Pakistan to deport Afghan refugees

[Flame]

no country in the world sacrificed so much for the Afghan people (or any other refugee worldwide)

maybe China did to North Koreans; maybe Syria or Jordan took some Iraqi refugees; in Iran, Afghan refugees are ''contained'' in designated mohallas and their movements traced


in Pakistan, they are allowed to roam wherever they please....


I'm not complaining necessarily, but I am making a point. We have been a very generous nation, and at times we get back-stabbed

Oh look who is complaining about getting stabbed in the back? I didn't get that, please try it again?

 

[Flame]

Send these afghans back to where they belong, all of these ungrateful dirtbags need be deported

What is with the dirty langauge. I can stand right next to you for a challenge.

 

[alibaz]

I think Afghan refugees should start going back to Afghanistan. Till the time they dont go back and fight their enemy out, may it be Taliban or US whoever they consider as their enemy. Nothing is going to change. Now Afghan land is available to all forces who want to show their muscles. IMO that should not be the case.

 

[ice_man]

well i think its a simple thing! YOU wish to live in PAKISTAN then consider yourself pakistani! swear an oath on pakistan live for pakistan die for pakistan!

if your allegiance lies with Afghanistan then please cross over and live their we will escort you across!

 

[Jacobtheindoamerican]

Like we need to deport illegal Bangladeshis.. Pakistan should do this.

 

[EagleEyes]

Those who are anti-Pakistan need to leave. Those who are pro-Pak they can live with us together. They can be as any Pakistani as a Pakistani can be.

 

[nForce]

Pakistan to deport Afghan refugees....The question is how many.It is an important question,as there are way too many Afghan refugees in Pakistan.Some were even born in camps in Pakistan.Needless to say, the exodus has been a massive blow to Pakistan's economy.It will be a hell of a task to achieve the objective.

 

[KS]

One Question:

Can Pakistan deport the Afghans..?

I have heard that tribal/clan loyalties are of utmost importance to the Pashtuns and will they react nicely if an Afghan national of the same clan is forcefully deported..?

 

[Sinnerman108]

One Question:

Can Pakistan deport the Afghans..?

I have heard that tribal/clan loyalties are of utmost importance to the Pashtuns and will they react nicely if an Afghan national of the same clan is forcefully deported..?

It does not make sense to deport;
there will be no deportation exercise;
all of this is just war of words with no action intended.

 

[Ahmad]

Those who are anti-Pakistan need to leave. Those who are pro-Pak they can live with us together. They can be as any Pakistani as a Pakistani can be.

Well, i think you need to deport them altoghter then.

 

[Sinnerman108]

You guys need to stop all this indignation of Afghans at a chance that makes you guys feel good and some kind of lords of Asia. Seriously what is with this arraogance coming from you Pakistanis. From what what I have gathered there are about three catogories of Afghans who live in Pakistan. 1) The wealthy business class who have inter-Afghan-Pakistan business, or in Pakistan or any other country but have chosen to live there (which is allowed anywhere in the world and you guys should be happy that some one wants to live there out of choice), 2) are Afghans who live in their own autonomous camps established since the time of Jihad which is a strategic conduit of Pakistani involvement and strategic extention in the form of political influence and espcially in the current context of sending brainwashed militants to Afghanistan, 3) are the ones you guys are abusing here who mostly live in Pashtunkhwa, may be some of them in other parts of Pakistan, and I don't know about their socio-economic stratification. I am in full agreement that Afghans should go back to Afghhanistan, but I am also aware that the current situation as it is wont offer the incentives for all these Afghans that you people want to kick out from your country. Regardless of how much you people want to clear out Pakistan from Afghans and how much I don't like seeing Pakistanis taking professional jobs and also taking million dollars contracts of building Kabul streets and roads, such will be the case and will remain so unless the countries are removed apart to opposite hemispheres of the globe, which I would also much desire. At the end of the day this will carry on, as long as it is those billions of dollars Pakistani exports are flowing to Afghanistan and beyond, which would remain to offer best potential of growth to major Pakistani industries and economy in general - and hence the status quo. I think it might be some of these bloody Afghans who facilitate this trade. And as long as this sort of interaction persist, I would see those bloody Pakistani also in Afghanistan, though not in the number that Afghans are in Pakistan. Hopefully, when things settle down in Afghanistan, believe me you wont see them in Pakistan again.

And I read somewhere that AFghans have brought with them prostitution to the highly culturered and affluent imperial Pakistan which you guys seem to represent in your high words and language. Have they really brought prostituion to Pakistan? Come on for god's sake! Did Afghans open the Heera-Mandai red light district of Lahore, where you guys along with those prostitues used to serve the Angreez masters?

On the other hand, I think Afghans still consider Pashtunkhwa as our ancesteral land, last I checked the border is not even recognised. I have more in common with a person in Quetta and Waziristan than may be most people from Panjab and Sind has, and that will be hardly changed.

Are you willing to stand by your words and are you going to debate the fall out ?

Will you be in a position to change your mind set in the face of argument ?

 

[Flame]

I am open for a debate, you go ahead. On the other hand my position is clear: Afghans should be repatriated and reintegrated back in Afghanistan. I welcome any pressure in this regard from Pakistan, no matter what the motivation. On the top of that I think the government of Afghanistan and Paksitan should work together in this regard, and the end the government of Afghanistan owes Pakistan a big thank you and should also extend its own gesture. This is my own thinking, may be it is ldealistic on my part. Therefore as such Pakistan should seriously curb on militant and terrorist that would stall this aim. Pakistan shoud immediately take it fingers out of the Afghan issues, for the best. Other then that, things can only get worse from bad and will breath more problems on a differnt scale.

 

[True_Pakistan_Zindabad]

For the entirety of our shared existence, Afghanistan has never imposed itself on Pakistan or our internal affairs. This is one point worth considering. However we will not allow Afghanistan to be a springboard for enemies of Pakistanis. This is also something to really memorize.

 

[Flame]

For the entirety of our shared existence, Afghanistan has never imposed itself on Pakistan or our internal affairs. This is one point worth considering. However we will not allow Afghanistan to be a springboard for enemies of Pakistanis. This is also something to really memorize.

I think any attitude of Afghanistan should be summed up within the highlighted part, I think it is a good riddle combined. Afghanistan has alot of shared interest in having fhealthy relaitonship with Pakistan, I am not going to repeat myself again. I thought youir were the humbled and sensible one. As I said Pakistan should immediately take its fingers out of the Afghan pot. Cease your involvement in the form of terrorits and other subvereive activities. Earn your trust from the Afghan side too. If Afghanistan choses to be your enemy and to a spring board then it will do so just like how Pakistan is is a spring board for the enmies of Afghanistan. You guys here are out of your mind.

 

[True_Pakistan_Zindabad]

If Afghanistan choses to be your enemy and to a spring board then it will do so just like how Pakistan is is a spring board for the enmies of Afghanistan. You guys here are out of your mind.

Bro I made that statement to show some solidarity. Now you go off and twist the rest of my words. ? Typical Afghan move, take the good gesture but return it with a knife to the back.

I know your country very well, trust me.