What's new

Pakistan is at a critical make-or-break stage

shuakataftab

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Feb 6, 2009
Messages
424
Reaction score
0
Abdul Sattar Edhi, the founder of the Edhi Foundation, is unarguably the most renowned philanthropist in Pakistan. He began his work in 1951 with the opening of a free, one-room medical clinic in Karachi. Currently, his foundation runs 250 centres across the country and houses more than 2,000 children at any given time.

The centres also provide free burial of unclaimed bodies, free health care and dispensaries, rehabilitation of drug addicts, free assistance for the handicapped, and family planning counselling. Over 6,000 destitute, runaways, and mentally challenged individuals are also in the foundation’s care. The Edhi Foundation has also managed to raise the largest single fleet of ambulances in Pakistan, providing transportation to over one million persons annually. The foundation is also involved in relief efforts for victims of natural and other disasters on a national and international level.

Dawn.com speaks with Edhi to gauge how the foundation has been affected by the ongoing political and security situation.

Q. Your foundation is involved in a range of activities. How do you decide what projects to pursue?

A. My work involves supporting those who have no one to look after them. That also involves looking after the dead bodies and arranging a respectable burial for them. I cannot say no to anyone.

Q. Is there any part of the country where your organisation has encountered problems owing to the security situation?

A. We have never had any serious problems with anyone. There have been incidents reported by our workers and volunteers regarding hide-snatching [during Eid-ul-Azha] in the past, but we are operating as we always have. In fact, we are also planning to establish centres in Tank and Hangu. Even the Taliban haven’t made any trouble for us; they donated money to the foundation and said they did so because I was helping those who couldn’t help themselves.

Q. The foundation has accepted donations from the Taliban; does that mean that you agree with their ideology?

A. No, I do not. I also told them that I do not agree with all the violence and destruction and the effect it has on people’s lives. To that, they said they were not behind the attacks that targeted civilians and ordinary people.

Q. What is it that makes your angry?

A. I don’t get angry – it’s not in my nature. Sometimes [my wife] Bilquis and I have arguments, but that’s all.

Q. Do you think philanthropic organisations such as yours cause the state to further abscond from its civic responsibilities?

A. If the state can ensure that all who are subject to pay taxes do so, that would be a good enough start. If people were to honestly pay their taxes and also give charity, it would solve more than half of the country’s problems.

Q. In 2008, eight children were abandoned by three women at an Edhi Foundation centre. The foundation later paid the families Rs. 100,000 each to take the children back. Are pay-offs of this kind effective when the root causes for children being abandoned are not addressed?

A. Pay-offs are, of course, no solution, and we normally do not hand out money like that. Usually, we give shelter to children whose families abandon them, primarily for monetary reasons. The day people stop abandoning their children at our centres, I will believe that things are changing in Pakistan. But that does not seem to be happening. It is also quite clear that the government does not get actively involved, so I have no hope of people getting support from the state.

Q. No hope? Isn’t that a fatalistic position to take regarding the state machinery?

A. It is. But how can I have hope in a state that is being exploited by the current system – a system that is itself being manoeuvred by groups with no commitment to the people of this country. The whole political frame as it currently exists has to reinvent itself before we can even begin to hope for change in Pakistan.

Q. Have you ever been approached by political or other groups for support?

A. Once, I was approached by General Hamid Gul, Imran Khan and few others, mostly military and intelligence officials, who were conspiring to overthrow Benazir Bhutto’s second government and wanted me to get involved. I declined because I am a social worker and not a politician. I also did not want to tarnish the credibility of my organisation by getting embroiled in something that obviously seemed quite disturbing. Eventually, I was made to feel threatened enough to temporarily leave the country.

Q. How do you see the future of Pakistan?

A. I will continue to do my work and serve the people. However, Pakistan is now at a critical make-or-break stage, and if the system does not undergo a major overhaul, I am afraid that the country may even break up. Given the current conditions, it will take nothing short of a calculated, studied revolution to change things and save Pakistan.
DAWN.COM | Metropolitan | "Pakistan is at a critical make-or-break stage"
 
.
Imran khan was conspiring to overthrow benazir bhutto's democratic government and he asked help from Abdul Sattar Edhi

Imran acts like an angel in front of TV
 
.
Imran khan was conspiring to overthrow benazir bhutto's democratic government and he asked help from Abdul Sattar Edhi

Imran acts like an angel in front of TV
 
.
Imran khan was conspiring to overthrow benazir bhutto's democratic government and he asked help from Abdul Sattar Edhi

Imran acts like an angel in front of TV

:))) so you posted it to bash Imran Khan ??

