Paris ban on Muslim street prayers comes into effect

[Bhairava]

french can have what ever ruke they make, but its clear neither french are interested in calling, frnce is our homeland we can ban what ever we want, and then go to libya kill libyans and stick out middle finger saying, hey we own 35% of libyan oil

Havent you heard of grammar,spacing,punctuations ? Try making sense.

"Our ground our rules. Dont like it GTFO" is what the French are saying.

Nothing wrong IMO.

 

[RKhan]

you can live where ever you want, nobody is forcing you to live anywhere, stop crying

if you wanna live in pakistan you have to live in by rules set by the majority

So why are you crying over this ban then?

 

[VCheng]

you can live where ever you want, nobody is forcing you to live anywhere, stop crying

if you wanna live in pakistan you have to live in by rules set by the majority

So, then, it follows that "if you wanna live in France you have to live in by rules set by the majority", and hence you have no basis to complain about the ban.

 

[RazPaK]

Dont resort to personal attacks if you don't have a point of view. He is clear about following rules and obeying local regulations. Before long they will be blasting prayer calls on the microphone like they do it here in India. It is Ok if your entire neighborhood is Muslim and they don't mind it. But if you are in multicultural societies it comes across as insensitive.

Ok.Here you go. If you are a pious muslim going about your your daily activities, and the time come for prayer, then you drop everything and pray. It takes ten minutes and should really not bother anyone except racists. You pray because it's your Farz/obligation and get it over and done with. The French controlling actions of a religion are just going to lead to Extremists. It's ironic that they preach Secularism, when they oppress basic freedoms of humanity.

 

[Roybot]

Ok.Here you go. If you are a pious muslim going about your your daily activities, and the time come for prayer, then you drop everything and pray. It takes ten minutes and should really not bother anyone except racists. You pray because it's your Farz/obligation and get it over and done with. The French controlling actions of a religion are just going to lead to Extremists. It's ironic that they preach Secularism, when they oppress basic freedoms of humanity.

Its not about one muslim man doing his prayers in public. Its about a whole bunch of them blocking the street and causing inconvenience to others.

Its a bit "in your face", and which is why today you see a ban on this.

 

[Mike2011]

Friday prayers cant be done at home , which is why everyone goes to Mosques on Fridays. btw Paris authorities have provided an alternative place where they can accommodate a few thousand people.

It came after a deal with Islamic community in Paris. No fuss at all.

Praying on road is nothing but jist show off...

It can't be at home but on road because Alla can see you directly..

 

[Bhairava]

So why are you crying over this ban then?

So, then, it follows that "if you wanna live in France you have to live in by rules set by the majority", and hence you have no basis to complain about the ban.

That was what I asked and got this answer. If you can, make something out of it. Ofcourse, I did not understand a single word.

french can have what ever ruke they make, but its clear neither french are interested in calling, frnce is our homeland we can ban what ever we want, and then go to libya kill libyans and stick out middle finger saying, hey we own 35% of libyan oil

 

[JonAsad]

Praying on road is nothing but jist show off...

It can't be at home but on road because Alla can see you directly..

its not that we pray on the roads and the mosques are kept empty- The house of God is the mosque not the street-

btw using a little bit of the common sense which bhagwan has gifted you- it will disclose to you that not many Muslims pray or go to mosque on regular days- its only fridays when you see mosques full and people praying on the road during Juma prayer time- being living in multicultural and ethical society you should have observed that-

and "show off" bit just shows your un maturity and inability to comprehend the situation which led to the ban-

---------- Post added at 03:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:39 AM ----------

Its not about one muslim man doing his prayers in public. Its about a whole bunch of them blocking the street and causing inconvenience to others.

Its a bit "in your face", and which is why today you see a ban on this.

i think aeronaut very clearly explained it to you- why muslims pray on the roads on fridays-

 

[Mike2011]

its not that we pray on the roads and the mosques are kept empty- The house of God is the mosque not the street-

btw using a little bit of the common sense which bhagwan has gifted you- it will disclose to you that not many Muslims pray or go to mosque on regular days- its only fridays when you see mosques full and people praying on the road during Juma prayer time- being living in multicultural and ethical society you should have observed that-

and "show off" bit just shows your un maturity and inability to comprehend the situation which led to the ban-

---------- Post added at 03:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:39 AM ----------



i think aeronaut very clearly explained it to you- why muslims pray on the roads on fridays-

I am still unable to comprehend, Prayer can't be done at home but only on road if not mosque.

 

[JonAsad]

That was what I asked and got this answer. If you can, make something out of it. Ofcourse, I did not understand a single word.

Being an indian living in india you might have seen alot of muslims praying in the streets- why no ban in india for this- can you explain this with out self praising?-

 

[Bhairava]

Isn't it a bit elementary ?

Roads are meant for transport, not for praying.

it ends there.

 

[VCheng]

Being an indian living in india you might have seen alot of muslims praying in the streets- why no ban in india for this- can you explain this with out self praising?-

Well, let's look up what "public right of way" means from a legal standpoint first, shall we?

 

[Bhairava]

Being an indian living in india you might have seen alot of muslims praying in the streets- why no ban in india for this- can you explain this with out self praising?-

I hardly see any Indian Muslim praying on the street. Maybe because Indian Muslims dont wear the religion up their sleeve. But if they do pray in some parts in INdia then I will support a ban. Because as I said Roads are for Transport, not for praying.

Also You never know what will hit you if you close your eyes for a second - a speeding auto or a taxi.

 

[JonAsad]

I am still unable to comprehend, Prayer can't be done at home but only on road if not mosque.

its simple- see them as brownie points- the pray (namaz) is ought to be prayed in a mosque (full points)- but if the mosque is full pray out side the mosque (little bit less points)- if even thats not possible- then pray at home (lesser points)-

It is said to pray this way- The point to understand is- it is not permissible to pray in the streets if the mosque is not full-

For us Muslims all that matters in the end are the points you scored in this world- and Juma prayer on fridays is an important prayer-- its like a weekly sermon - i cannot get more simpler than this-

 

[Roybot]

(God forbid if I am wrong) Street, Graveyard, Animal Barns, Wash-rooms and Streets are few where salat shouldn't be offered. So there is violation of Islamic values.

Friday prayers cant be done at home , which is why everyone goes to Mosques on Fridays. btw Paris authorities have provided an alternative place where they can accommodate a few thousand people.

It came after a deal with Islamic community in Paris. No fuss at all.

i think aeronaut very clearly explained it to you- why muslims pray on the roads on fridays-

Yes he did. But its not like people suddenly find out that, "oh no there is no space left in the mosque"! When you know that mosque is going to be full, why not just do it at home?

As Graphican meantioned, Salat?(am guessing friday prayers?) shouldn't be offered on the street.