Our army didn't intrude into Ladakh: China

[nair]

After reading the heading.... i was like..... If it is not chinese army then it might be the Aliens who came in their UFO as reported earlier j/k

 

[Psyops]

It's funny the Indians claiming that they were united before the British. That's laughable. The British united India, everyone knows this.

 

[Jackdaws]

The upper and lower Egypt was united the most of time through out history, so it was a continuous empire through out its history from 3000BC to 20BC, the longest historical empire throughout time. Same with China through out last 2000 years. India is a land with many kingdom until British unified it. Sure, it has empires that united most of India today like Maurya or Moghul empire, but they are created for themselves, not a continuation of an India.

Right - no one is doubting the existence of the Egyptian empire but that is not the same as a nation state in the modern sense of the word. Also - you still have to explain the 16 and 10 kingdoms of China.

Once India loses a major war against China many states including the Northeast will secede.

Yawn! Once China grows the balls for a major war with India we will see...

 

[Jackdaws]

There was no such thing as 'India' before the British came. That's why the British always say they civilised the Indians. Remember Winston Churchill's famous quote about Indians.

"I hate Indians, they are a beastly people with a beastly religion" - Winston Churchill

You really need to get over this fixation of what white leaders say as the gospel truth - I know they use your country as one giant sweatshop but grow a backbone for crying out loud.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

Some Chinese seem to act as if they know anything about India or this region.One can only laugh and pity their poor sense of history.

India has been united many times before the British came, under the Mauryans, then the Tughlaqs, then the Mughals after which the British came.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

What nonsense. The vast majority of Indian Muslims want their own country. The Sikhs tried to have independence in 1984 and was brutally crushed. India is a divided that is why India has more separatist groups than the rest of the world combined. It's that bad.

1.The vast majority of Indian Muslims want their own country.- Where are you getting this from ? Please post some authentic source.Please make sure your source suggests vast majority very clearly.

2.The Sikhs tried to have independence in 1984 and was brutally crushed.- Are you sure that movement was supported by vast majority of the Sikhs ? Who crushed this movement for the main part ?Punjab police. Do you know Sikhs constituted the majority in Punjab police ? Please get authentic , valid and citable sources for these as well.

3.India is a divided that is why India has more separatist groups than the rest of the world combined- How many of these groups listed on the internet are active ? How many have no more than 50 or 100 members ?Cared to do any research on this ?

Please don't make a fool out of yourself. Research , then comment.

 

[Jackdaws]

1.The vast majority of Indian Muslims want their own country.- Where are you getting this from ? Please post some authentic source.Please make sure your source suggests vast majority very clearly.

2.The Sikhs tried to have independence in 1984 and was brutally crushed.- Are you sure that movement was supported by vast majority of the Sikhs ? Who crushed this movement for the main part ?Punjab police. Do you know Sikhs constituted the majority in Punjab police ? Please get authentic , valid and citable sources for these as well.

3.India is a divided that is why India has more separatist groups than the rest of the world combined- How many of these groups listed on the internet are active ? How many have no more than 50 or 100 members ?Cared to do any research on this ?

Please don't make a fool out of yourself. Research , then comment.

Man, please - how can they possibly research? Their communist state prevents the free flow of information - even if he does manage to research - there will hardly be a credible source. Cut the Chinese some slack I say - imagine if you were not free. It is like asking an African on a cotton plantation in Louisiana in 1813 to throw off those chains and start living like a free man. It is easier said than done.

 

[Srinivas]

First of all, you are not even at elementary level when in regard to Chinese history. CPC was continued from ROC and ROC inherited from Qing dynasty.

First of all the democracy movement against the Imperial Chinese emperor took place and then Mao lead the people's revolution by killing Millions of his people, pests etc..etc....

The fact here is one party dictatorship from CCP is legitimate??

do they represent entire China??

They are not, since CCP do not consider people's opinion, on the other hand India is a democracy and people vote for parliament and they are doing it for almost 70 years.

So based on that People of India do support India as a country but the opinion of Chinese is still unknown and legitimacy of CCP is still not verified and the existence of China under CCP is a disputed one.

Given voting rights I am sure Xingiang and Tibet will denounce Han chinese.

Tell your B.S to some one else not me.

Mughal were invaders that replaced another previous invaders. These empires do not regard itself as a "successor" of the previous empires, but as an invader that replaced another empire. The British was just another invader after a long line of invaders.

As if Mongol invaders are successors of Chinese kings and after Mongol emperor those who ruled china are from Mongols

Laughable and logic fail

 

[faithfulguy]

First of all the democracy movement against the Imperial Chinese emperor took place and then Mao lead the people's revolution by killing Millions of his people, pests etc..etc....

The fact here is one party dictatorship from CCP is legitimate??

do they represent entire China??

They are not, since CCP do not consider people's opinion, on the other hand India is a democracy and people vote for parliament and they are doing it for almost 70 years.

So based on that People of India do support India as a country but the opinion of Chinese is still unknown and legitimacy of CCP is still not verified and the existence of China under CCP is a disputed one.

Given voting rights I am sure Xingiang and Tibet will denounce Han chinese.

Tell your B.S to some one else not me.



As if Mongol invaders are successors of Chinese kings and after Mongol emperor those who ruled china are from Mongols

Laughable and logic fail

We are talking about the British created India. Not about the type of government is in the country now.

 

[INDIC]

We are talking about the British created India. Not about the type of government is in the country now.

What about this. Looting of Chinese pie.

 

[Android]

We are talking about the British created India. Not about the type of government is in the country now.

When British left there were more than 500 independent princely states scattered all over the subcontinent governed by local monarchs . India's first Home Minister Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel aka Iron Man of India was responsible for successfully making most of the kingdom join India so he mas the man who who created modern day Republic of India not Britishers

 

[Psyops]

You really need to get over this fixation of what white leaders say as the gospel truth - I know they use your country as one giant sweatshop but grow a backbone for crying out loud.

Churchill knew about India and Indians more than anyone else because India was his colony. I would listen to Winston Churchill's opinion about India before I listen to anyone else. There was a quote he made that said the British civilised the Indians because they gave the Indians the British law, British education system, British political system and British language.

Churchill just called a spade a spade.

 

[faithfulguy]

What about this. Looting of Chinese pie.

China was weak so many western countries carve out concessions in China. This slicing up stopped after Republic of China was found in 1911, even though the concession were not returned to China until WWII.

India was created by the British as a country after British unified the whole India. Without the British, India would be more like western Europe or Balkans.

When British left there were more than 500 independent princely states scattered all over the subcontinent governed by local monarchs . India's first Home Minister Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel aka Iron Man of India was responsible for successfully making most of the kingdom join India so he mas the man who who created modern day Republic of India not Britishers

The Princely states were de facto controlled by the British. But yes, India has to put some efforts to unified them. By then, Indians were taught by the British about creating a nation.

 

[INDIC]

China was weak so many western countries carve out concessions in China. This slicing up stopped after Republic of China was found in 1911, even though the concession were not returned to China until WWII.

India was created by the British as a country after British unified the whole India. Without the British, India would be more like western Europe or Balkans.

They didn't conquer China becuse your Monarch led them loot China.

While your last Qing Emperor Puyi tried to create Manchu homeland "Manchuquo" with the help of Japanese.

 

[Jackdaws]

Churchill knew about India and Indians more than anyone else because India was his colony. I would listen to Winston Churchill's opinion about India before I listen to anyone else. There was a quote he made that said the British civilised the Indians because they gave the Indians the British law, British education system, British political system and British language.

Churchill just called a spade a spade.

Good for you. Here is a Japanese quote on Nanking -
"We had fun killing Chinese. We caught some innocent Chinese and either buried them alive, or pushed them into a fire, or beat them to death with clubs. When they were half dead we pushed them into ditches and burned them, torturing them to death. Everyone gets his entertainment this way. Its like killing dogs and cats."

I guess because China was a Japanese colony, you believe this to be gospel as well.