Come on even if he got the help it was not possible to overthrow her govt .
 
. .
Abdul Sattar Edhi, the founder of the Edhi Foundation, is unarguably the most renowned philanthropist in Pakistan. He began his work in 1951 with the opening of a free, one-room medical clinic in Karachi. Currently, his foundation runs 250 centres across the country and houses more than 2,000 children at any given time.

The centres also provide free burial of unclaimed bodies, free health care and dispensaries, rehabilitation of drug addicts, free assistance for the handicapped, and family planning counselling. Over 6,000 destitute, runaways, and mentally challenged individuals are also in the foundation’s care. The Edhi Foundation has also managed to raise the largest single fleet of ambulances in Pakistan, providing transportation to over one million persons annually. The foundation is also involved in relief efforts for victims of natural and other disasters on a national and international level.

Dawn.com speaks with Edhi to gauge how the foundation has been affected by the ongoing political and security situation.

Q. Your foundation is involved in a range of activities. How do you decide what projects to pursue?

A. My work involves supporting those who have no one to look after them. That also involves looking after the dead bodies and arranging a respectable burial for them. I cannot say no to anyone.

Q. Is there any part of the country where your organisation has encountered problems owing to the security situation?

A. We have never had any serious problems with anyone. There have been incidents reported by our workers and volunteers regarding hide-snatching [during Eid-ul-Azha] in the past, but we are operating as we always have. In fact, we are also planning to establish centres in Tank and Hangu. Even the Taliban haven’t made any trouble for us; they donated money to the foundation and said they did so because I was helping those who couldn’t help themselves.

Q. The foundation has accepted donations from the Taliban; does that mean that you agree with their ideology?

A. No, I do not. I also told them that I do not agree with all the violence and destruction and the effect it has on people’s lives. To that, they said they were not behind the attacks that targeted civilians and ordinary people.

Q. What is it that makes your angry?

A. I don’t get angry – it’s not in my nature. Sometimes [my wife] Bilquis and I have arguments, but that’s all.

Q. Do you think philanthropic organisations such as yours cause the state to further abscond from its civic responsibilities?

A. If the state can ensure that all who are subject to pay taxes do so, that would be a good enough start. If people were to honestly pay their taxes and also give charity, it would solve more than half of the country’s problems.

Q. In 2008, eight children were abandoned by three women at an Edhi Foundation centre. The foundation later paid the families Rs. 100,000 each to take the children back. Are pay-offs of this kind effective when the root causes for children being abandoned are not addressed?

A. Pay-offs are, of course, no solution, and we normally do not hand out money like that. Usually, we give shelter to children whose families abandon them, primarily for monetary reasons. The day people stop abandoning their children at our centres, I will believe that things are changing in Pakistan. But that does not seem to be happening. It is also quite clear that the government does not get actively involved, so I have no hope of people getting support from the state.

Q. No hope? Isn’t that a fatalistic position to take regarding the state machinery?

A. It is. But how can I have hope in a state that is being exploited by the current system – a system that is itself being manoeuvred by groups with no commitment to the people of this country. The whole political frame as it currently exists has to reinvent itself before we can even begin to hope for change in Pakistan.

Q. Have you ever been approached by political or other groups for support?

A. Once, I was approached by General Hamid Gul, Imran Khan and few others, mostly military and intelligence officials, who were conspiring to overthrow Benazir Bhutto’s second government and wanted me to get involved. I declined because I am a social worker and not a politician. I also did not want to tarnish the credibility of my organisation by getting embroiled in something that obviously seemed quite disturbing. Eventually, I was made to feel threatened enough to temporarily leave the country.

Q. How do you see the future of Pakistan?

A. I will continue to do my work and serve the people. However, Pakistan is now at a critical make-or-break stage, and if the system does not undergo a major overhaul, I am afraid that the country may even break up. Given the current conditions, it will take nothing short of a calculated, studied revolution to change things and save Pakistan.
DAWN.COM | Metropolitan | "Pakistan is at a critical make-or-break stage"


he openly takes donations from Taliban is it allowed as per law?????

what type of revolution is he talking about??????
 
