Pakistan will not apologise to Bangladesh: Qureshi

[salman nedian]

I mean, this is just sheer idiocy, isn't it? India was neutral in the '71 war! India was the country that covertly provoked the war and then JOINED and participated in the war.

Pakistan has held its side accountable..The Hamadoor Report (which was commissioned by a Bengali actually), did not find the Pakistan Army completely innocent, but the casualty figures were much closer the truth. It's time Bangladesh held its side accountable.

India should also answer that why it interfered in an independent country’s matter and they should be held responsible for all the attrocities committed by mukti Bahini as they were trained by the Indians.

 

[vish]

India should also answer that why it interfered in an independent country’s matter

What choice did we have besides interfering?

Your people-in-power screwed up their country themselves.

 

[salman nedian]

What choice did we have besides interfering?

Your people-in-power screwed up their country themselves.

IT was our internal matter if we screwed our people (according to you) still India had no right to interfere in our matter.

 

[vish]

IT was our internal matter if we screwed our people (according to you) still India had no right to interfere in our matter.

It became our concern when the millions of refugees started pouring in. Most of these were very pissed off and would have wrecked the law and order inside our territory.

 

[salman nedian]

It became our concern when the millions of refugees started pouring in. Most of these were very pissed off and would have wrecked the law and order inside our territory.

Indian army has been involved in human rights violations in Kashmir and hundreds and thousands of Kashmiris have migrated to azad Kashmir and Pakistan so should we take the same action?

The support of Mukti bahini by the Indians in East Pakistan way back in 1971 shows the Indian history of supporting cross border terrorism.

 

[vish]

Indian army has been involved in human rights violations in Kashmir and hundreds and thousands of Kashmiris have migrated to azad Kashmir and Pakistan so should we take the same action?

Haven't you tried that already? And failed at the same? The population of the Indian side of J&K is nowhere near as hostile as the one in the then East Pakistan.

Do provide me link with regard to this statement: "hundreds and thousands of Kashmiris have migrated to azad Kashmir."

The support of Mukti bahini by the Indians in East Pakistan way back in 1971 shows the Indian history of supporting cross border terrorism.

How long was Mukti Bahini active before the birth of Bangladesh?

Mukti Bahini became active after the conditions in the then East Pakistan deteriorated significantly and the outflow of refugees reached alarming levels.

 

[salman nedian]

Haven't you tried that already? And failed at the same? The population of the Indian side of J&K is nowhere near as hostile as the one in the then East Pakistan.

Do provide me link with regard to this statement: "hundreds and thousands of Kashmiris have migrated to azad Kashmir.".

It’s not the matter of passing or failing it’s the matter that Indian army has been involved in killings of Kashmiris come and see in azad kashmir that how many people have migrated from IOK.

How long was Mukti Bahini active before the birth of Bangladesh?

Mukti Bahini became active after the cons in the then East Pakistan deteriorated significantly and the outflow of refuditiongees reached alarming levels.

So you are claiming that Mukti bahini was formed overnight? No they were active before the operation ‘Search Light’ that’s why the operation took place.

 

[cactuslily58]

India should also answer that why it interfered in an independent country’s matter and they should be held responsible for all the attrocities committed by mukti Bahini as they were trained by the Indians.

Do you have to answer why you entered the territory of an belligerent ( then considered an enemy) once both have declared war on each other ?

As regards interference.. if no refugees had entered India ( & they were muslims too), India would not have bothered.

 

[vish]

It’s not the matter of passing or failing it’s the matter that Indian army has been involved in killings of Kashmiris come and see in azad kashmir that how many people have migrated from IOK.

Stop using the term IOK. I'm being civil, expect you to do the same.

I can't come to Pakistani side of J&K; please provide me a link.

So you are claiming that Mukti bahini was formed overnight? No they were active before the operation ‘Search Light’ that’s why the operation took place.

Operation Searchlight was launched to curb the nationalist sentiment among the Bengalis. Mukti Bahini gained strength after Operation Searchlight.

Was Mukti Bahini in significant presence prior to 1971? No. So your original claim is moot. We supported Mukti Bahini after things really hit the fan.

 

[salman nedian]

Do you have to answer why you entered the territory of an belligerent ( then considered an enemy) once both have declared war on each other ?

As regards interference.. if no refugees had entered India ( & they were muslims too), India would not have bothered.

An answer must be given for interfering in a sovereign and independent country.

 

[salman nedian]

Operation Searchlight was launched to curb the nationalist sentiment among the Bengalis. Mukti Bahini gained strength after Operation Searchlight.

Was Mukti Bahini in significant presence prior to 1971? No. So your original claim is moot. We supported Mukti Bahini after things really hit the fan.

Bengali separatists started their activities before operation search light with the help of India The main phase of Operation Searchlight ended with the fall of the last major town in Bengali hands in mid May which they captured with the support and training by Indian forces.

 

[vish]

Erred post; please delete this message; was unable to do so myself.

 

[vish]

Bengali separatists started their activities before operation search light with the help of India The main phase of Operation Searchlight ended with the fall of the last major town in Bengali hands in mid May which they captured with the support and training by Indian forces.

They did start their activities; but these picked up steam once Operation Searchlight was initiated. We effectively came into the picture "big-time" in the middle of Operation Searchlight as the flow of refugees had turned into a tsunami.

 

[salman nedian]

They did start their activities; but these picked up steam once Operation Searchlight was initiated. We effectively came into the picture "big-time" in the middle of Operation Searchlight as the flow of refugees had turned into a tsunami.

Good! Those activities by Mukti bahini were not in the interest of Pakistan so we started the operation and it was the help from India in the earlier stages that due to which operation was inevitable and which resulted in migration of separatists to West Bengal so all an all it was a game plan by India.

 

[vish]

Good! Those activities by Mukti bahini were not in the interest of Pakistan so we started the operation and it was the help from India in the earlier stages that due to which operation was inevitable and which resulted in migration of separatists to West Bengal so all an all it was a game plan by India.

How limited were these activities?... Well let me guess... Very.

Further, why were these activities taking place? They started off due to your the then government treating its own population as second class.

We were not there in the earliest stages; we came in much later; we did not "initiate" these.

Stop accusing India for your own country's mistake.