Pak & India should withdraw from Siachen, Nawaz Sharif

[Amolthebest]

We should not withdraw from Siachen. If we withdraw, then India will again capture siachen as they did in 1984. Soldier should continue to make sacrifices for Pakistan, They are made for sacrifice and they will.

How can you withdraw from Siachin when you are not even present there?

 

[LiberalAtheist]

We should not withdraw from Siachen. If we withdraw, then India will again capture siachen as they did in 1984. Soldier should continue to make sacrifices for Pakistan, They are made for sacrifice and they will.

you do realize that India controls the entire glacier right? you guys only control the low ground that leads to the saltoro ridge

 

[ashokdeiva]

We should not withdraw from Siachen. If we withdraw, then India will again capture siachen as they did in 1984. Soldier should continue to make sacrifices for Pakistan, They are made for sacrifice and they will.

May be you can fill the shoes of PA personal along with IA personal who die batling the cold weather there.
and when did your army controlled Siachen, are you in this world or are you in a parallel world where Pakistan has won all the wars with INDIA.

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

How can you withdraw from Siachin when you are not even present there?

How you claim siachen. No side has full control of siachen. I said as Indian is not trusty, As you invaded in Siachen in 1984, Pak still have lot of territory there. So we should not send gift siachen Glacier to India. We can send and pay some million dollars for construction work in India for some stuff as zardari did it last week

 

[Saleem]

maybe he's not had enough aloo gosht---or he should switch to beef de bon aka muttar qeema...

 

[Amolthebest]

How you claim siachen. No side has full control of siachen. I said as Indian is not trusty, As you invaded in Siachen in 1984, Pak still have lot of territory there. So we should not send gift siachen Glacier to India. We can send and pay some million dollars for construction work in India for some stuff as zardari did it last week

I won't troll in reply cause your other posts are sensible. My point was after kargil treason it's highly impossible.

 

[Secur]

How can you withdraw from Siachin when you are not even present there?

How many times will you guys repeat this debunked myth ?

Enlighten me , where is the Gyari Sector ?

Where is Gyong La - one of the three major mountain passes ?

Where is Conway Saddle ? Pakistan's army largest base on the Siachin area ...

As a result of operation "Meghdoot", two out of three passes on the Siachen – Sia La and Bilfond La -- came under India's control, while the third pass -- Gyong La – remained under Pakistan's control.


-Cobra Post

It then mounted a superhuman effort to stabilise the situation, even as the initial tactical advantage had enabled the Indian army to capture positions on the ridge; the valorous Pakistani contingent was still a week short of it. This counter-move was not futile; it relatively secured the Gyong La pass sub-sector


-Tacstrat

In two ways, India ’s position has already been compromised, as Pakistan controls the Gyong La pass overlooking Shylok and Nubra rivers, along with the road that links mainland India to Leh, and China ’s de facto hold over Aksai Chin.


-BR

 

[Ammyy]

How many times will you guys repeat this debunked myth ?

Enlighten me , where is the Gyari Sector ?

Where is Gyong La - one of the three major mountain passes ?

Where is Conway Saddle ? Pakistan's army largest base on the Siachin area ...

As a result of operation "Meghdoot", two out of three passes on the Siachen – Sia La and Bilfond La -- came under India's control, while the third pass -- Gyong La – remained under Pakistan's control.


-Cobra Post

It then mounted a superhuman effort to stabilise the situation, even as the initial tactical advantage had enabled the Indian army to capture positions on the ridge; the valorous Pakistani contingent was still a week short of it. This counter-move was not futile; it relatively secured the Gyong La pass sub-sector


-Tacstrat

In two ways, India ’s position has already been compromised, as Pakistan controls the Gyong La pass overlooking Shylok and Nubra rivers, along with the road that links mainland India to Leh, and China ’s de facto hold over Aksai Chin.


-BR

"The expeditions are also meant to show to the international audience that Indian troops hold "almost all dominating heights" on Saltoro Ridge, which is the highest watershed in the area and towers along the western edge of the glacier. And, of course, that Pakistani troops are nowhere near the 72-km-long Siachen Glacier."

India opens Siachen to trekkers - Times Of India

Even International audience know the truth

 

[Secur]

"The expeditions are also meant to show to the international audience that Indian troops hold "almost all dominating heights" on Saltoro Ridge, which is the highest watershed in the area and towers along the western edge of the glacier. And, of course, that Pakistani troops are nowhere near the 72-km-long Siachen Glacier."

India opens Siachen to trekkers - Times Of India

Even International audience know the truth

Try to answer my questions first

 

[Ammyy]

Try to answer my questions first

Yes Pakistan have 15-20 % area of Siachen under their control ... no one is denying it

 

[Secur]

Yes Pakistan have 15-20 % area of Siachen under their control ... no one is denying it

Then who was parroting the same BR response here again and again that Pakistani forces aren't even on Siachin so how can they withdraw ?

 

[Ammyy]

Then who was parroting the same BR response here again and again that Pakistani forces aren't even on Siachin so how can they withdraw ?

Thing is that you are not in a position to negotiate for Siachen ...

You have to accept what we want ... otherwise India is not in hurry

 

[Secur]

Thing is that you are not in a position to negotiate for Siachen ...

You have to accept what we want ... otherwise India is not in hurry

Everybody's in every position to negotiate for everything This is called diplomacy ...

The second , neither are we in a hurry , you have to spend more since you dont have a road line upto the glacier so you have to airlift everything , your presence doesn't threaten Northern Areas / KKH

 

[Leader]

man post 113 and 115 are especially amusing , two guys with same id names, same avatars, same number of posts, same flags, thanked and still talked opposite

 

[Ammyy]

man post 113 and 115 are especially amusing , two guys with same id names, same avatars, same number of posts, same flags, thanked and still talked opposite

Only if you can read

post 113

"almost all dominating heights"

post 115

"Yes Pakistan have 15-20 % area of Siachen under their control"