Pakistans no.1 enemy Afghanistan

[MastanKhan]

You are not sheltering afghans...you are using refugee Afghan men's as terrorist and using female afghans as prostitutes for the army. Who in the world has free food like this. If Pakistanis are doing good for someone. ..there is a purpose ...you Muslim brother. Afghans know the crocodile tears...squeezing americans.

@WebMaster this gentleman does not belong here.

 

[RedRock]

WTF are you talking about? And who are you fooling? "winning hearts and minds of Afghans"??? Every Afghan thinks Pakistan is the cause of their suffering, their previous generation's sufferings and all. And you think you'll change that mind set????
Hell, the 3 million people you've been keeping for the past three decades, STILL blame Pakistan for everything and hate Pakistan, WHILE they live, work and earn their living in Pakistan!!! Some of them even wanted a Pashtunistan built and some Pashtun Army generals were with them too. Investigate IK's funding and see how much money many Pashtuns have given to him, who actually belong to Afghanistan. This was specifically to somehow build a Pashtunistan.

So do me a favor, try not to bullshiit me. I know the reality. What "people to people" connections? This is all more bullshiit. People can't go from the local check posts made every 10-15 miles or so? Do they must cross the mining area? The way you do it is put a fence up inside a few meters of Pakistan's territory and outside of it, still the Pakistani area but touching the other side, you put mines.

Kiyani seriously wanted to mine the border. That would've been the best thing to do. You would've successfully eliminated terrorism from your country and no one would be able to run to Afghanistan, hide and come back and stage attacks inside Pakistan.

oh american..lol... i never said the PA has to win the hearts and minds of the afghan people..lol where did you get that from? that was your job and now the afghan armies. I am talking about what PA has done in our tribal belt. Now calm down and re read what i have written.
cheers

 

[Viper0011.]

oh american..lol... i never said the PA has to win the hearts and minds of the afghan people..lol where did you get that from? that was your job and now the afghan armies. I am talking about what PA has done in our tribal belt. Now calm down and re read what i have written.
cheers

When we want to win hearts and minds, we do. It works out well and has ALWAYS worked. But you need to tell me what Pakistan is going to do about Afghanistan???? The Talibans won't leave Pakistan alone.....so the border needs to be sealed. Whether through a double sided fence with barb wires in between and posts, or through mines. What's it going to be??? The financial issues aren't there the way they existed in Zardari and Mushy's time. I know your interior minister has told NS and RS that he wants a Fence put in ASAP!!!

 

[RedRock]

When we want to win hearts and minds, we do. It works out well and has ALWAYS worked. But you need to tell me what Pakistan is going to do about Afghanistan???? The Talibans won't leave Pakistan alone.....so the border needs to be sealed. Whether through a double sided fence with barb wires in between and posts, or through mines. What's it going to be??? The financial issues aren't there the way they existed in Zardari and Mushy's time. I know your interior minister has told NS and RS that he wants a Fence put in ASAP!!!

Apparently you know the answer.

 

[Mythal]

That's 5 million OFFICIAL LEGAL Afghans in Pakistan. The real figure is probably many times higher. Pakistan probably has more Afghans than Afghanistan itself. Afghans have been living off the backs of Pakistanis for the last 36 years. Afghans are a Pakistani man's burden it seems. Wish they'd all go home. Anyway, why does it surprise anyone that Afghans hate Pakistanis? They hate eachother more and have been killing one another for centuries. Why should we worry about what the Afghans think of us? They're not exactly as developed and as militarily powerful as America. No one hates Afghans as much as the Iranians. If you all have read how Afghans are treated in Iran, you'd get the shock of your lives. It's akin to the Palestinian treatment by the Israelis. We should adopt this approach towards the Afghans in Pakistan.

The official registered number of Afghans is nearly 1.5 Million (1,478,030 according to UN in 2015).

 

[Genghis khan1]

Afghan not only hate Pakistani, They hate Iranians too. They hate themselves too. Uzbek can't get along with Tajik, Tajik with Hazara and Pushtune with them all. I found Tajiks in Afghanistan pretty reasonable and much friendlier than Pushtunes, although it is easy to turn disgruntle pushtun into friend cuz Pakistan got more Pushtuns than Afghanistan and in much better condition, so Afghan Pushtun honor that fact. Than comes Hazaras and finally Uzbek. Uzbeks are pretty unfriendly to Pakistan and very croupt.

 

[Indika]

After reading all the opinion , the conclusion is that pakistan is a saint and rest are sinners .
we gave afghan food,shelter....etc So what ? Are they indebted to pakistan for life nope. Pakistan is responsible for state of affairs in afghanistan, it is their constant meddling that have made afghans life worse.

