Pakistan will Unite Afghanistan and its Pasthun's in the distant future

[Taimoor Khan]

Are you serious hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah.
Wake up of your dream. You have an unstable country that is more divided across ethnic lines then Afghanistan. You already lost Bangladesh. Kashmir is a lost cause. Balochis hate you. 40 millions Pashtuns are die hard Pakistanis hahaha I don't think there are so many Gul Khans.

We would rather happily die then be called Pakistanis. LOL.

LOL, an Afghan telling about a "divided" country. Do you even have viable state sunnyboy? Being occupied currently by the yanks and NATO. First become independant and then talk about statehood.

Ofcourse, its your choice, if you want to rot in your hellhole called Afghanistan living under the thumb of minority Farsawan bacheybaz, then good on you, we will keep the border closed all this time.

I am forced to make another post because your Idea does not make any sense.

So we have a country named Afghanistan. Basically named after our ethnicity. National Language is Pashto. School etc. are in Pashto language. National anthem is in Pashto. The President is Pashtun. And we are biggest ethnic group in our country and we must give all that up to join Pakistan(A third world country that we can easily access and that does not really offer anything more then we are already used to) to become a minority with the biggest ethnic group 3-4 times our size. Our language we be demoted. Culture be demoted.. etc.

Bro I don't want to talk Pashto like a Gul Khan, please.

AND

Being the biggest ethnicity in Afghanistan, YET being under the thumb of minority Farsawan of northern alliance all these years.

who in the right frame of mind would like to compare the dusty and rotten Afghansitan with Paksitan? There are many Afghans who line up our border just to get treated in Pakistan. Many Afghans use Paksitani passport to travel aboard. You population is already dependent on Pakistan sunshine. Third world or first world, it doesnt matter, as we are a complete different world as compare to Afghanistan. Trust me, it will be huge upgrade from where you lot are.

Our KPK got more Pakhtoons then whole of your Afghansitan, hell, even Karachi got more Pakhtoons then in Kabul!!

 

[pakistani342]

Are you serious hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah.
Wake up of your dream. You have an unstable country that is more divided across ethnic lines then Afghanistan. You already lost Bangladesh. Kashmir is a lost cause. Balochis hate you. 40 millions Pashtuns are die hard Pakistanis hahaha I don't think there are so many Gul Khans.

We would rather happily die then be called Pakistanis. LOL.



I am forced to make another post because your Idea does not make any sense.

So we have a country named Afghanistan. Basically named after our ethnicity. National Language is Pashto. School etc. are in Pashto language. National anthem is in Pashto. The President is Pashtun. And we are biggest ethnic group in our country and we must give all that up to join Pakistan(A third world country that we can easily access and that does not really offer anything more then we are already used to) to become a minority with the biggest ethnic group 3-4 times our size. Our language we be demoted. Culture be demoted.. etc.

Bro I don't want to talk Pashto like a Gul Khan, please.

When speaking to a friend the other day he pointed out to a fundamental conflict between Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Afghan identity is defined by what is (supposedly) a proud history -- Pakistani identity is defined by what may (supposedly) be an illustrious future.

But history always gives way to the future -- history has always lost in the long term to the further.

Today the great grandson of Porus, Balkhi, is named Ashraf Ghani
Today the great grandson of Ravi, Ranjput is named Nawaz Sharif
...Thus History has already lost in Afghanistan and Pakistan
.....It has lost a little more in Pakistan than Afghanistan
.....But Afghanistan is not far behind.

The question is:
...Do Afghans want to be proud of Pashto or landing on the moon
...Do Pakistanis want to be proud of Pashto or landing on the moon
...Maybe they will answer both?
.....Ok (let's rephrase the question): what would you be rather proud of:
.......Pashto
.........--OR--
........landing on the moon
........sending a taskforce to save the survivors of a Tsunami
........curing cancer?
.....I just realized that today this question may just draw confusion.
.....But the day this question has a clear answer, a single country from Herat to Wagha would not be too far off.

Best of luck.

 

[.]

No thanks!

You are probably right but there can be gains made which bring stability for future and end proxies because once under Pakistan control.
Afghani territories would stop being the assembly point for all terrorist activities directed inside Pakistani borders.
No matter how much the afghans cry and ditch their frustrations on Pakistan and this thread,In the end it is their country that is fighting a civil war today and their own people.

 

[Kabira]

You are probably right but there can be gains made which bring stability for future and end proxies because once under Pakistan control.
Afghani territories would stop being the assembly point for all terrorist activities directed inside Pakistani borders.
No matter how much the afghans cry and ditch their frustrations on Pakistan and this thread,In the end it is their country that is fighting a civil war today and their own people.

Since you said distant future then who knows. First occupation needs to end. After that afghanis need to sit down and end civil war which doesn't look likely for another 40 years.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Need to absrob the whole region ..into Pakistan as Province and launch a offensive to tackle Terrorist head on

 

[.]

Need to absrob the whole region ..into Pakistan as Province and launch a offensive to tackle Terrorist head on

You should post those invasion plans of yours

 

[Sine Nomine]

When speaking to a friend the other day he pointed out to a fundamental conflict between Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Afghan identity is defined by what is (supposedly) a proud history -- Pakistani identity is defined by what may (supposedly) be an illustrious future.

But history always gives way to the future -- history has always lost in the long term to the further.

Today the great grandson of Porus, Balkhi, is named Ashraf Ghani
Today the great grandson of Ravi, Ranjput is named Nawaz Sharif
...Thus History has already lost in Afghanistan and Pakistan
.....It has lost a little more in Pakistan than Afghanistan
.....But Afghanistan is not far behind.

The question is:
...Do Afghans want to be proud of Pashto or landing on the moon
...Do Pakistanis want to be proud of Pashto or landing on the moon
...Maybe they will answer both?
.....Ok (let's rephrase the question): what would you be rather proud of:
.......Pashto
.........--OR--
........landing on the moon
........sending a taskforce to save the survivors of a Tsunami
........curing cancer?
.....I just realized that today this question may just draw confusion.
.....But the day this question has a clear answer, a single country from Herat to Wagha would not be too far off.

Best of luck.

Sir I agree with you,aftet extensively traveling for years and interacting with thousands of peoples,and analyzing current security situation in Af-Pak I have opinion that without capturing and cleaning that hell hole with brute force thinking of peace in Pakistan is utmost idiocy,as soon as US will leave,Talibans would be divided,central Govt will fall and fully equipped militias will unleash terror in Afghanistan and we willnot be save.