What's new

Pakistani Calls Attack Evidence Flimsy

BanglaBhoot

RETIRED TTA
Joined
Apr 8, 2007
Messages
8,839
Reaction score
5
Country
France
Location
France
A senior Pakistani diplomat said last year's terrorist rampage in Mumbai wasn't planned in Pakistan, and accused India of backing up its allegations of a Pakistani link with "fabricated" and "flimsy" evidence.

Wajid Shamsul Hasan, Pakistan's high commissioner to Britain, made his comments Friday to The Wall Street Journal and other news outlets. It was unclear whether his views represented the government's official conclusions on a dossier provided several weeks ago by India. The dossier, prepared by the Indian government, said the plot for the November assault was hatched in Pakistan and carried out by Pakistanis directed by Pakistan-based terrorist organization Lashkar-e-Taiba.

Mr. Hasan, speaking from London in a telephone interview, cautioned that he had only talked with people involved in the Pakistani investigation and hadn't seen his government's official report on the Indian dossier. Mr. Hasan said the report is likely to be released Monday or Tuesday.

Mr. Hasan's comments contradict statements by Pakistani security officials, who have said privately that at least one suspect -- a senior Lashkar member -- arrested by Pakistan after the assault, has confessed that his group plotted the operation, trained the attackers at bases inside Pakistan, and maintained phone contact with the gunmen during the three-day killing spree.

Pakistan's prime minister, Yousuf Raza Gilani, who is at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, said in an interview with the Journal, that the investigation is continuing. Mr. Gilani said he didn't want to comment on the investigation or the high commissioner's remarks, which he said he hadn't seen.

Mr. Hasan's remarks appear to reflect broader uncertainty in Islamabad over how to respond to the Mumbai attacks. While some officials are inclined to pursue the culprits -- because of international pressure and Pakistan's battle against Islamic militant groups -- at the same time, many don't want to be seen as caving to Indian demands for action.

Mr. Hasan said he was speaking with the media only because of persistent questions about whether the attacks "were planned in Pakistan or the U.K."

He said the people he spoke with who were working on the Pakistani report said "it was not the U.K., not Pakistan that was used for planning purposes."

Mr. Hasan said Pakistan's Interior Ministry is still investigating where the planning took place. "It could have been a neighboring country," he added. He declined to be more specific.

An Indian foreign ministry official expressed disbelief when told of Mr. Hasan's statements. The official said "we expect them to come clean" but that New Delhi would wait for the final report on the Pakistani investigation before formally responding.

In Washington, U.S. officials said they continue to believe that Lashkar-e-Taiba members in Pakistan were behind the attacks. "There are strong indications that much of the plot was hatched by individuals in Pakistan," a U.S. counterterrorism official said.

Pakistani Calls Attack Evidence Flimsy - WSJ.com
 
.
LONDON - Statement of High Commissioner to Britain Wajid Shamsul Hasan that Pakistan’s territory was not used to plan the Mumbai attacks has perturbed Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani who maintained that Wajid has spoken too soon.
In a preview of the findings of Islamabad’s investigation into the Indian dossier, Wajid told Indian news channel NDTV in London: “Pakistan’s territory was not used so far as we know. It could have been some other place but not the UK. Pakistani territory was not used so far as the investigators have made their conclusions. Because there were two places I was concerned about. They categorically informed me that UK was not involved. Pakistan was not involved. Its territories were not used for planning this operation.”
Wajid said Pakistan’s examination of the Indian dossier would show its ‘non-involvement’ in the attacks and questioned the veracity of the Indian information, saying it ‘could be fabricated’.
Wajid's utterance perturbs Gilani | Pakistan | News | Newspaper | Daily | English | Online

I think high commissioner spoke out of turn, which was not liked by PM.
 
.
Even Millaband said according to British evidence attracts are from Pakistan soil.
 
.
Pakistan should come clean on its role(role of elements operating from Pakistan). India and the world will be watching closely what conclusion Pakistan cmes up with.

Why is all the evidence being kept secret? If there is war over this then it will affect millions than should we not know the contents of these dossiers and determine what is flimsy or solid. Has Pakistan been given access to Qasab yet?
 
.
Why is all the evidence being kept secret? If there is war over this then it will affect millions than should we not know the contents of these dossiers and determine what is flimsy or solid. Has Pakistan been given access to Qasab yet?

If asked will be given why did they did not ask I thought they will ask to confirm his statement in there probe?
 
.
Why is all the evidence being kept secret? If there is war over this then it will affect millions than should we not know the contents of these dossiers and determine what is flimsy or solid. Has Pakistan been given access to Qasab yet?
Google it You will get what is there in dossier..It was all over print and electronic media..As far as access to qasaab is concerned there is no request from pakistan..
 
.
Google it You will get what is there in dossier..It was all over print and electronic media..As far as access to qasaab is concerned there is no request from pakistan..

here is your evidence

 
Last edited by a moderator:
. . . .
unfortunately truth is usually bitter. maybe funny for u.
but chillout
 
.
Restrain from personal attacks all of you. And please dont undermine the quality of discussion by posting kiddish videos.




If you have been tracking the story and development since 26/11, you will see that Pakistan accepted the fact that Kasab is Pakistani as late as 20th December. India had proposed to the Pakistan, to grant legal aid to Kasab after they had publicly accepted the fact, since no lawyer in India was ready to defend Kasab. Pakistan denied it. India has however said that if Pakistan seeks counseler access to Kasab, it will be granted.

Evidence has not been kept a secret. I am sure India has given enough evidence for Pakistan to book the perpetrators, that is what India wants.
And goverments donot need to share everything with its citizens. So you can accept disclarity even after probe findings have been revealed.

let the mods do their job,:rolleyes: and BTW this is not a kiddish video
 
.
what ever Kasab is Pakistani and attacks are by Pakistanis.
If no terrorists are there in Pakistan why is US bombing it and breaching it's sovereignty?
 
.
what ever Kasab is Pakistani and attacks are by Pakistanis.
If no terrorists are there in Pakistan why is US bombing it and breaching it's sovereignty?

Is that what you are being taught in School now?

As for the "Terrorists" who are being bombed by the drones, more women and children are dying from those attacks than any "Terrorists". But no point arguing because it's the new "In" thing these days to use the "Drone attacks" as a reason to label Pakistan as a terrorist state. Since you're all dangling in the arms of U.S nowadays, everything they'll say and do against Pakistan would sound like something out of a holy scripture to you folks now.
 
.
lets wait for the pakistani report and then have the discussion
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom