Pakistan Navy forces out an armed Indian Submarine from Pakistani waters.

[SrNair]

@waz @Irfan Baloch @WebMaster @WAJsal
@Oscar @Jango
I have posted only one post in this thread.Neither I derailed nor trolled this thread ,And my reply was just on the basis of info I got from PDF .Nor I insult anyone .
But this think tank gave me a negative rating for nothing.
So I am done in this PDF .
Will you delete my profile ?
Or where should I apply for it ?
Not interested in continuing in here .

 

[Skyliner]

Have a look pls.
is it possible that it was a Israeli 209 Dolphin class.
it looks more identical to our video.

@HRK @Basel @Irfan Baloch @MastanKhan @Oscar @saiyan0321

Dolphin II Class

Dolphin I class

 

[The Eagle]

@waz @Irfan Baloch @WebMaster @WAJsal
@Oscar @Jango
I have posted only one post in this thread.Neither I derailed nor trolled this thread ,And my reply was just on the basis of info I got from PDF .Nor I insult anyone .
But this think tank gave me a negative rating for nothing.
So I am done in this PDF .
Will you delete my profile ?
Or where should I apply for it ?
Not interested in continuing in here .

I don't think so this the right place to complain in-case of any, so better have your say at GHQ where none other than you and Mods can discuss the matter and would be sorted out if it is about -tive or anything else.

 

[danger007]

IN chief already denied anything like this happened calling it basless.

2nd question is what is an indian submarine doing at persicope depth in enemy waters???Thats suicidal and no trained navy would do that.It negates the entire concept of stealth.

Finally,the persicope arrangement seen in the one black and white photo they released doesn't match either the indian kilo class,or sindhughosh class or the akula but is very similar to the agosta 90B class.So either they mistook their own submarine or this is a deliberate stunt to secure more funds from the army dominated budget.

It doesn't match with Indian subs but am not sure how are these guys jumping into conclusion.. They don't even know what they have chased..


Am amazed to see their argument.. On one side they dragging Hinduism and Abusing country and the other side, they are accusing Indians trolling. Am unable to decide who is trolling.. Why not some one post a pic of Indian sub periscope- snorkel.. Penguin already posted those pics..

This is Type-209.

View attachment 353496


This is Kilo.

View attachment 353499

now compare it with following.


View attachment 353503

Where did it match?

 

[Khafee]

Have a look pls.
is it possible that it was a Israeli 209 Dolphin class.
it looks more identical to our video.

@HRK @Basel @Irfan Baloch @MastanKhan @Oscar @saiyan0321

Dolphin II Class

Dolphin I class

Absolutely not. Compare the placements of the periscope and the snorkel, different layout.

 

[Sneaker]

this few lines has shown how much you know about the UNCLOS ..... and how carefully you read.

NOW I REPEAT DON NOT REPEAT THAT BULLISH AGAIN .....

Well, have you read sections 50 to 55 and 87?

 

[danger007]

Absolutely not. Compare the placements of the periscope and the snorkel, different layout.

Does it match to Indian submarine..


Penguin already posted those pucs..

https://defence.pk/threads/pakistan...ubmarine-from-pakistani-waters.461722/page-37

 

[HRK]

Well, have you read sections 50 to 55 and 87?

plz go & read those Articles you have quoted & all of your posts ..... after that read my post carefully don't quote me unnecessarily ....

 

[SrNair]

I don't think so this the right place to complain in-case of any, so better have your say at GHQ where none other than you and Mods can discuss the matter and would be sorted out if it is about -tive or anything else.

Thank You

 

[danger007]

Wow ... 48 pages ... Indian (& Zionist) trolls out here in full force ...

So, barking dog seldom bites..

ch ch ch ch ch ch,,,
I can see you sad,
even when you smile,
even when you laugh,
I can see in your eyes
deep inside you wanna cry...

Am not sure who is trolling. Compare persicope snorkling position with Indian. Provide that pic..

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

@waz @Irfan Baloch @WebMaster @WAJsal
@Oscar @Jango
I have posted only one post in this thread.Neither I derailed nor trolled this thread ,And my reply was just on the basis of info I got from PDF .Nor I insult anyone .
But this think tank gave me a negative rating for nothing.
So I am done in this PDF .
Will you delete my profile ?
Or where should I apply for it ?
Not interested in continuing in here .

Please do. The less indians the better.

 

[mzain]

First submarine

they want to put pressure on pakistan tri services. now i think it will be airforce.

Now it is drone in they sent 60 m in Pakistani territory.

 

[A.P. Richelieu]

My dear patriotic indian what was indian submarine doing near pakistani territorial water it was ofz for monitoring cpec related activities ...

Regrding news and highlighting it ... havent you seen news that american war planes and ships wscorted by chinese near territorial water ??? why this is important ? it is slap on indian power projection ...

Regarding detection of snorkeling depth submarine how many incidence you find ? its rare to detect them unless they are in attack mode ...

Maybe You should read up on International Laws and treaties.
Any state ship can sail in International Waters without having to explain to anyone why.

You seem to have a problem accepting that a non-Indian does not accept your narrative .

Submarine warfare has almost been non-existent since WW2,
but snorkling submarines were detectable by radar already at that time.
Not a big feat to do the same 70 years later,

 

[Asim Mirza]

Obviously we will deny
What were you expecting ??

Most of our subs are under maintenance so it's not possible what Pak media is claiming

I think your Navy Comd Will come to you and will tell you we are using this thing to spay pak or may b CPEC

Get some sense when u will

 

[muhammadali233]

Maybe You should read up on International Laws and treaties.
Any state ship can sail in International Waters without having to explain to anyone why.

You seem to have a problem accepting that a non-Indian does not accept your narrative .

Submarine warfare has almost been non-existent since WW2,
but snorkling submarines were detectable by radar already at that time.
Not a big feat to do the same 70 years later,

Cold war sub veterans might want to disagree on your statement on "Sub warfare being non-existent post ww2".
Now coming back on topic:
Sub was chased out of pak waters,it was detected while it was submerged for the past 3 or 4 days,it was more of a cat and mouse chase,as the 209 hurried making full use of it's engine thrust was able to escape Pak water but was still in EEZ,but this heafty movement depleted the batteries,it had to surface to snorkel to start the engines and charge the batteries and was videotaped.Being able to find a sub in 1000sq km of an area isn't easy,the chinese Type-39 went through Indian waters undetected and docked at Karachi waters.You need to keep in mind,Paks new asw platform are coming before 2018,these old p-3c Orion are not very effective relative(when compared to) to p-8 etc.
Two facts you need to keep in mind while debating about Pak-Ind Naval Capabilities.
1.Pak submarine scored the only kill after ww2 sinking 1 frigate and damaging another (not a big feat ikr).
2.Taliban attacked a pakistan naval airbase,main target was the ASW platforms,those talis had pics of P-3Cs,recent parking positions,that airbase had other high value targets too but why only ASW aircrafts were targeted?Yeah no brainer.