ming's genious design saved our numerious tests and money, time.

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

India will never cross to megatons fission stage. I seriously doubt they even miniatured their 20kt fission bomb.

It's very vey difficult.

It takes France 8 years, they still couldnt figure out. In the end British helped them.

China's first H-bomb already miniatured and weaponized, dropped by a bomber, thanks to real genious and hero Yu Ming.

It takes US a dozen tests to come to this level.

Yu ming's genious design saved our numerious tests and money, time.

His nuke design layout is superior to that of T-U, so the US shouldn't blame China for creating a thermonuclear warhead that is superior to W88.

 

[DrawingDead]

Two points:

1. If the US was really capable of exterminating China via comprehensive nuclear extermination, and avoiding a second strike, they would have done so already. China is not under Russia's nuclear umbrella, so there would be no consequences for the USA. The fact that it hasn't happened casts OP's claims in irreparable doubt.

2. If China is not able to mount an effect second strike against the USA, we would have to follow an Israel-like "Samson option". That's why the 300 nukes in our possession would all be dropped on India (excluding IOK). There is an absolute doctrinal imperative to exact revenge, and demonstrate that our deterrence is not hollow, and that is why India would be erased.

Those have to be the 2 dumbest points you've ever made.

(1) Nobody goes around nuking countries just because they can. We didn't nuke you in the 50s and 60s when you didn't have shyte. Why would we do it now?

(2) That has to be the dumbest Samson option I've ever heard of. Hey genius, we're exactly half way across the earth from India. So go ahead and nuke them. I'm sure that will teach us a lesson

The OP is stupid. But he is right that the PLA would be defeated in an hour. The only problem is, in a war of this magnitude, we probably won't be around to celebrate the victory either.

 

[lonelyman]

useless to talk to An ignorant who do not understand the difference between the yield of Bomb and accuracy of missile.

what accuracy? India has the highest rocket lauch and missle tests failure rate,your GSLV 3 is still not operational(with numerious tests failures), LEO payload 8t. China's long march 3b, LEO payload 12t, was designed and operational 30 years ago.

You even cant get it up, let alone accuracy. You Indians know no shame in boasting

what accuracy? India has the highest rocket lauch and missle tests failure rate,your GSLV 3 is still not operational(with numerious tests failures), LEO payload 8t. China's long march 3b, LEO payload 12t, was designed and operational 30 years ago.

You even cant get it up, let alone accuracy. You Indians know no shame in boasting

FYI, Long march 5 will test flight next year, LEO payload 25 t.

Wait for long march 9 in a couple of years, you indians will shit your pants.

 

[HariPrasad]

Those have to be the 2 dumbest points you've ever made.

(1) Nobody goes around nuking countries just because they can. We didn't nuke you in the 50s and 60s when you didn't have shyte. Why would we do it now?

(2) That has to be the dumbest Samson option I've ever heard of. Hey genius, we're exactly half way across the earth from India. So go ahead and nuke them. I'm sure that will teach us a lesson

The OP is stupid. But he is right that the PLA would be defeated in an hour. The only problem is, in a war of this magnitude, we probably won't be around to celebrate the victory either.

They are bunch of funny people. They do not mind getting exposed and proving themselves funny in process of replying. Just enjoy their comedy and do not take them seriously.

 

[MastanKhan]

So---why would the U S hit china with a nuc strike?

 

[Cossack25A1]

What would happen if humans become extinct suddenly???

These would take over planet Earth.

 

[Aepsilons]

These would take over planet Earth.

lol

 

[Cossack25A1]

lol

Or chickens as they outnumber humans, given that humans suddenly goes extinct without using nukes or many chicken survives nuke war and "mutate."

 

[lonelyman]

The OP is stupid. But he is right that the PLA would be defeated in an hour. The only problem is, in a war of this magnitude, we probably won't be around to celebrate the victory either.

Agree, what difference does it make? US destroys China 3 times, China destroys US 1 time, in the end its the same

Its posted by an Indian troll, day dreaming China get destroyed. He should get banned.

 

[Aepsilons]

Or chickens as they outnumber humans, given that humans suddenly goes extinct without using nukes or many chicken survives nuke war and "mutate."

Super size adobo manok ! ha ha !

 

[HariPrasad]

So---why would the U S hit china with a nuc strike?

No US won't.

 

[Beast]

Using same logic, May i conclude that China has not tested any bomb for years so chinese capability in N Bomb area has not increased in all these years?

US and Russia has not tested for many decades. So by your logic, US and Russia both shall be doubted as major nuclear power?

China has demonstrated H bomb with 3.3 megatons explosion in 1967. There is no doubt of China nuclear capabilities even until today. India has not demonstrated even once of high yield nuclear explosion.