What's new

No cow slaughtering in Pakistan’s border district, not under compulsion but respect

Areesh

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
45,157
Reaction score
3
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
KARACHI: Tharo Khan, a resident of Islamkot town of Tharparkar, bought a goat for sacrifice on Eidul Adha. This cost him Rs. 18,000 ($146). He could get a share in a cow which would cost him less than Rs. 6,000 ($49) but he opted for goat. The reason is not “affordability” but “respect for the fellow citizens practicing another faith.”

“Sacrifice (slaughtering animal) is a religious obligation which I have to fulfil. However, at the same time I have a social obligation to take care of the sentiments of my Hindu friends, who make up 90 percent of our town,” Khan told Arab News.

While the slaughtering of cows and subsequent lynching of Muslims who are the minority faith in India often makes headlines, in the Pakistani border district of Tharparkar the majority of Muslims opt to not slaughter cows to avoid hurting the feelings of their Hindu fellows.

Tharparkar, situated at the India-Pakistan border, has the lowest Human Development Index of all the districts in Sindh. It has a 1,649,661 population (1.6 million), as per census of 2017. Of these 1.6 million, well over 40 percent are Hindus.

However, in urban areas, including its headquarter Mithi and Tehsil towns of Diplo, Islamkot, Chachro, Dahli, Nagarparkar and Kaloi, Hindus forms majority of the population. In Islamkot Hindus are more than 90 percent.

“We are faced with drought and have the lowest human development index but we are rich in terms of love, respect and brotherhood,” Kaldeep Kumar, 40, and president of the Islamkot traders’ association, told Arab News.

Kumar on Wednesday visited his Muslim friends to greet them at Eid; he ate sweets and grilled mutton, since his Muslim friends like other Tharis don’t slaughter the cow.

“Hindus of Thar arrange Iftar dinners for the Muslim friends in the fasting month of Ramadan. They (Muslims) attend our religious rituals and festivals,” said Kumar.

“Although not prohibited by law, there is an unannounced ban on the slaughter of cow, which is sacred to Hindus. This ban is however not forced but self-imposed and reflects the centuries-old interfaith harmony,” said Abdul Ghani Bajeer, a local journalist.

“This is not confined to Eid. You can’t find a single of a dozen of meat shops across the district which may be offering cow’s meat to its customers,” Bajeer told Arab News. “In the Muslim weddings, serving food of cow meat is being avoided as many Hindus also attend the wedding ceremonies.”

At Eid, the locals chose to slaughter goats but in some cases if they slaughter a cow, it’s done away from the eyes of Hindu fellow citizens out of respect for their religious feelings.

Bajeer said that over the past few years, different welfare organizations including Al-Khidmat Foundation, Human Relief Foundation, Darul Uloom Karachi, Al-Mustafa Trust, have started arranging sacrifices for the underprivileged local Muslim communities. “But local volunteers make sure that slaughtering process is being done in closed spaces and the meat doesn’t reach the Hindus,” he said.

Piaro Shawani, the 40-year-old Hindu owner of Café Thar in Mithi, said that Tharparkar is backward in resources but is wealthiest due to its interfaith harmony, brotherhood, respect and love. “In the rainy season, we celebrate the rain related festival together. We also attend each other’s religious festivals,” he said.

Abdul Rehman Otho, the 45-year-old principal of a private school in Diplo town of Thar, said that there is no prohibition on slaughtering cow. “No Hindu can stop us from slaughtering (the cow) but we have inherited this legacy of not hurting the feelings of our fellow Hindus from our forefathers,” Otho told Arab News. “Hindu-Muslim women are even more attached to each other.”

Advocate Faqir Sagir, general secretary of the Mithi Bar Association, said: “This interfaith harmony leads to a tolerant society where the crime rate is low. We have a zero crime ratio.”

Ghansham Das, the 60-year-old former chairman of Islamkot City union council, said: “If we are not asked by someone about it we even don’t remember about cow slaughtering.”

In our area, people of two different faiths live together but this is a blessing for us not a curse, unlike what we see in many places around the world. “We are not only an example for the rest of our country but for the entire world. We participate in their festivals and they (Muslims) in ours.”

Amar Guriro, who has reported about Thar Desert extensively, said that Thar Desert is a hub of religious coexistence and interfaith harmony. “People of Sindh are emotionally attached to their motherland, language and culture, more than their religion. For Sindhi people, one’s religion or faith is not important but someone who loves their motherland, speaks their language, and practices Sindhi culture is important,” Guriro said.

