New Pakistans in making in India

[footmarks]

Are not you confusing ethnicity with Identity?
Indian Ethnic != Indian National ( where India is used a nation's name)

No. I am talking about india as a geographical identity - the land between himalayas and indian ocean. Indian nationals are indian passport holders. Ethnic Indians are all people living in the indian subcontinent.

 

[Nalini]

The Muslims in India are thanking their stars for their forefathers not doing the same blunder like the many Barelvis, Deobandis, Mohajirs, Ahmadiyyas & Shias who went with great Islamic spirit & passion to Pakistan. The minorities in India at-least can speak any nonsense like Zakir Naik & the mullah in this video & still be alive.

Pakistan should worry about the muslims in its country rather than worry about Muslims of India. Indian Muslims & the world can see what's the state of existing Pakistan. The people of today's India are no more fools like the previous generations where we had a culture of Non Violence & Sacrifice. Gandhi is from Gujarat so is Modi. Today if somebody in India will ask for separate land, they will only get death.

One day hopefully these Muslim talks & hatred of India over religion will take you to a very bad humiliation, when you are forced to shed the very religion for which, Pakistan was created. I wonder how this forum will look like if the Muslims of Pakistan are converted to some other religion. Where would you relate your culture. You can still extend a hand of friendship & love to revive your culture & roots rather than running to Arabs, Turks & Chinese, so that, you can use your time for something productive than waste time on such posts.

 

[countryman]

No. I am talking about india as a geographical identity - the land between himalayas and indian ocean. Indian nationals are indian passport holders. Ethnic Indians are all people living in the indian subcontinent.

Like I said before you're confusing you're confusing Indian ethnicity with Indian (Your Country's Trade Mark Name). Anything that belongs to Indian ethnicity doesn't necessarily attribute to "India". Also, in terms of geography, it is no longer "India" - it is year 2017.

 

[El Sidd]

Culture is influenced by aspirations too. Case in point - you would not like to be identified as of indian origin (though most likely that is the case, india being the geographical identity having culture that is nowadays identified as hindus). Muslims in the sub-continent aspire to align themselves as arabs or turks (a class higher perhaps).

See that is the kind of generalization that stops much of the growth. Muslims in India, well the learned ones, do not see them nor aspire themselves to be Arab or Turk.
There is a Muslim identity which only a Muslim can help you understand. and i am sorry if you met racists who think that being somehow connected to A-rabs or I-ran or the Turk identity somehow makes them superior.
Sadly this racist attitude or 'being better' attitude is not only a muslim monopoly in India. Caste system dissection may help you understand that.

 

[KhanSahab]

He is a brave man

 

[Zee-shaun]

Wow, you know it better than Indian muslims. There is nothing called Modi's India.

In less than three years Modi has changed a semi secular country into an extremist hindutva society, for sure he's a god for Hindus. Today's India is Modi's India.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

My friend this is not fundamental thinking, Indian muslims are desperate to survive in Modi's India. Modi's India is not secular, its even more fundamentalist than Taliban. Even Taliban dont kill people for eating beef.

Except Talibans kill for practising other faiths, not allowing women's to study, not allowing them to wear what they wish, and marrying a girl as soon as 14...

Muslims all around India are living without any issue. Those Muslims in the north who dont have any work other than making babies are the only one creating issues.

 

[Nexus]

Well, they tried in 2002 In my own state. I must say it was Awesome.

 

[313ghazi]

Pakistan is not a natural nation state. It is not based on history, ethnicity, geography. Pakistan is much more than that. Pakistan is an ideal, it is a project, it's frontiers are open to change. When Indian Muslims need a home, Pakistan will be that home, wherever it is geographically.

 

[Rational guy]

I hope Indians dont get infuriated over such incidences and start treating muslims living in India like myanmar is doing to rohingiya muslims.

 

[Sam.]

I didn't questioned their patriotism. I said mostly there are hindu-muslim divide in north India. Terror hotbed lie in Kerala, WB and Hyderabad.

Unification is more powerful than divide if you don't believe me then visit our place. See how many Hindus celebrating Eid and vice versa. But media has no interest in those do they?

I am fed up with people who hear rumors and news from prestitutes and believe it to be reality.

 

[Tom M]

Don't know about new Pakistan, but new Nepal is under progress : Darjeeling Unrest

What a Joke, they are asking for a separate state not a country. I hope you know the difference between both ??

We have witnessed similar agitations in the past and had heard the concerns and taken appropriate corrective measures as well, the reason why India with 14 states and 6 Union Territories in 1950 is now having 29 states and 7 UT's. So much for bursting you Happy Darjeeling Bubble. LOL

 

[TMA]

As @haviZsultan has said earlier that pakistan is a state of mind, it can occur anytime anywhere. So new pakistans can crop up not only in india but throughout the world. May be in europe, russia, america and africa.
I hope secular ideology pravails and people can learn to live with people of other faiths peacefully.

This maulana Barkati is very fundamental in his thinking, he rejects everything that a modern democracy stands for.
I am just waiting for the day he pledges allegiance to isis.

It would be wise of the Government of Bharat to try to include Muslims a bit like what the Russian Federation has done into the life of Bharat without compromising on their faith, otherwise should she continue appeasing the extremist anti-Muslim sentiment that exists in RSS types et al, then Muslims of Bharat will no doubt seek to make their own.

Indian or Hindu is a geographic and cultural identity. Even those who are born in Pakistan or Bangladesh are Indian. I agree you are a separate land now bcz of borders (just from few years back ) but roots are same "an Indian''. This is the reason we call south Asia region as Indian subcontinent.

Yes the real Indians are now the Pakistanis and the real India is Pakistan post 1947. Okay NW Bharat can have some claim to it but Bharat really should be called Gangia in English. Bangladesh is not Indian, Afghanistan is more Indian than Bangladesh.

 

[YeBeWarned]

desh mai Jehad chor den gay
@The Sandman @Zibago @Hell hound @django @Kaptaan bhai yeh koi new Liquid form ka Jehad aya hai Market mai ?

 

[Zibago]

I have no affinity for Muslims of India