Pakistan government failing on minorities, report says

[Karachiite]

then why dont you leave pakistan and go elsewhere?
mr minority.
only yesterday you were saying you have no religion but a muslim dad and a muslim name.and now you pose as monority as in christian or hindu.
you are one messed up boy.

Hi, my mother's side is Christian so Im not posing as anyone. Im more of an Agnostic but that doesn't really matter. The sad part is that you want anyone that is not muslim to leave Pakistan. I understand your a mulli but this is really extreme. It was the minority Parsis that donated tons of money to the National treasury of Pakistan in 1947 when Pakistan had nothing. It was the minority Ahmadis that sacrificed themselves for the creation of Pakistan. After paying countless tax and blood this is what the minorities get. A big slap in the face and are told to leave the country because they do not follow Islam. Now we know why Pakistan is in a big mess and why it is hated so much around the world.
Can you give me the address to your madarsah?

 

[Safriz]

so you think it is ok for an individual to have different standards in different countries ?

no. if you start hating pakistan because islamabad doesnt build road to your little village on the corner of baluchistan and making that a reason you start making love with india and kill mkne wotkers you rather leave pakkistan and live elsewhere. thats what k mean. clear now?

 

[Safriz]

Hi, my mother's side is Christian so Im not posing as anyone. Im more of an Agnostic but that doesn't really matter. The sad part is that you want anyone that is not muslim to leave Pakistan. I understand your a mulli but this is really extreme. It was the minority Parsis that donated tons of money to the National treasury of Pakistan in 1947 when Pakistan had nothing. It was the minority Ahmadis that sacrificed themselves for the creation of Pakistan. After paying countless tax and blood this is what the minorities get. A big slap in the face and are told to leave the country because they do not follow Islam. Now we know why Pakistan is in a big mess and why it is hated so much around the world.
Can you give me the address to your madarsah?

and thats why i dont see any parsi moaning. they are taken care of and they are capable of taking care of themselves,and they are well aware of how to integrate .

 

[Karachiite]

and thats why i dont see any parsi moaning. they are taken care of and they are capable of taking care of themselves,and they are well aware of how to integrate .

Really, you don't see Parsis moaning? Reach Saddar Karachi or Parsi colony and I will introduce you to some Parsis and you can know how happy they are. I'll also introduce you to some Ahmadis in Punjab, Hindus in Balochistan and Christians in Punjab. You'll know how happy they are and all their great experiences.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

This has got more to do with education.

 

[great]

This has got more to do with education.

Would you be so non-chalant about Indian minorities too?

 

[T-Faz]

Hi, my mother's side is Christian so Im not posing as anyone. Im more of an Agnostic but that doesn't really matter. The sad part is that you want anyone that is not muslim to leave Pakistan. I understand your a mulli but this is really extreme. It was the minority Parsis that donated tons of money to the National treasury of Pakistan in 1947 when Pakistan had nothing. It was the minority Ahmadis that sacrificed themselves for the creation of Pakistan. After paying countless tax and blood this is what the minorities get. A big slap in the face and are told to leave the country because they do not follow Islam. Now we know why Pakistan is in a big mess and why it is hated so much around the world.
Can you give me the address to your madarsah?

It was the Parsi's, Ahmadi's and Aga Khani's who out their own money into the national treasury. These three groups donated enough money that was able to stabilize Pakistan and save it from its impeding collapse.

The Parsi Mehta family, who owned the longest runaway in Asia then (Quetta) donated obscene amounts of money, Aga Khan also pulled all stops worldwide to get money into Pakistan, the House of Habib loaned money to Pakistan so that they could pay off wages.

This is not heard of or told to Pakistani's anymore, also our Economic development was being led by a Hindu who was killed in riots.

 

[Safriz]

Really, you don't see Parsis moaning? Reach Saddar Karachi or Parsi colony and I will introduce you to some Parsis and you can know how happy they are. I'll also introduce you to some Ahmadis in Punjab, Hindus in Balochistan and Christians in Punjab. You'll know how happy they are and all their great experiences.

i doubt you ever been out of your bedroom.
for your info i have roamed the country for years and unlike your google and wiki knowledge i have first hand knowledge from these people. in my little corner of northetn pakistan we have christian missionary hospitsl. germans come there sincec 1930s and actively preach christianity and we have a large local christian population. we have parsis living there who have big shops. we never had anh ptoblems with any of these people.
now go oregon in the free world usa and live thete i will see how many days you will pass without being attacked by white mobs..
suffice saying that whatever problrm you are trying to magnify and cry about is not only in pakistan.its evetywhere.

