What's new

Paper elephant : India spends a fortune on defence and gets poor value for money

where in the article did it talked about the rate of importing equipment? Even if u're referring to this single sentence in the article:



India was and still is the world's top importer of defence equipment- and not only that, it is going on an ever-increasing trend, not a decreasing one:

https://www.firstpost.com/world/ind...ina-lead-in-defence-expenditures-4252683.html

Global arms and military services sales rose for the first time since 2010, with India, Saudi Arabia, UAE, China and Algeria emerging as the top importers during the five year period of 2012-2016, a Firstpost analysis of the latest Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) report on global arms sales showed.

Together, these countries accounted for 34 percent of all global imports with India leading the table accounting for 13 percent for all arms imports. Vietnam was a new entry in the top-10 arms importers accounting for 3 percent of all global sales.


Global arms sales highest in five years
Infogram
Based on sales by the world's 100 biggest arms producers, the report pointed at an increase of 1.9 percent (based on 2015 US dollar values) from 2015 with $374.8 billion spent on arms and military services. Based on current US dollar values, the arms sales rose by 1.3 percent.

ADVERTISING


According to SIPRI's military expediture database, the volume of transfers of major weapons in 2012–16 was 8.4 percent higher than in 2007–11.

The United States managed its stand as the world's largest spender followed by China and Russia. The US also accounted for largest share of arms sales (33 percent) followed by Russia 23 percent. Interestingly, Saudi Arabia, the fourth largest spender, is the largest client of American arms, accounting for 13 percent of arms sales by US companies. The US also accounted for 14 percent of all Indian purchases, however, it was Russia which led the table accounting for 68 percent of India's arms imports during 2012-2016.


India was also among the top five spenders on arms and military services in 2016 spending $55,923 million in arms and military services.
According to the report, geopolitical tensions in the South China Sea, West Asia, and the Indian sub-continent has fuelled a rise in arms imports in West Asia and the Asia-Oceania, with the two regions contributing to 72 percent of all arms imports during 2012-2016 as compared to 2007-2011.

Though USA, Russia, China, France, and Germany accounted for 74 percent of the total volume of arms exports, a change was witnessed in arms exporters with South Korea maintaining its stand as an emerging arms supplier, whereas Germany and France seeing a decrease in arms sales.








Anyway, the topic was about Indian army getting poor value for the amount of money it spends on defence.

Furthermore, India spends lion's share of whatever budget it has- on personnel's pay and pension- not in its Defence MIC or any R&D- as seen in:



There u go, just rhetoric- again:

27grdd.jpg

Sensible people would not have replied to that post.

India's imports was 70% of the procurement budget, now it has fallen to 60%. By next year, it will be around 50%. The idea is to get to 40%.

This has nothing to do with competing with other countries in weapons imports.
 
. .
Sensible people would not have replied to that post.

India's imports was 70% of the procurement budget, now it has fallen to 60%. By next year, it will be around 50%. The idea is to get to 40%.

This has nothing to do with competing with other countries in weapons imports.
u're not addressing my post at all- which is that the thread is not about imports, but about how despite spending copious amounts of money, the Indian defense forces are still poorly-equipped- so why are u evading this point?

Also, im not interested in knowing your personal wishes that Indian defense imports will decrease to '40%' with a nice '10% decrease' per year. Keep masturbating to that.
 
.
u're not addressing my post at all- which is that the thread is not about imports, but about how despite spending copious amounts of money, the Indian defense forces are still poorly-equipped- so why are u evading this point?

Also, im not interested in knowing your personal wishes that Indian defense imports will decrease to '40%' with a nice '10% decrease' per year. Keep masturbating to that.

You are being clueless about how this works. I don't expect High IQ Chinese to understand.
 
. .
India is just starting to shift its gears, no need to compare with China which is aging, realised its full potential and set to become consumer driven economy.
 
.
India is just starting to shift its gears, no need to compare with China which is aging, realised its full potential and set to become consumer driven economy.
Ah, I admit it. After all, we are high-life expectancy country, different from India.
 
.
India is just starting to shift its gears, no need to compare with China which is aging, realised its full potential and set to become consumer driven economy.
Unprecedented mass unemployment disaster in human history will be more like it.
 
.
India is just starting to shift its gears, no need to compare with China which is aging, realised its full potential and set to become consumer driven economy.

How can India, which produce little and barely export anything except raw materials, have a consumer driven economy. The answer is in remittance. India is specifically a remittance based, factor driven economy. Though remittance is a small part of Indian GDP, its the driving factor.

Unprecedented mass unemployment disaster in human history will be more like it.
The focal point of Indian diplomacy is visa for India workers. China exports goods. India exports labor.
 
.
Unprecedented mass unemployment disaster in human history will be more like it.

Indian society is a society that encourages enterprise by way of self employment. So maybe this disaster could turn out to be a boon in disguise too.

Either way, fortune telling is not really your forte, is it ? :angel:
 
.
You are being clueless about how this works. I don't expect High IQ Chinese to understand.
There u go- still avoiding the topic at hand, which is how despite spending so much money, the Indian defence forces, from using the 'Flying coffin' https://www.firstpost.com/india/iafs-troubled-relationship-with-the-mig-21-955435.html to the https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/aft...ia-knocked-out-of-international-drill-1736699 that broke down during the 2017 Tank the biathlon to the https://www.firstpost.com/tech/news...t-scientists-try-to-locate-fault-3621591.html that failed multiple trials to the https://www.firstpost.com/india/del...ate-costs-impact-indian-navy-cag-2926052.html that is being built behind schedule


-are still ill-equipped.
 
Last edited:
.
Back
Top Bottom