Pak building infrastructure along LoC

[karan.1970]

depreciation that was written off

.. What depreciation method does Pakistan use for territory?? Straight line?? Over how many years??

Are there any tax deductions on this depreciation

---------- Post added at 06:51 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:50 AM ----------

Offtopic , but still is it in your control ?

How does that matter.. We are being totally negative right now.. Counting your losses, and not our gains.

 

[Secur]

How does that matter.. We are being totally negative right now.. Counting your losses, and not our gains.

Our losses ?
Who spends more just to keep Kashmir under oppressive rule ? Does keeping 7 million troops in the valley come cheap for you ? Or the Siachin , where you spend millions of INR per month ?

 

[karan.1970]

Our losses ?
Who spends more just to keep Kashmir under oppressive rule ? Does keeping 7 million troops in the valley come cheap for you ? Or the Siachin , where you spend millions of INR per month ?

It may not come cheap, but so far, it seems, we can afford it (now I guess we will move to poverty in India )

 

[ares]

Gained 85 000 + km2 of Kashmir ... What is it called a defeat ?

Your unprovoked invasion of princely state of Kashmir back in 47, was the biggest mistakes of your existence.

You not only pushed, then neutral Kashmiri rulers to India for help ..you made sure Kashmir will become a part of India by invading its territory.

Had you used your brains and not balls ..you would have realized instead invading you could have negotiated with the King ..perhaps offer him more incentives even partial autonomy ..so that he would sign over kashmir to Pakistan.

It is but your Cavalier attitude and almost complete lack of diplomacy responsible for this Kashmir mess.

But even your invasion only succeed ..while you were fighting untrained Kashmiri soldiers, once Indian army entered into fray, you only lost land ...You were driven off from outskirts of Srinagar back to a tiny strip of land of what you now call Azad Kashmir.

 

[Secur]

It may not come cheap, but so far, it seems, we can afford it (now I guess we will move to poverty in India )

Not to mention , the astronomical defense budget you have to maintain to counter self made enemies Pakistan and China

 

[Secur]

Your unprovoked invasion of princely state of Kashmir back in 47, was the biggest mistakes of your existence.

You not only pushed, then neutral Kashmiri rulers to India for help ..you made sure Kashmir will become a part of India by invading its territory.

It is but your Cavalier attitude and almost complete lack of diplomacy responsible for this Kashmir mess.

But even your invasion only succeed ..while you were fighting untrained Kashmiri soldiers, once Indian army entered into fray, you only lost land ...You were driven off from outskirts of Srinagar back to a tiny strip of land of what you now call Azad Kashmir.

Seriously you have no idea of the history of the tribal invasion ... The conspiracy of giving Kashmir to India was made long before Pakistan even thought of invading Kashmir ... The muslim majority was all for acceding to Pakistan ... Was a plebiscite ever held like Junagarh or Did Maharaja accept the likes of Muslims ? Independence was never an option that time ... Otherwise you wouldn't have invaded Hyderabad ... The strategic Gurdaspur district was given to India by Mountbatten so that it can have access to Kashmir ... After the Indian troops landed in Srinagar , Jinnah ordered Gracy to send PA into Kashmir which he refused ... He then asked the tribals to re capture Kashmir on popular muslims demand and no we were never in Srinagar ... Whom do you think liberated Skardu and Gilgit ? The tribals ? No , it was Gilgit scouts ... and if you were so successful , why did Nehru go running to the UN to ask for ceasefire ?

 

[NirmalKrish]

Our losses ?
Who spends more just to keep Kashmir under oppressive rule ? Does keeping 7 million troops in the valley come cheap for you ? Or the Siachin , where you spend millions of INR per month ?

we spend only 2% of GDP on defense as a whole you have aid coming in left right and center and that is still not enough.

 

[karan.1970]

Not to mention , the astronomical defense budget you have to maintain to counter self made enemies Pakistan and China

Did you compare the Defence budget of India and Pakistan as a percentage of their respective GDPs ??? I guess not..

---------- Post added at 07:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:11 AM ----------

Seriously you have no idea of the history of the tribal invasion ... The conspiracy of giving Kashmir to India was made long before Pakistan even thought of invading Kashmir ... The muslim majority was all for acceding to Pakistan ... Was a plebiscite ever held like Junagarh or Did Maharaja accept the likes of Muslims ? Independence was never an option that time ... Otherwise you wouldn't have invaded Hyderabad ... The strategic Gurdaspur district was given to India by Mountbatten so that it can have access to Kashmir ... After the Indian troops landed in Srinagar , Jinnah ordered Gracy to send PA into Kashmir which he refused ... He then asked the tribals to re capture Kashmir on popular muslims demand and no we were never in Srinagar ... Whom do you think liberated Skardu and Gilgit ? The tribals ? No , it was Gilgit scouts ... and if you were so successful , why did Nehru go running to the UN to ask for ceasefire ?

Your story is a little backwards. Indian troops landed after the invasion that forced the King to accede to India..And yes, the tribals were at the Srinagar city.. Wiki and a million other sources are full of this story.. Read it up..

 

[deepakclaw]

congrats 1 millionth therad thae started elsewhere and end up as india vs pakistan

 

[ares]

Seriously you have no idea of the history of the tribal invasion ... The conspiracy of giving Kashmir to India was made long before Pakistan even thought of invading Kashmir ... The muslim majority was all for acceding to Pakistan ... Was a plebiscite ever held like Junagarh ? ... The strategic Gurdaspur district was given to India by Mountbatten so that it can have access to Kashmir ... After the Indian troops landed in Srinagar , Jinnah ordered Gracy to send PA into Kashmir which he refused ... He then asked the tribals to re capture Kashmir on popular muslims demand ... Whom do you think liberated Skardu and Gilgit ? The tribals ? No , it was Gilgit scouts ... and if you were so successful , why did Nehru go running to the UN to ask for ceasefire ?

Seriously i do have an idea of what you are talking about.
It was a conspiracy ..but conspiracy was.."that your leaders had convinced your tribals, since King of Kashmir is a Hindu ..he will side with secular India and not Islamic Pakistan."

Because of these preconceived notions instead of negotiation with the King ..you guys invaded Kashmir and pushed him to sign accession treaty with India..It was only then India intervened and airlifted troops to Kashmir ..and pushed back your tribal militia led by your armed forces from outskirts of Srinagar airport..and prevented fall of Kashmir.

Nehru approaching UN on Kashmir issue was one of the biggest blunders of his political life(second was his recognizing Tibet as part of China)..he being idealist did not realise the ramifications of his move in the real world.

 

[Secur]

Your story is a little backwards. Indian troops landed after the invasion that forced the King to accede to India..And yes, the tribals were at the Srinagar city.. Wiki and a million other sources are full of this story.. Read it up..

I dont believe the official BR source being quoted at Wiki ... So no need ...

 

[NirmalKrish]

I dont believe the official BR source being quoted at Wiki ... So no need ...

nice to know, returned back to your turtle shell have we?

 

[Secur]

nice to know, returned back to your turtle shell have we?

Just like you dont believe countless other sources ...

 

[karan.1970]

I dont believe the official BR source being quoted at Wiki ... So no need ...

Pick up any source except the Pakistani history text books or terrorist propaganda, and you should be fine

 

[Secur]

Pick up any source except the Pakistani history text books or terrorist propaganda, and you should be fine

Why not i pick the official UN resolutions calling upon both parties to hold plebiscite which my country adheres to ?