The Muslim majority has always taken care of our sentiments so other countries, especially our neighboring India, should take a lesson from it as well,” Kaldeep Kumar said.

http://www.arabnews.com/node/1360936/world
 
The difference between the mentality of a nation.
One is based upon protection of Islamic values and lifestyle which includes respect for other religions.
The other is based upon trying to remove the mental burdens of being ruled for hundreds of years by lashing out at insecurities and aimless attempts at proving themselves.
 
How is refraining from cow slaughter respect for them? I see it as an insult to Islam.
Cows today, idols tomorrow?
 
There are other and better ways to respect Pakistan's minorities. Protect their rights and provide them safety. But denying yourself something that's permissible in Islam is not respectful to anyone. I doubt they would want to deny others their rights.
 
I fail to understand how can killing innocent living beings and spilling blood be a religious obligation? Why no modern muslim questions this barbaric practise?
 
Why no modern muslim questions this barbaric practise?

Why is it for Muslims only to question their faith? Why no modern Hindu (if such a person exists in the first place) questions millions of backward retarded practices in his ...... whatever you call Hinduism a culture or a religion or whatever it is.

No one questions when a fake santa happens every year, no one bats an eyelid every year when so much resources and money is wasted on new year eve, or a valentines day .......... but come eid and Muslim rituals ... oh its barbaric, oh its backward, oh its this oh its that ............ its your ignorance and your intolerance ..... nothing more nothing less.


I fail to understand how can killing innocent living beings and spilling blood be a religious obligation?

Good that you accept your failure ..........
 
I fail to understand how can killing innocent living beings and spilling blood be a religious obligation? Why no modern muslim questions this barbaric practise?

Those "innocent" animals are raised for their meat in the first place just like any other crop.

Although not one it's original purposes but this festival clearly shows that life of any human whether he is a Muslim, Christian, Brahmin or Dalit is clearly more valuable than any animal especially a bovine. A lesson that has been largely forgotten in the pseudo vegetarianism that is being preached
 
Last edited:
The Muslims in the cities of Islamic Spain (Al Andalus) treated the non-Muslims in the best possible way. In return, the non-Muslims showed respect to the sensibilities of the Muslims and would circumcise their own children and refrain from eating pork.

Remember this was an Islamic Empire few centuries ago! Compare the Islamic Caliphate in Spain to “secular” modern India.
 
Once again Pakistan taking the moral high ground.
We gave nothing but love to Mr. Sidu.
Now we are giving love to our Hindu citizens.

Of course this will never be reported in Hindutva media.
Even if it is reported it won't make a difference. Bharti hindus have a dogmatic hateful nature which can't be changed.
 
I fail to understand how can killing innocent living beings and spilling blood be a religious obligation? Why no modern muslim questions this barbaric practise?
It's not barbaric, it's a part of life. We have been eating meat since the beginning, it was crucial to our evolutionary development and we will continue to eat meat.

During Eid, we sacrifice this animal and give it out to the poor. The animal is cut from the fatty tissue below the neck, where it does not feel pain, to the animal - it feels like sleeping.

Before Islam was introduced to South Asia. Hindus used to practice human sacrifice, forced widow burning, and many other barbaric practices. (senseless) Animal sacrifice is still an integral part of Hinduism for many Hindus.

You guys kill "innocent" living beings, aka plants.
 
The difference between the mentality of a nation.
One is based upon protection of Islamic values and lifestyle which includes respect for other religions.
The other is based upon trying to remove the mental burdens of being ruled for hundreds of years by lashing out at insecurities and aimless attempts at proving themselves.
Good but still not much different situation in Pakistan about minorities. Molvi circles around minorities day and night and forcing them to change religion.
Many communities are not safe in Pakistan like hazara community in Baluchistan , Christians living in Pakistan, & others.
Things are improved at some level but still lots of work to be done.
Religious bigotry, sectarian fight and extremism is still issue , but as I said things are improved at some percentage.
 
I fail to understand how can killing innocent living beings and spilling blood be a religious obligation? Why no modern muslim questions this barbaric practise?
Unlike you most of the world eats Chicken, Mutton, Beaf, Seafood i.e Animal Meat.
So do we like all normal people.
And on this festival we distribute the meat to the poor so that they can eat it too as it is an expensive food which poverty struck masses fail to have rest of the year. Their is nothing barbaric in it. Your ancestors have been hunters for centuries before they learned to farm non-perishable store able crops like Wheat Rice Corn Oat grains etc which is not natural vegetation pattern.
Anyways no arguing on beliefs everyone is free in his belief.
 

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom