Pakistan Textbooks Acknowledge Role of Minorities

[nForce]

Read about 1946 elections...

Make the point, provide the statistics. Don't just say read this and that.

1.Pakistan built first small reactor in 1960,SUPARCO did On 7 June 1962, SUPARCO landed a record achievement when it launched first unmanned solid-fuel sounding rocket and took its first initial space flight from the Sonmiani Terminal Launch.
2.First steel mill at Chittagong East Pakistan and second at Karachi with 26 manu units.
3.Pakistan produced electric locomotives with help from Japan.
Joke of century kid no country can run fully on foreign Aid even today Aid makes up 1% of our budget and saudis saw economic boom only after 80's and still we have better living standard then Bhartis...

I will not make a shoulder to shoulder comparison here, because that is futile and also makes us all drift from the topic.

Try to drop the high handedness, because it definitely does not suit you, neither is it a point-earning factor in a discussion.

It is a nice thing which you quote a few good things about your country and I appreciate it. But, will just go straight ahead and tell me what is the point that you are trying to make ?

 

[Sine Nomine]

Make the point, provide the statistics. Don't just say read this and that.

Indian provincial elections, 1946 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
they AIML was in better position after 1937 and got huge votes in 1946 election.

 

[nForce]

Indian provincial elections, 1946 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
they AIML was in better position after 1937 and got huge votes in 1946 election.

If you look closely, you will notice there was hardly any place where the Muslim League had majority. So, the voting was mainly on sectarian lines only and not on any other issues. I don't see how that can be a good thing.

 

[Sine Nomine]

If you look closely, you will notice there was hardly any place where the Muslim League had majority. So, the voting was mainly on sectarian lines only and not on any other issues. I don't see how that can be a good thing.

elaborate......

 

[nForce]

elaborate......

You need to know when to use the word 'please' . What's wrong with your manners ?

My specific point is, you take part in an election with an agenda. Now, that agenda, for a political party is usually based around betterment of the society. If the agenda of the political party is liked by the common people, they get a majority.

Now Muslim League did not get majority in any of the states. So, how did they get the votes. They got the vote on face-value, being 'Muslim' and that's why they got a larger number of votes in Bengal, which had vast Muslim majority at that time. Moreover, the figures more or less follow the graph of Muslim populations in those states. Now, one must be wondering, what were they voting for ? It was blindly on the basis of religion only and not on any other party agenda. Hence the results were biased.

 

[macnurv]

Partition was never necessary. It was Jinnah's ego all along. There cannot be any other reason. His argument that Muslims cannot live in a Hindu majority India has already been rebutted by the fact that India has more Muslim population than Pakistan and they are doing quite well. Muslims are well represented in Indian society.
And the famous two-nation theory went for a toss when Bangladesh was created.

It's funny, because now Pakistan exists just not to be India.What kind of existence is that ?

What a half assed attempt to rewrite history, nothing better is expected of you. Jinnahs argument has been validated time and time again, and his original argument was never about just surviving but about equality.

Changed the minds of Muslims of India ?
Are you even thinking ? Muslims of India were not even organized together. All the decisions were being taken by a few elite families who had vested personal interests. And that, is exactly what gave rise to long-standing feudalism in Pakistan.

As always, short-sighted. You economy was always hollow from inside. Tell me what was your chief export in those days ? What was the scientific progress ? How many Iron & steel manufacturing plants you have constructed on your own ? Do you produce your own rail engines ? How many automobile industries are there in Pakistan that manufacture their own cars and bikes ? The reality is not even a moped engine has been designed in Pakistan.

The country used to run on American money and Saudi money. They Americans needed you because they wanted to use that airbase in Peshawar and to use you as a shield against the advent of the Soviets. You need to see the bigger picture here. Holistic, organic and self-sustaining progress & development.. you never saw it.

HAHAHAHA, now you cant challenge that logic after all they were flying spaceships 10,000 years ago.

 

[nForce]

What a half assed attempt to rewrite history, nothing better is expected of you. Jinnahs argument has been validated time and time again, and his original argument was never about just surviving but about equality.

The East Pakistanis did not get equality, which is why they created a separate nation for themselves, hence debunking the theory.

HAHAHAHA, now you cant challenge that logic after all they were flying spaceships 10,000 years ago.

With poor comprehension power, comes great responsibilities. The most important among them is not to open your mouth when you don't know head or tail you are talking about.

 

[wiseone2]

Partition was never necessary. It was Jinnah's ego all along. There cannot be any other reason. His argument that Muslims cannot live in a Hindu majority India has already been rebutted by the fact that India has more Muslim population than Pakistan and they are doing quite well. Muslims are well represented in Indian society.
And the famous two-nation theory went for a toss when Bangladesh was created.

It's funny, because now Pakistan exists just not to be India.What kind of existence is that ?

there are a lot of countries with interesting demographics. India and Pakistan are just one pair.
Malaysia/Singapore
Burundi/Rwanda

What a half assed attempt to rewrite history, nothing better is expected of you. Jinnahs argument has been validated time and time again, and his original argument was never about just surviving but about equality.

East Pakistanis were never given their share. You would think if someone cared about equality they would have gone out of the way to be sensitive to the demands of East Pakistanis. Their demands were pretty benign in the beginning.
That debunks your theme about equality

Urdu speaking elite in India were the biggest proponents of Pakistan. IMO they were clueless, did not care about their community and power hungry. Nothing else explains their actions.

Of course they are other villains in the whole drama.

 

[salarsikander]

East Pakistanis were never given their share. You would think if someone cared about equality they would have gone out of the way to be sensitive to the demands of East Pakistanis. Their demands were pretty benign in the beginning.
That debunks your theme about equality

Urdu speaking elite in India were the biggest proponents of Pakistan. IMO they were clueless, did not care about their community and power hungry. Nothing else explains their actions.

Of course they are other villains in the whole drama.

Hi,
IMO youre just as clueless as you said Urdu speakers are.

Like i have said to you many times, reading something on news is quite actually different from reality.

Unless you have experienced reality, you're in no position of commenting on it

 

[nForce]

Hi,
IMO youre just as clueless as you said Urdu speakers are.

Like i have said to you many times, reading something on news is quite actually different from reality.

Unless you have experienced reality, you're in no position of commenting on it

You seem to be speaking without any prejudice.We would very much like to hear your point. Can you please elaborate ?

 

[salarsikander]

You seem to be speaking without any prejudice.We would very much like to hear your point. Can you please elaborate ?

Hi,
theres no point on sharing my point here with you guys, the fact that i replied to guy who is just interested in trolling, he's been owned several times.

Secondly what matters here, does it concern you guys?

 

[nForce]

Hi,
theres no point on sharing my point here with you guys, the fact that i replied to guy who is just interested in trolling, hes been owned several times.

Secondly what matters here, does it concern you guys?

You don't really have to be so pessimistic about it.
To answer your question, no, it does not really concern us, or me in particular. It's your country, your rules, and nothing really objectionable is going on there. So to speak, I am not concerned, interested rather.

 

[salarsikander]

You don't really have to be so pessimistic about it.
To answer your question, no, it does not really concern us, or me in particular. It's your country, your rules, and nothing really objectionable is going on there. So to speak, I am not concerned, interested rather.

Hi,
Too much curiosity can kill.
I would love to know the nature or intention of this 'interest'. Unsurprisingly every Indian is very much interested in Pakistani affairs, I wonder why?
Some even have claim to know lot more about Pakistani then us pakistani themselves you know.

The very 'Interest' in our affair is what is putting me off to have a decent discussion with you.

Because i can see that how the thread has been ruined to score brownie points

 

[nForce]

Hi,
Too much curiosity can kill.
I would love to know the nature or intention of this 'interest'. Unsurprisingly every Indian is very much interested in Pakistani affairs, I wonder why?
Some even have claim to know lot more about Pakistani then us pakistani themselves you know.

The very 'Interest' in our affair is what is putting me off to have a decent discussion with you.

Because i can see that how the thread has been ruined to score brownie points

Not building much trust here, are we.. Well that's alright.

You feel sore, because you believe some people, like me, have ruined the thread to score brownie points. Well let me apologize first. But do try to understand that it goes both ways.
So far as the interest is concerned, well this is a Pakistan centric forum and hence the topics are as such. I am also part of a forum where they discuss about model aviation, there is a cooking forum and a trekking related closed-user-group forum. They don't have topics related to Pakistan. Getting the point here ?

 

[salarsikander]

Not building much trust here, are we.. Well that's alright.

You feel sore, because you believe some people, like me, have ruined the thread to score brownie points. Well let me apologize first. But do try to understand that it goes both ways.
So far as the interest is concerned, well this is a Pakistan centric forum and hence the topics are as such. I am also part of a forum where they discuss about model aviation, there is a cooking forum and a trekking related closed-user-group forum. They don't have topics related to Pakistan. Getting the point here ?

Hi,
very gullible indeed.
i see more indian on pakistani specific threads than on any other. especially after Eco corridor news the rear end was most of member was very sore.

especially the member that i quoter earlier i swell known troll here