 

[pak-marine]

i dont know what you are on about but if pakistan was such a discriminating country we wont have all.the business of our financial hub karachi run by bahai bohra and agha khanis who arent muslims.
we wont have indigenous americans sat on top of every big corporate business such ad Gillet. Treet.Liver brothers and such. There is no such law in europe but as you go towards the top.ranks of their gkvernments and sny large buisinesses you see less and less non europeans .

What i am on about is recent cases of blasphemy laws .... hundreds of minority rights ripped off , just hear yourself , you passed verdict on some sects that they are non muslims ... , you just asked a member to leave the country when he complaining about minoroty right being abused. Not sure what planet you are on !

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Would you be so non-chalant about Indian minorities too?

Dude dnt bring india........Atleast our CMs arent ordering police and encouraging people to kill,rape and destroy sacred places>>? and our army discouraging minorities not to join it.

Also a good example is a christian PAF Pilot flying JFT in Turkey.........Hence u cant blame the govt.


...........

@Pak-marine......dude out of the 60 or so blasphemy accused people........57 are muslims........ Just few weeks back a 13 year old kid was nabbed just for tearing some poster with a mosque or somethin.....

 

[Safriz]

I am on the same planet as you.Didnt know what you were saying but now clear.
I am against paople playing race and religion card for special treatment.
Pakistan is a poor country with problems and everybody shares this. Many muslim groups dont have quota in jobs and education but there are dedicated quotas for minorities. that shouldnt have been if pakistan was such a minority oppressor.

 

[Last Hope]

1) Failing how exactly?
They have failed for whole Nation, which includes minorities. So why point at them?

2) The 'minorities'
They themselves want to stay un-attached with others and not treat themselves as one Nation.
We cannot help if they pruposely want to be supporting who break the Nation (MQM)

3) So what?!
What if Pakistan government is failing? We know that much more than you.
So why come up with article about it?? This is old news!

You being a Bharti must be more concerned over this:
Bharti government failed to protect minorities

 

[Karachiite]

i doubt you ever been out of your bedroom.
for your info i have roamed the country for years and unlike your google and wiki knowledge i have first hand knowledge from these people. in my little corner of northetn pakistan we have christian missionary hospitsl. germans come there sincec 1930s and actively preach christianity and we have a large local christian population. we have parsis living there who have big shops. we never had anh ptoblems with any of these people.
now go oregon in the free world usa and live thete i will see how many days you will pass without being attacked by white mobs..
suffice saying that whatever problrm you are trying to magnify and cry about is not only in pakistan.its evetywhere.

Im talking about the present not 1930s. Instead of preaching on the internet about your knowledge of Islam and deciding who's a muslim or not why don't you do something productive like actually coming to Pakistan seeing how the minorities live here in parts of Interior Sindh, South Punjab, NW and Balochistan. Its easy to talk bull on the internet. And I don't know why your bringing America in this but its your fellow Pakistanis that are dying to run away to America even if it means living in Alabama. Again America has full 100% freedom of religion and is a secular country unlike Pakistan. Don't even think about comparing the two.

 

[VelocuR]

come on, don't fight over minorities. I have seen pretty big issues going on, not just Pakistan.

US treated black people as a low citizen & US govt failed to provide necessary
Britain slaves millions people over the world & the worst government failed to allow freedom same as Australia, France, Africa, Russia.

These experiments in many years is happen to other country, Pakistan will learn similary this issues, I assure you minority will be equal as first citizen in all matters, our GoP doesn't have alot of money to use Law and Order systems.

At least, we need to unite at the moment of difficult times.

 

[Safriz]

Im talking about the present not 1930s. Instead of preaching on the internet about your knowledge of Islam and deciding who's a muslim or not why don't you do something productive like actually coming to Pakistan seeing how the minorities live here in parts of Interior Sindh, South Punjab, NW and Balochistan. Its easy to talk bull on the internet. And I don't know why your bringing America in this but its your fellow Pakistanis that are dying to run away to America even if it means living in Alabama. Again America has full 100% freedom of religion and is a secular country unlike Pakistan. Don't even think about comparing the two.

the areas you mention are poor and nobody is living good there. minority or otherwise. why relate general poverty with religious minority. isnt it manilulating of facts?
about ahmedi and qadiani. i used to worm in manchester immigration court as a translator and i seen many ahmedis from pakistan being refused asylum because British home office has proof that they are well protected in pakistan and dont face persecution. you dont have to beleive me on that. its all on the United Kingdom Borders AGENCY WRBSITE.
A foreign country says in court with evidence that ahmedis are well protected but people like you say othrwise. what evidence of actual persecution you have?apart from an internet commnt made by somebody or political jibjab among power thirsty politicians. Go on and prove that out on the roads pakistani people are petsecuting minorities en mass