Pakistan set to move WB against Indian power plants

[third eye]

Here we go ... again

Pakistan set to move WB against Indian power plants

LAHORE - The government is all set to move the Word Bank in a week after India ignored its call for mutual agreement on appointment of a neutral expert to decide the fate of two hydel power plants in Occupied Kashmir.

Despite serious opposition by Pakistan, India sped up construction work on both the projects, official sources told The Nation.

Indus Water Commission of Pakistan has been raising serious objection to the design of 330MW Kishanganga Hydroelectric Project (KEHP) and 850MW Ratle Hydroelectric Plant (RHEP). Fed up with the delaying tactics of India, Pakistan wrote a letter on July 24, proposing appointment of an international expert to decide the matter.

However, New Delhi did not bother to reply to Pakistan’s call while the work on both the projects is in full swing, officials of the water sector aware of the developments said.

It is mandatory for the World Bank, being the broker of the Indus Water Treaty, to appoint an expert on the request of Pakistan and give verdict on the matter.

Pakistan had lost the case of Baglihar Dam because of its failure to raise objection to the design parameters of the project before the start of the construction work on it, but India would not get a similar benefit in international arbitration in case of KHEP and RHEP as Indus Water Commission officials have evidence of repeated correspondence with their counterparts in India, raising objections to the designs of the water sites.
Kishanganga project is designed to divert water from the Kishanganga River to a power plant in the River Jhelum basin. It is located 5km north of Bandipore in Occupied Kashmir. Ratle project is located in the River Chenab basin.

Besides the two projects, Pakistan had expressed concern over the design of three other projects being built by India on River Chenab. These projects are: 1,000MW Pakal Dul, 120MW Miyar and 48MW Lower Kalnai.
In 2010, Pakistan appealed to The Hague’s court against the construction of KHEP. However, India was given a go-ahead for the construction of the dam by the court in December 20, 2013.

But this time Pakistan is moving against the design of the project which is not meeting the treaty’s requirements.

“We have objection to the depth of spillways of the Kishanganga and other dams at the Chenab River as India cannot do this under the Indus Water Treaty,” said the sources in water commission.

When asked, the Indus water commissioner confirmed that they were moving the World Bank within a short span of time. However, despite serious objections to the designs, the Pakistani side is still willing to resume the talks on three other controversial projects, he added. He stated that Pakistan’s point of view on the two sites was very clear and hoped it would win the case.

Water experts believe that apart from adverse impact to be caused by the Kishanganga dam on Pakistan’s irrigation system and energy sector schemes, it would have a devastating effect on biodiversity and ecosystem in Neelum Valley. It is being considered the proposed projects of India would drastically impact the water flows in the Chenab and the Jhelum rivers which irrigate most of the land in Pakistan.

 

[asquare]

Here we go ... again

Pakistan set to move WB against Indian power plants

I'm not supporting India's stand, I don't know enough about this to know who's right, but World Bank can't do any thing about it. India is the World Bank's biggest client by a huge margin. Already this year, several new Bank project proposals have been rejected by the government and, as a result, the Bank is falling way behind its disbursement targets. So if there is an feeling that India is in the wrong, the Bank will just delay or avoid any proceedings on the matter. Despite Jim Kim meeting Modi twice last year, the government has been turning down Bank projects and the Bank is very worried.

 

[Umair Nawaz]

That beautiful Neelum Valley is at risk, what a shame.

 

[[Bregs]]

The project height and release of water would be as per the treaty otherwise India won't take gamble of investing 100's of crores into these projects. These are running water projects with not depending upon on the sabotage water hydel dams because these rives are 12 months running with plenty of water so need of storing water and creating scarcity in pakistan areas

 

[Razia Sultana]

It is mandatory for the World Bank, being the broker of the Indus Water Treaty, to appoint an expert on the request of Pakistan and give verdict on the matter.

Wow! a broker of a water treaty has a right to give a verdict to two sovereign nations even 65 years after brokering.

 

[volcano]

That beautiful Neelum Valley is at risk, what a shame.

Neelum valley is in pakistan or india???

 

[Srinivas]

India gave the water treaty to Pakistan. Between India and China there is none and China is building more dams.

Pakistanis can go to WB but nothing will come out of it, It is a mutual agreement between two countries.

 

[Echo_419]

Here we go ... again

Pakistan set to move WB against Indian power plants

LAHORE - The government is all set to move the Word Bank in a week after India ignored its call for mutual agreement on appointment of a neutral expert to decide the fate of two hydel power plants in Occupied Kashmir.

Despite serious opposition by Pakistan, India sped up construction work on both the projects, official sources told The Nation.

Indus Water Commission of Pakistan has been raising serious objection to the design of 330MW Kishanganga Hydroelectric Project (KEHP) and 850MW Ratle Hydroelectric Plant (RHEP). Fed up with the delaying tactics of India, Pakistan wrote a letter on July 24, proposing appointment of an international expert to decide the matter.

However, New Delhi did not bother to reply to Pakistan’s call while the work on both the projects is in full swing, officials of the water sector aware of the developments said.

It is mandatory for the World Bank, being the broker of the Indus Water Treaty, to appoint an expert on the request of Pakistan and give verdict on the matter.

Pakistan had lost the case of Baglihar Dam because of its failure to raise objection to the design parameters of the project before the start of the construction work on it, but India would not get a similar benefit in international arbitration in case of KHEP and RHEP as Indus Water Commission officials have evidence of repeated correspondence with their counterparts in India, raising objections to the designs of the water sites.
Kishanganga project is designed to divert water from the Kishanganga River to a power plant in the River Jhelum basin. It is located 5km north of Bandipore in Occupied Kashmir. Ratle project is located in the River Chenab basin.

Besides the two projects, Pakistan had expressed concern over the design of three other projects being built by India on River Chenab. These projects are: 1,000MW Pakal Dul, 120MW Miyar and 48MW Lower Kalnai.
In 2010, Pakistan appealed to The Hague’s court against the construction of KHEP. However, India was given a go-ahead for the construction of the dam by the court in December 20, 2013.

But this time Pakistan is moving against the design of the project which is not meeting the treaty’s requirements.

“We have objection to the depth of spillways of the Kishanganga and other dams at the Chenab River as India cannot do this under the Indus Water Treaty,” said the sources in water commission.

When asked, the Indus water commissioner confirmed that they were moving the World Bank within a short span of time. However, despite serious objections to the designs, the Pakistani side is still willing to resume the talks on three other controversial projects, he added. He stated that Pakistan’s point of view on the two sites was very clear and hoped it would win the case.

Water experts believe that apart from adverse impact to be caused by the Kishanganga dam on Pakistan’s irrigation system and energy sector schemes, it would have a devastating effect on biodiversity and ecosystem in Neelum Valley. It is being considered the proposed projects of India would drastically impact the water flows in the Chenab and the Jhelum rivers which irrigate most of the land in Pakistan.

We don't give a flying fook about this

India gave the water treaty to Pakistan. Between India and China there is none and China is building more dams.

Pakistanis can go to WB but nothing will come out of it, It is a mutual agreement between two countries.

Agreed the Pakistanis are wasting their time & money