.
:))) so you posted it to bash Imran Khan ??

Come on even if he got the help it was not possible to overthrow her govt .
i just pointed out that he was conspiring against a democratic government everyone should know he does not practice what he preaches
 
.
I remember my own conversations with Abdus sattar Edhi, a decade or so back
and he struck me as pragmatic as opposed to faith based.

Though he does recoganise the system as flawed and the need to change it.
I wonder why his preference has been to stay downstream of the system dealing with its flotsam and jetsam that the system threw out - instead of taking a position upstream to do something about the society and the system itself.

He was uniquely placed to take such a stand.
 
.
I remember my own conversations with Abdus sattar Edhi, a decade or so back
and he struck me as pragmatic as opposed to faith based.

Though he does recoganise the system as flawed and the need to change it.
I wonder why his preference has been to stay downstream of the system dealing with its flotsam and jetsam that the system threw out - instead of taking a position upstream to do something about the society and the system itself.

He was uniquely placed to take such a stand.

Because he would have been reduced to the same level to which all those who want to change the system have been to.

He is focusing more on helping the victims of the system instead of trying to change it as there are too many lobbies and too many paid morons both internaly and externaly who creat obsticales
 
.
Because he would have been reduced to the same level to which all those who want to change the system have been to.

He is focusing more on helping the victims of the system instead of trying to change it as there are too many lobbies and too many paid morons both internaly and externaly who creat obsticales
Which means Jana, that he is more concerned about himself and his Org, than about the society and its people from where such problems emanate that he has to constantly deal with.

There will always be morons and people opposing you, whether you are doing good or bad - this is the duality we live in, which we call LIFE.
 
.
Abdul Sattar Edhi is a great person at least that's what i think about him. he must candidate for the noble prize. We need persons like him in politics too. Only if our politicians and leaders can get example from him we could solve all of our problems. we need more unity, faith and dicipline as a nation!:pakistan:
 
.
Which means Jana, that he is more concerned about himself and his Org, than about the society and its people from where such problems emanate that he has to constantly deal with.

There will always be morons and people opposing you, whether you are doing good or bad - this is the duality we live in, which we call LIFE.

NO he is not at all concerned about himself and his org becuase.

1. He has only few pairs of cloths hardly five.

2. He doesnt own any property neither he will have.

3. At this old age he is still traveling around the world for humanitarian work.

4. This system in Pakistan is not at all easy for a man like him to change that too at this old age. And for a something imposible at his age he can not leave the downtroden at the mercy of this feudal system.

5. Perhapes in south asia his organisation is the only one that also have helicopters which are used for resecue and other humanitarian work around the world.


For changing this system it need atleast half a century if not more
 
.
NO he is not at all concerned about himself and his org becuase.

1. He has only few pairs of cloths hardly five.

2. He doesnt own any property neither he will have.

3. At this old age he is still traveling around the world for humanitarian work.

4. This system in Pakistan is not at all easy for a man like him to change that too at this old age. And for a something imposible at his age he can not leave the downtroden at the mercy of this feudal system.

5. Perhapes in south asia his organisation is the only one that also have helicopters which are used for resecue and other humanitarian work around the world.


For changing this system it need atleast half a century if not more
It is not about personal wealth and possessions, Jana.
It may be something entirely different, like not looking
at it the way I look at it.

He may be old but he should have started somewhere, someone else may have taken the last steps.

A change does not take as long as you may think and even if it does do you not
think it is worth it anyway.

How long has it taken for the change to take hold just adjacent West of your country?
 
.
It's strange that People like Obama get Nobel Peace Prize while true People working for Humanity like Edhi Shahab are ignored.

For one simple reason.. Edhi is in Pakistan Obama in USA. Indeed, there is no discrimination and exception in the laws of discrimination. ;)
 
.
It is not about personal wealth and possessions, Jana.
It may be something entirely different, like not looking
at it the way I look at it.

He may be old but he should have started somewhere, someone else may have taken the last steps.

A change does not take as long as you may think and even if it does do you not
think it is worth it anyway.

How long has it taken for the change to take hold just adjacent West of your country?

I understand what you are saying but honestly speaking he is not capable of changing the system, so why he should waste that time and leave many needy people to die which is saving at the moment.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom