What's new

Pakistan Is Losing the Space Race

Joined
Sep 12, 2017
Messages
3,056
Reaction score
-4
Country
Australia
Location
Australia
India’s space program is thriving as one of the fastest-growing in the world. With a successful Mars missionand various satellite launches in recent years, India is emerging as a new space power.

The Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) is now a go-to for countries like Germany, South Korea, Japan, and France seeking to launch and deploy their satellites into space. Even companies like Google use ISRO rockets to launch their satellites. This will help India economically, giving it a foot in the door in a rapidly growing industry (Morgan Stanley projects that the space industry will go from being worth around $350 billion today to over $11 trillion by the 2040s).

In June 2016, ISRO successfully launched 20 satellites in a single payload; in February 2017, it launched 104 satellites on a single rocket and thus set a world record. ISRO launched its heaviest rocket, Geosynchronous Satellite Launch Vehicle-Mark III (GSLV-Mk III), on June 5, 2017 and placed a communications satellite GSAT-19 in orbit. With this launch, ISRO became capable of launching massive, four-ton satellites.

Meanwhile, India launched a Mars orbiter mission in November 2013, and in September 2014, that space probe began successfully orbiting Mars.

India’s new prominence in space has its consequences, especially for Pakistan. India’s rise as a space power will come at the cost of Pakistan’s interests.

ISRO is mainly involved in launching commercial satellites, those dealing with the weather, space navigation, and communications. However, Pakistani authorities should be alarmed due to the multipurpose nature of satellite. A satellite network provides India with a technological advantage on the ground and, in case of war, can be easily exploited for tactical and strategic gains. With a vast array of satellites, India can keep tabs on its borders through high-resolution imagery, intelligence gathering, navigation, and military communications – thus undermining Pakistan defenses. These satellites will also help India develop early warning systems specifically designed to detect ICBMs during different flight phases or incoming ballistic/cruise missiles.

Currently, the Indian military uses 13 satellites. The satellites utilized by the military for surveillance include the Cartosat-1 and 2 series and Risat-1 and Risat-2; the Indian Navy employs satellites like GSAT-7 or INSAT-4F, a multiband military intelligence satellite developed by the ISRO. According to defense experts, the satellite enables the navy to extend its blue water capabilities and stop relying on foreign satellites like Inmarsat, which provide communication services to its ships.

Such critical military and communications satellites could be decisive in preventing or responding to an enemy attack.

As evidence of its dual use function, ISRO works in tandem with India’s Defense Research and Development Organization (DRDO) along with the Defense Research and Development Service (DRDS). Both organizations are responsible for the development of emerging and defense technologies (including missile programs, land, air, and sea armaments, electronic and cyber warfare capabilities, etc.) One example of the partnership between all three organizations was the recent successful test firing of the Agni V Intercontinental Ballistic Missile (ICMB) capable of hitting targets at a distance of up to 5,000 km. In addition to it, India is also testing anti-satellite weapons to foster their space prowess further.

Pakistan’s Space Program

Pakistan’s space program, the Space and Upper Atmosphere Research Commission, commonly referred to as SUPARCO, predates the Indian space program by more than eight years – it was founded in 1961, while the ISRO launched in 1969. But today, SUPARCO lags behind on all the technological advances that have made the Indian program a potent force.

Due to a lack of resources, bureaucratic hurdles, and mismanagement, Pakistan’s space program, especially when it comes to commercial space exploration, has seen a considerable decline. There have been some commendable successes on military applications, like the development of short- to medium-range ballistic missiles, but such achievements have come at the cost of almost every other facet of the Pakistani space project. For example, it would likely take Pakistan decades to achieve anti-satellite (ASAT) capabilities, something that is sorely needed given India’s satellite advantage.

Today there is little interest from the government or policy quarters (both the military and civilian apparatus) to advance Pakistan’s commercial space program and there are few schools, universities, or institutions focusing on the subject. The entire subject of space studies is in neglect; there is no national discourse, debate, or discussion in public circles about building a robust and potent space program. Pakistan continues to lag behind India, despite being the first to set up its space agency.

The SUPARCO website is evidence of the rudderless nature of Pakistan’s space program. It contains very little information regarding Pakistan’s space policy or vision. In fact, there is very little literature available anywhere on the policy-level national space mission. Such indifference toward an extraordinarily important area like space could prove very damaging.

Pakistan must develop a serious space program, especially in the face of a resurgent Indian space program. It is time for the decision-makers in power to give SUPARCO particular attention.

It is essential for Pakistan to acknowledge that the time for face-to-face wars or conflicts is over; new technologies are making modern warfare more or less indirect and deeply reliant on space tools, which provide surveillance and remote sensing; real-time situational awareness; information gathering, processing, and communication; and early warning systems. Satellite have, consequently, become strategic assets playing a crucial role in the outcome of war, making aerospace technological abilities not just essential but a difference maker.

The reason why the Indian space program has become such a success is the belief in and acknowledgement of space as an avenue for a variety of practical applications, from scientific exploration to military applications and economic gain. India has built a national narrative explaining the need for a robust and sustainable space program. Pakistan needs to do just that.

It is vital for Pakistan to understand and acknowledge the importance of a robust space program. Doing so will not only enable national and commercial space exploration but help provide Pakistan with significant military and economic gains, needed now to compete with a resurgent and dominant neighbor.

https://thediplomat.com/2018/02/pakistan-is-losing-the-space-race/

Does Pakistan even have a Space Program?
 
.
Pakistan already has access to Beidou, Chinese intelligence and tech. So why bother. India needs to worry as India does not have a strong ally to rely on like Pakistan could on China.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
what a useless thread, there is no comparison b/w ISRO and SUPARCO, SUPARCO is failed organization because their no political/scientific will showed by Pakistani govt, whereas ISRO is highly successful
How has SUPARCO failed?
 
.
Pakistan already access Beidou, Chinese intelligence and tech. So why bother. India needs to worry as India does not have a strong ally to rely on like Pakistan could on China.

In the end Pakistan can only rely on itself to defend its people and harm India

Whilst a space program is not a top propriety the continued development of our various, cruise, ballistic and other missiles etc would be boosted by development of our space programme

Pakistan initial aim is to ensure complete missile coverage of India and to make those missiles as sophisticated, manoeuvrable with a big a bag of tricks as possible

But once again a developed space programme will help in making longer range missiles and ICBMs
 
.
There is absolutely no comparison between SUPARCO & ISRO.
ISRO is light years ahead of SUPARCO.
Pakistan does not seem interested in space research or any other cutting edge scientific research, how many scientific papers does Pakistan publish each year? Laughable..!
 
.
So what? Does Saudi Arabia have a space program? Yes we are behind some countries in the space race.

There are more important things than the space race like focusing on the economy
 
.
Allow me to play the devil's advocate;

What will Pakistan do with a Space Program?

India is launching micro-satellites for high schools/universities, multi-national corporations (that already are integrated within India), and their own.

While Pakistan's buying rejected satellites already in space or buying them from China. There's no robust Space Program within the "Muslim World" and those that do have the ability to buy and send satellites to space will choose India. You don't think Abu Dhabi can ask Pakistan to convert one of their missiles into a SLV? Or the House of Saud finance a joint space program with their Petro$$$$$$$$.
 
.
Allow me to play the devil's advocate;

What will Pakistan do with a Space Program?

India is launching micro-satellites for high schools/universities, multi-national corporations (that already are integrated within India), and their own.

While Pakistan's buying rejected satellites already in space or buying them from China. There's no robust Space Program within the "Muslim World" and those that do have the ability to buy and send satellites to space will choose India. You don't think Abu Dhabi can ask Pakistan to convert one of their missiles into a SLV? Or the House of Saud finance a joint space program with their Petro$$$$$$$$.
Yes but we are catching up fast
 
. . . .
So what? Does Saudi Arabia have a space program? Yes we are behind some countries in the space race.

There are more important things than the space race like focusing on the economy
Pakistan isn't engaged in a space race at all not with India nor any other country. It's just that sometimes Indians like to stroke their cocks to these kinds of comparisons regardless of how stupid it maybe as long as India comes out on top somehow...it gets their dicks real hard.
 
.
While Pakistan's buying rejected satellites already in space or buying them from China. There's no robust Space Program within the "Muslim World" and those that do have the ability to buy and send satellites to space will choose India. You don't think Abu Dhabi can ask Pakistan to convert one of their missiles into a SLV? Or the House of Saud finance a joint space program with their Petro$$$$$$$$.
Pakistani missiles are solid fueled and Sats cannot take the jerks and speed solid fuel give. A country that can develop a warhead and can manage reentry can develop a sat. this is like taking a step back but why do we need a space program this is your valid question.
 
.
Allow me to play the devil's advocate;

What will Pakistan do with a Space Program?

India is launching micro-satellites for high schools/universities, multi-national corporations (that already are integrated within India), and their own.

While Pakistan's buying rejected satellites already in space or buying them from China. There's no robust Space Program within the "Muslim World" and those that do have the ability to buy and send satellites to space will choose India. You don't think Abu Dhabi can ask Pakistan to convert one of their missiles into a SLV? Or the House of Saud finance a joint space program with their Petro$$$$$$$$.


Ironic considering Pakistan was the first country to send rockets into space in south asia and perhaps even in the greater middle eastern region.
 
.
In the end Pakistan can only rely on itself to defend its people and harm India

Whilst a space program is not a top propriety the continued development of our various, cruise, ballistic and other missiles etc would be boosted by development of our space programme

Pakistan initial aim is to ensure complete missile coverage of India and to make those missiles as sophisticated, manoeuvrable with a big a bag of tricks as possible

But once again a developed space programme will help in making longer range missiles and ICBMs


Welcome to the globalization. No country makes everything in today's world. There is not need to waste time and money when what is need is readily available for use. You do not need ICBMs to take care of India. Haft, Babur and RAAD are more than enough. Shaheen and Ababeel are an overkill for India.
 
.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom