Pakistan, US agree on new Afghan set-up - India retreating?

[jarnee]

I think India is doing itself a favour. Think about it in another perspective, Already USA is planning to bring out troops in 2011 and USA I estimated about a Trillion waste on this war, and if India takes over trying to stabilize the country, it would affect your growing economy.This is how I see it, compared to other Pakistanis.

maybe you are right! ..its nonsense to get your people killed when its not your war. What ever development work India did has been wasted. now they will blow all the infrastructure they built.

Good time ..good sense prevailed. Phate mein tang adana is foolishness.

India should focus on development and ensuring our borders are safe.

 

[ek_indian]

I think India is doing itself a favour. Think about it in another perspective, Already USA is planning to bring out troops in 2011 and USA I estimated about a Trillion waste on this war, and if India takes over trying to stabilize the country, it would affect your growing economy.This is how I see it, compared to other Pakistanis.

Well....India always does what suits it best. So it has always done a favour to himself.
I understand USA may be leaving the country. However India is not involved in military operations there. USA spent all amount on war while India's mission was some development activities.

Technically India did a master stroke. If it stays there (for any time period) it is going to get influence. If it leaves it will get sympathy.
Also India does not seem to be in hurry as well.

India won't scale down missions in Afghanistan: Shiv Shankar Menon - dnaindia.com

 

[IMADreamer]

@jarnee: check ur post count

i m just telling you because you was the same person who was telling interesting story to "JHA" shahib..

2 email id .i hope you will not mind

 

[Spring Onion]

@
India is not engaged in any war there. So it is not direct party of any talk show. However I agree with you on wait and watch thing.

since long Indians have been trying to become a party wherein they are not supposed to be a party from any aspect

 

[ek_indian]

since long Indians have been trying to become a party wherein they are not supposed to be a party from any aspect

India has always said it would not send its army for any war. It has only deployed paramilitary personals that too for securing ongoing construction work, consulates etc.

 

[ameer219]

maybe you are right! ..its nonsense to get your people killed when its not your war. What ever development work India did has been wasted. now they will blow all the infrastructure they built.

Good time ..good sense prevailed. Phate mein tang adana is foolishness.

Well if you are happy, I am happy bro.

Well....India always does what suits it best. So it has always done a favour to himself.
I understand USA may be leaving the country. However India is not involved in military operations there. USA spent all amount on war while India's mission was some development activities.

Technically India did a master stroke. If it stays there (for any time period) it is going to get influence. If it leaves it will get sympathy.
Also India does not seem to be in hurry as well.

India should focus on development and ensuring our borders are safe.

Well,that is what I was thinking too, but I do not want Indians to take this as a defeat of any sort. I mean they still have infrastructure there.

Hmm, I know they do not have military operations there,but I am sure they have some military men guarding the infrastructure right ek_indian?

 

[ek_indian]

Well,that is what I was thinking too, but I do not want Indians to take this as a defeat of any sort. I mean they still have infrastructure there.

Hmm, I know they do not have military operations there,but I am sure they have some military men guarding the infrastructure right ek_indian?

I agree with you.

 

[equiliz3r]

Bring them back home...............Let Pakistan do all development work

 

[blueoval79]

Just a discussion going on in the foreign office and they make a news of it......India diplomacy is not stupid enough to back out of Afghanistan.....it gives strategic advantage..... let terrorists explode more of themselves to thwart Indian efforts.....the only thing happening here is strengthening of pro India lobby in Afghanistan and Western Countries..... I'd say...go India go....stay there for as long possible and leverage this in world community.

 

[Spring Onion]

Just a discussion going on in the foreign office and they make a news of it......India diplomacy is not stupid enough to back out of Afghanistan.....it gives strategic advantage..... let terrorists explode more of themselves to thwart Indian efforts.....the only thing happening here is strengthening of pro India lobby in Afghanistan and Western Countries..... I'd say...go India go....stay there for as long possible and leverage this in world community.

aahh at last someone accepted the reality of strategic interests by India

 

[Cheetah786]

Bring them back home...............Let Pakistan do all development work

Dont let the door hit ya on the *** on your way out.


ameer219

Well,that is what I was thinking too, but I do not want Indians to take this as a defeat of any sort. I mean they still have infrastructure there

.

which part of india you are from

 

[BATMAN]

Bring them back home...............Let Pakistan do all development work

This would bring an end to child kidnapping, fake marriages, drugs and organ trade.

Previously all reconstruction contracts worth billions of dollars had been awarded to indina army engineering wing without inviting any third country.
So far US has sent billions to Afghan re-construction but indians build poor quality temporary buildings..... with no inspection record by independent certified technical authorities.

An independent body should be formed to review all the technical details of buildings and raods.

 

[ambidex]

Its a good news if true, it further prooves that we were there to help Afghanistan nothing else. Its a good move we can not risk indian citizen's life. The pressure will be on other side that is why they will not accept victory. I would like to see peace! prevailing in that region specially in pakistan after when india will halt its mission.
Soon we will see pakistanis blamming USA for all its problems when India will leave AF.
Good move India should fast track all pending assignment and leave ASAP.

 

[Speaker]

aahh at last someone accepted the reality of strategic interests by India

I think you've missed entire threads discussing the strategic importance of India or Pakistan's relationship with Afghanistan. The important question is whether the strategy tends towards brute power or soft power. India never had much of physical presence in Afghanistan (as no foreign country should). But our imprints on Afghanistan's future are indelible. Call it wishful thinking, only development can win in Afghanistan.

I am sure even if we leave the country, Pakistan will not blow up the infrastructure we built (not that Afghanistan will allow them!). Our military exchanges would not cease. Our trade relationship will not cease. Our cultural exchanges will not cease. Then what other strategic influence could a country want?

 

[ameer219]

which part of india you are from

Listen here Kid, just because I am neutral on this you keep thinking I am Indian???

Just to let you know, I am Pakistani mix with a little Indian and Chinese.

After posting a lot of threads of Pakistan Economy, and always trying to make this two country to go along hand in hand, you accuse me to be a Indian?

If you have read all my posts, you would have known that I support Pakistan more than I do for India, and yet you still claim I am from India?

I am much more proud to be a Pakistani as my forefathers came from Rawalpindi!

I am a Singaporean Pakistani, and proud to be one, so don't tell me where I am from and What I am not, and what is worst, coming from a senior member like you accusing me of being Indian is worst