Pakistan ,a country of serious concern for minorities:USCIRF

[Pandora]

Whats special with muslims , they are relegious minority like others ...
as you are referring to India , India already have chiefs of Army ,Air force and Navy chiefs from relegious minority ... tell me how many Army , airforce and Navy chiefs you had in Pakistan from any of your relegious minorities

Like i said let me know when you have Muslims at top positions. Being one of the largest minority and never been to one of the highest ranking position explains everything about treatment of Muslims. Also it is a well established fact that Indians Hindus have generic hate for Muslims so i would bet on them ever being on a top post in a million years.

BTW if you want to compare minorities make up almost 20% of India whereas in past that percentage is only less than 4% so you are comparing apples and oranges here. No due favor is given to any group especially in our armed forces. Being at the rank of Major general is no small feat when you belong to a group which is only less than 2% of our population. If seniority allows then i cant see why a non Muslims cant become an army air or naval chiefs. Even statistically chance of a non Muslim becoming a chief is low but same cant be said about India. Indian Muslims make up 15% of your total population.

 

[aman_rai]

the special thing about muslims is, they are 15% and the largest minority(more than 70% of all minorities), dont you think there should have been a muslim PM by now?

View attachment 628188

regards

No... it's PM of a country... Not some govt job where minorities can have Kota system...

 

[GHALIB]

How many minorities getting lynched in the streets of Pakistan!!
How many are asked on the streets to prove if they are Hindus or Muslims or Christians in Pakistan!!

There is only one minority, which is asked to identify their place of worship and don't call them mosques like Muslims.
That minority has all the rights to live as a minority but are prohibited to call themselves Muslims, rightly so. Because they are not Muslims. Period.

lynching of minorities do happen in pakistan , one christian couple was burnt alive in punjab few years ago . hindus, christians got killed by muslims for alleged blasphemy , so you can not point fingers on india . in india minorities have equal status with majority .

Like i said let me know when you have Muslims at top positions. Being one of the largest minority and never been to one of the highest ranking position explains everything about treatment of Muslims. Also it is a well established fact that Indians Hindus have generic hate for Muslims so i would bet on them ever being on a top post in a million years.

BTW if you want to compare minorities make up almost 20% of India whereas in past that percentage is only less than 4% so you are comparing apples and oranges here. No due favor is given to any group especially in our armed forces. Being at the rank of Major general is no small feat when you belong to a group which is only less than 2% of our population. If seniority allows then i cant see why a non Muslims cant become an army air or naval chiefs. Even statistically chance of a non Muslim becoming a chief is low but same cant be said about India. Indian Muslims make up 15% of your total population.

lol you can not give not even a single time post of governorship , chief ministership, presidentship , chief of army ship to minorities but we had given all these to . minorities in past . how amusing is to ask for PM ship to muslims in india ? first give one post to minorities in pakistan then talk about india .

Yes bcz Muslims are the largest minority in India and also the minority most discriminated. So tell me how many were made Chief justice, PM or Miltary chief?
We had
Rana Bhagwandas as Chief Justice of Pakistan.

As for Pakistan we had several high ranking non Muslim Military officers. Following are just Christians

Pakistan Air Force

• Air Vice Marshal Eric Gordon Hall (1947-1977)
• Air Vice Marshal Michael John O'Brian
• Air Commodore Patrick Desmond Callaghan (1945-1971)
• Group Captain Cecil Chaudhry
• Air Commodore Nazir Latif
• Wing Commander Mervyn L. Middlecoat
• Squadron Leader Peter Christy
• Flight Lieutenant William D. Harney

Pakistan Army

• Major General Julian Peter
• Major General Noel Israel Khokhar
• Brigadier Samson Simon Sharaf
• Brigadier Mervyn Cardoza
• Brigadier Daniel Austin

Pakistan Navy
Rear-Admiral Leslie Mungavin

we have big big big list of minorities heading top posts in all walks of life not only in armed force as you came with some masihi serving in army , we have far far better record of giving minorities representation in all places .

 

[El Sidd]

lynching of minorities do happen in pakistan , one christian couple was burnt alive in punjab few years ago . hindus, christians got killed by muslims for alleged blasphemy , so you can not point fingers on india . in india minorities have equal status with majority .



lol you can not give not even a single time post of governorship , chief ministership, presidentship , chief of army ship to minorities but we had given all these to . minorities in past . how amusing is to ask for PM ship to muslims in india ? first give one post to minorities in pakistan then talk about india .




we have big big big list of minorities heading top posts in all walks of life not only in armed force as you came with some masihi serving in army , we have far far better record of giving minorities representation in all places .

How does Indian constitution define a minority?

As per the amended constitution, there are no minorities in India.

 

[GHALIB]

How does Indian constitution define a minority?

As per the amended constitution, there are no minorities in India.

right now i don't have constitution with me ,
but as regular practice non hindus are considered minority , constitution provides every citizen is equal and every citizen is entitled to sit on highest of the position in india .
which is not in pakistan , non muslims can't held highest posts .

 

[El Sidd]

right now i don't have constitution with me ,
but as regular practice non hindus are considered minority , constitution provides every citizen is equal and every citizen is entitled to sit on highest of the position in india .
which is not in pakistan , non muslims can't held highest posts .

you do realise that the indian document does not recognize any minority and calls all Indians as Hindus?

 

[GHALIB]

Like i said let me know when you have Muslims at top positions. Being one of the largest minority and never been to one of the highest ranking position explains everything about treatment of Muslims. Also it is a well established fact that Indians Hindus have generic hate for Muslims so i would bet on them ever being on a top post in a million years.

BTW if you want to compare minorities make up almost 20% of India whereas in past that percentage is only less than 4% so you are comparing apples and oranges here. No due favor is given to any group especially in our armed forces. Being at the rank of Major general is no small feat when you belong to a group which is only less than 2% of our population. If seniority allows then i cant see why a non Muslims cant become an army air or naval chiefs. Even statistically chance of a non Muslim becoming a chief is low but same cant be said about India. Indian Muslims make up 15% of your total population.

highest post in india is post of president who also happens to be supreme commander of indian armed forces , this post was held by three muslims abdul qalam, fakhruddin ali ahmad and zakir hussain .

you do realise that the indian document does not recognize any minority and calls all Indians as Hindus?

pl show if you have any evidence if everyone is called hindu ?

 

[El Sidd]

highest post in india is post of president who also happens to be supreme commander of indian armed forces , this post was held by three muslims abdul qalam, fakhruddin ali ahmad and zakir hussain .

if they were alive they would be considered infiltrators

pl show if you have any evidence if everyone is called hindu ?

Its not a religion. Its a geographical term

 

[crankthatskunk]

lynching of minorities do happen in pakistan , one christian couple was burnt alive in punjab few years ago . hindus, christians got killed by muslims for alleged blasphemy , so you can not point fingers on india . in india minorities have equal status with majority .

Well, that is the point, you have to go few years back. Not few days or hours back in the case of India.
These sort of incidents by some lunatics do happen in every country. I don't know what incident was that or what circumstances, so I cannot comment.
The thing is that in Pakistan we all not only condemn it but work against all such people and we try our best to protect minorities. Not target them like the Indians do.

Just look at what they doing to Muslim vendors in India right now. Your legislature's members, politicians calling for their boycott publicly.
That's why India is a terrorists , full of religious intolerance state. Pakistan is not.
Indian's decades old propaganda in the world against Pakistan is dying and your real face is open to the world now.
Shame on you mate for standing for this ugly and racists face of India.

 

[GHALIB]

if they were alive they would be considered infiltrators



Its not a religion. Its a geographical term

that is your perception chacha .

 

[El Sidd]

that is your perception chacha .

gaon se nikal kar shehar ja pata lag jaega.

India is against old and the sick in systematic manner. All 70 plus don't have citizenship nor access to healthcare in covid19 crisis.

shameless a holes have more pride than you

 

[GHALIB]

Well, that is the point, you have to go few years back. Not few days or hours back in the case of India.
These sort of incidents by some lunatics do happen in every country. I don't know what incident was that or what circumstances, so I cannot comment.
The thing is that in Pakistan we all not only condemn it but work against all such people and we try our best to protect minorities. Not target them like the Indians do.

Just look at what they doing to Muslim vendors in India right now. Your legislature's members, politicians calling for their boycott publicly.
That's why India is a terrorists , full of religious intolerance state. Pakistan is not.
Indian's decades old propaganda in the world against Pakistan is dying and your real face is open to the world now.
Shame on you mate for standing for this ugly and racists face of India.

i showed you these things happen in pakistan regularly
i am showing your reality and hypocrisy , there are cases of abduction of hindu girls , attack on churches and gurudwaras in pakistan recently . you should search your news papers you will find it .

gaon se nikal kar shehar ja pata lag jaega.

India is against old and the sick in systematic manner. All 70 plus don't have citizenship nor access to healthcare in covid19 crisis.

shameless a holes have more pride than you

you are against india , that is very simple

 

[El Sidd]

you are against india , that is very simple

Nature compels me to negate you

 

[crankthatskunk]

i showed you these things happen in pakistan regularly
i am showing your reality and hypocrisy , there are cases of abduction of hindu girls , attack on churches and gurudwaras in pakistan recently . you should search your news papers you will find it .

What hypocrisy!!

None of us say that occasional incidents do not happen, one in few years or decades. We not only condemn it but works towards harmony and love for minorities to make it better for them. And punish those who perform such acts.

So accepting infrequent incidents is hypocrisy, but not accepting that your state is sponsoring the daily incidents of Muslim's hate, Islamaphobia and killings of Muslims in systematic terrorism is not hypocrisy!!

Get real.

 

[GHALIB]

Nature compels me to negate you

apki marzi .