Pakistani members keep repeating that borders need to be closed, refugees need to be expelled ....etc Why not do it instead of ranting and raving. Money should not be factor, hasnt india done the same ? long border or short order just do it and save your life.

Who are taliban ? proxy of pakistan, what is strategic ditch...err depth? coveting afghanistan territory through proxy.
Common afghan has every right to be pissed off, just like an iraqi is turned of by american. This refugees,brothers sentiment is all rubbish garbage there is no charity only ulterior motives.

Stop ranting and get on with it, pakistan is reaping what it sowed.

 

[Genghis khan1]

After reading all the opinion , the conclusion is that pakistan is a saint and rest are sinners .
we gave afghan food,shelter....etc So what ? Are they indebted to pakistan for life nope. Pakistan is responsible for state of affairs in afghanistan, it is their constant meddling that have made afghans life worse.

Pakistani members keep repeating that borders need to be closed, refugees need to be expelled ....etc Why not do it instead of ranting and raving. Money should not be factor, hasnt india done the same ? long border or short order just do it and save your life.

Who are taliban ? proxy of pakistan, what is strategic ditch...err depth? coveting afghanistan territory through proxy.
Common afghan has every right to be pissed off, just like an iraqi is turned of by american. This refugees,brothers sentiment is all rubbish garbage there is no charity only ulterior motives.

Stop ranting and get on with it, pakistan is reaping what it sowed.

How about you shut your pie hole.

 

[Indika]

How about you shut your pie hole.

Pakistan should stop supporting taliban and expel so called quetta shura.

 

[Genghis khan1]

Pakistan should stop supporting taliban and expel so called quetta shura.

India should stop supporting state sponsored terrorism in Kashmir and other proxies in Afghanistan.

 

[Indika]

India should stop supporting state sponsored terrorism in Kashmir and other proxies in Afghanistan.

Really every one knows that pakistan is the known epicenter of world terrorism and also home to so called mujaaaaaaaaahideeeeeeeeen . They did not find bin laden in india, did they ?

 

[punit]

Yes I have only recently in life found out (from Afghans) that they do not consider Pakistanis as friends or brothers. Indeed the general feeling of hatred is quite intense. I can say that I am better able to converse with a Hindu Indian than a Muslim Afghan. Such is the animosity!

Do not worry I was one of those who wished for brotherly relations with Afghans and thought good of Afghanistan. With time and forums like these Pakistanis will be made aware that this is not the case (unforutnately). Also the Pakistani media is in the hands of anti-Pakistani elements hence why they do not highlight critical issues like these. What Pakistanis should do is raise this awareness when discussing with family and friends.

u destroyed their country for ur and american vested interest.

 

[-blitzkrieg-]

I grossly disagree with this notion that Afghans are our enemy.You are talking about a nation you were almost about to form a confederation with in early 50s, a country you share cultural heritage for centuries unlike Indians. and here you people are promoting animosity on political differences formed over what last 50-60 years? which is outright ridiculous because whatever an urbanized afghan says or no matter how ungrateful an afghan refugee is there is STILL a huge section of Afghan population that has goodwill towards Pakistan and wants peace on the border regions, now if those people are not given coverage by the int. and afghan media you dont need to fall for for it. im not shooting this in the dark whatever your experience is, i have seen very friendly Afghans in Pakistan and outside.Check any of the localities in overseas, Afghans and Pakistani live in the same neighborhood WHY? Afghan may choose some other neighborhood but they dont, . Yes they have political differences, and those who dont cross the limit in mutual respect are able to live in harmony.If they say Pakistan has failed as a nation the response is not to curse him in return but put your point in a way which makes him believe we are not giving up in building this nation. And No not every Afghan believes in Durand line, most of them are happy with their current borders, they DONT want to fight a war with a MUSLIM nation. Please dont blow the distrust out of proportion and stop the racism.you disagree with the kabul govt fine dont stereotype aghans into everything.
p.s im not a PasthuN/Afghan

 

[Genghis khan1]

Really every one knows that pakistan is the known epicenter of world terrorism and also home to so called mujaaaaaaaaahideeeeeeeeen . They did not find bin laden in india, did they ?

Modi Terrorist, wanted by US courts is not the PM of Pakistan, or is he?!

Really every one knows that pakistan is the known epicenter of world terrorism and also home to so called mujaaaaaaaaahideeeeeeeeen . They did not find bin laden in india, did they ?

Modi Terrorist, wanted by US courts is not the PM of Pakistan, or is he?!

 

[Indika]

Modi Terrorist, wanted by US courts is not the PM of Pakistan, or is he?!
Modi Terrorist, wanted by US courts is not the PM of Pakistan, or is he?!

Most of the pakistans intelligence community has already accepted that they are behind taliban in afghanistan like haqqani group, so no point in denying it.