What's new

Pakistan to ban encryption software

fd24

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Messages
5,864
Reaction score
0
Pakistan internet cafe

Millions of internet users in Pakistan will be unable to send emails and messages without fear of government snooping after authorities banned the use of encryption software.

A legal notice sent to all internet providers (ISPs) by the Pakistan Telecommunications Authority, seen by the Guardian, orders the ISPs to inform authorities if any of their customers are using virtual private networks (VPNs) to browse the web.

Virtual private networks allow internet users to connect to the web undetected, meaning that they can access banned websites and send emails without fear of government interception.

Pakistan's 20 million internet users have previously been banned from popular social networks, such as Facebook, because of blasphemous material about the prophet Muhammad. All internet traffic in the country travels through the Pakistan Internet Exchange, which can be intercepted by the military and civil intelligence agencies. The move echoes a crackdown against encrypted communications across the border in India and in China.

The Pakistan Telecommunications Authority legal notice urged ISPs to report customers using "all such mechanisms including EVPNs [encrypted virtual private networks] which conceal communication to the extent that prohibits monitoring". Anyone needing to use this technology needs to apply for special permission, the notice said.

Authorities in Islamabad insisted that the ban on VPN access was intended to stem communications by terrorists.

However, banks, call centres and many other businesses use encrypted connections to communicate with their branches and customers, to protect sensitive data such as account numbers and passwords.

"This is like banning cars because suicide bombers use them," said Shakir Husain, chief executive of Creative Chaos, a Karachi-based software company. "You have to find out who these guys [extremists] are. This is a blanket, knee-jerk, response."

There is strict regulation of internet traffic in Pakistan. Last year, the authorities banned the entire Facebook website for months after a user launched a contest to draw a cartoon of the prophet Muhammad. Accessing the internet on BlackBerry smartphones is problematic, because of the device's high-security encryption software.

Recently the regulator made it impossible for Pakistanis to access the website of Rolling Stone magazine, after it published an article on the high proportion of the national budget in Pakistan that goes on its military.

Josh Halliday and Saeed Shah in Lahore
guardian.co.uk,
 
.
This will hit IT industry in Pakistan as many clients want a dedicated Encrypted VPN network.
 
.
No Foreign Tech Company worth it's name will invest in Pakistan because they won't risk transferring their financial data and other information over open links which can be easily intercepted.The situation is already bad for Pakistani Internet Bossiness men looks like PTA is screwing it up even further.
 
.
I remember a few Pakistanis saying Pakistan will take away chunks of India IT sector away in next 5 years. Lets see if that happens.
 
. .
That is crazy! Are they going to ban SSL as well which most of the email providers use i.e. Google, hotmail etc?
If that is the case; its heaven for hackers :woot:
 
.
Somebody needs to explain the term "hackers" and "hacking" to Pakistan Telecommunications Authority.
 
.
If I am not very much mistaken,the US govt. also does similar kind of snooping.
Can anyone clarify?
 
.
Nothing wrong with banning normal people using encryption

Who the f ... uses encryption unless they have something to hide , they stated that legal business entities will be able to use encryption with a permit (businesses , banks , financial transactions)

Rest will be banned so they are easily spotted and this will prevent Spies/terrorist/Americans to use encryption to send emails from US embassy to other terrrorist
 
.
Nothing wrong with banning normal people using encryption

Who the f ... uses encryption unless they have something to hide , they stated that legal business entities will be able to use encryption with a permit (businesses , banks , financial transactions)

Rest will be banned so they are easily spotted and this will prevent Spies/terrorist/Americans to use encryption to send emails from US embassy to other terrrorist
Banning encryption totally will increase chances of hacking in to your personal accounts.That means,if you are a facebook user,then there is a pretty good chance that a hacker may take control of your account and make wrong use of your personal information.Same goes for emails.We not only exchange funny pictures but also sensitive information through emails.

So,yes,its a weird step for govt of Pakistan.May be they should have asked the service providers to provide access to the data.
 
.
The stated the ban is for encrypting your email if you are not a bank or other important entity no point Ramond Davis being able to encrypt his message to terrorist

It would be easier to search text that is not encrypted for key words that promote terrorism and espionage

Specially US embassy's email to Terrorist cells operating in Pakistan

Average Pakistan only send email to friends and he has nothing to fear from encryption or none encryption the fear is from Spy networks operating using encryption and sett-elite phones

Like the ones Ramond davis was caught with
 
.
Banning encryption totally will increase chances of hacking in to your personal accounts.That means,if you are a facebook user,then there is a pretty good chance that a hacker may take control of your account and make wrong use of your personal information.Same goes for emails.We not only exchange funny pictures but also sensitive information through emails.

So,yes,its a weird step for govt of Pakistan.May be they should have asked the service providers to provide access to the data.
I don't think they are only banning VPN"s not SSL because if they BAN SSL then how will Banks operate and other critical financial institutions?
 
.
Virtually impossible to do this btw.

Maybe its only aimed at the non-commercial users and its impossible to do it there too.
 
.
this is bullsh1t as thousands of organisation connect using VPN with their head offices for accounting and sensitive information sharing. Millions of tele-workers use VPN, and Banks solely operate on VPN for security reasons. Banning VPN is impractical and idiotic which can only be expected from an illetrete like Rehman Nai. Secondly, VPN does not equal encryption and thirdly there is no way to detect an actual encryption software at the ISP side.
 
.
I don't see how it will be enforceable unless Pakistan plans on creating a massive enforcement authority. Which they will then need the budget to support.

And even then there are ways for people to send encrypted communications without being detected.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom