What's new

“Okay! We Won’t Eat Beef” Indian Muslims

. .
Well if I was an Indian Muslim, I would also not beef only to respect my Hindu neighbour. But I would expect the same respect from them too.

The fact of the matter is, these proclaimations mean nothing now, India is now completely in the grips of right wing fascists, with their borrowed nazi salutes and policies. I have seen how Indian Muslims live, they are one of the most poor and backward people, I do not see any result of this mythical appeasement. Just another bogeyman invented by a right wing ideology to de-humanise the other.

The talk of Hindu right wing fanatics on PDF and in India is eerily similar to the ranting of our own right wing reactionary folk in Pakistan. My own elders also said that there is a large number of Hindus who have bottled up their hatred for Muslims for centuries and it will explode one day when they are at the helms. Now these elders were Brahmins who converted to Islam and they understood the true mentality of these extremists and witnessed it first hand in Kashmir during the Dogra rule. It seems to be coming to pass indeed.
 
.
We are not a Hindu Taliban country because had we been Taliban, we would have been your fast friend.

You guys are Hindu Taliban.

The degree of violence is because you are Hindus. That's all.
 
. .
How does one attain beef without cow slaughter my Bharti friend?
Well .. India is the biggest exporter of Buffalo Meat... which is a supplement of Cow Meat... then there are government guidelines that allow a certain kid of cow slaughter.. majority of India Muslim population have bee using that historically... becaue Caw slaughter laws have been in place since 1954... this latest randi rona is a hogwash.
 
.
Well.. we work hard.. pay taxes and built a nation.. and of course we are also sustaining a ton of mufatkhors in the name of subsidy.

You are not the only ones working hard. Or paying taxes.

I work hard. I pay more tax than 50 of you here.

Should I not get to eat what I want in my own country?

If not, why not? I'm working. I'm paying huge taxes.

Answer.
 
. . .
Should I not get to eat what I want in my own country?

If not, why not? I'm working. I'm paying huge taxes.

No you will eat only what your states allows you to eat. I think eating is not banned but slaughter is banned but if animals can not be slaughtered than how can you eat that?
 
.
b
Why do you think Pakistan should open their arms for Indian Muslims? They have their own nation and their own fight. Kashmiris are the only ones that we have affinity for because they are our own people. Since you want to be a smart pants Hindu, can you tell me where 'jiziyah' is practiced today? In what nation is it practiced?
bro i will reply tomorrow
have to do some urgent work now
will keep this discussion open
 
. .
You are not the only ones working hard. Or paying taxes.

I work hard. I pay more tax than 50 of you here.

Should I not get to eat what I want in my own country?

If not, why not? I'm working. I'm paying huge taxes.

Answer.
Great if you pay more taxes than all of us... You must be getting certificate of appreciations from Income Tax department. You can eat your Bada as long you get it form a legal Shop... whats the fuss...no one is stopping you from doing that. Whats the fuss about than.. or may be you belong to those illegal traders community who are suddenly finding their profits shrink so you are making hue and cry.
 
.
Trying to find some answers from the past to address the situation prevailing now
M.A. Jinnah on Hindu-Muslim question (April 17, 1938;Calcutta)
"Although some of the pronouncements of the President and other leaders of the Congress at Haripura created an impression of a really genuine desire for the settlement of the Hindu-Muslim question, ....yet there is no slackening on the part of the Congress in the determination of their set purpose to annihilate every other party, and particularly the All-India Muslim League.
The Congress attitude, so far as it can be summoned up, is first that the Communal Award must go lock, stock and barrel; secondly, that there must be no separate electorates, and thirdly, that there must be no differential franchise, and if possible, there should be no reservation of seats of any community.Mussalmans will be wiped out from securing any adequate representation either in the legislatures or in the municipal, local and district boards- as did happen in Bihar recently, since the Government have even removed the cumulative voting which existed before they assumed office. It is no use masquerading under the name of nationalism. The Congress is a Hindu body mainly. It is begging the whole question to say that 'we are eager to do our very best to arrive at an agreed solution' and qualify it by saying 'consistently with the fundamental principles of nationalism' as if the Muslim League were opposed to the fundamental principles of nationalism. Muslims have made it clear more than once that, besides the question of religion, culture, language and personal laws, there is another question, equally of life and death for them, and that their future destiny and fate are dependent upon their securing definitely their political rights, their due share in the national life, the Government, and the administration of the country.
They will fight for it till the last ditch, and all the dreams and notions of Hindu Raj must be abandoned. They will not be submerged or dominated and they will not surrender so long as there is life in them." (M.A. Jinnah 1938)
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom