What's new

New faces of J&K’s new politics

That's okay. I didn't expect you to understand. My highlighting of the farcical nature of Indian democracy is for the benefit of non-Indians. You are beyond help.
I can't do anything but laugh at your lack of understanding of the matter in general.

But it is good that you started reading what coalition governments are. But there is a small issue though, the state of Jammu and Kashmir had special laws, the "gift" of Article 370 of Indian constitution, which does not require a legislative assembly to dissolve a government but a failure of government like this case when there was no new government formed after BJP left the alliance. Governor rule can then be applied.

India has not engaged in a democratic process, but rather in a seizure of power by a party with minority vote share in Kashmir. During that period of seizure of power without majority consent, the constitution of Kashmir was rewritten still without majority consent. Now, anyone who wishes to restore article 370 in Kashmir will be charged with sedition.
Democratic process you're talking is asking the public to take policy decisions. Fundamentally India is a democratic country, the only issue here is if Governor's rule was imposed illegally. Now, wtf is the constitution of Kashmir? Kashmir has no constitution, to begin with, it was the Indian constitution with special status for the state. Whoever rules the central government with a mandate can re-write these provisions, in fact, the special provisions were re-written numerous times before by the Congress government who had the mandate.
Indian parliament is superior to any legislature in making constitutional decisions. Article 370 was not created by the state of Jammu and Kashmir, but the President of India with the 'blessings' of the Indian parliament. By MPs we elected, so it's only natural that the same MPs voted to repeal it.

Answer a simple question, was Article 370 illegal provision created by the President and Parliament? If it isn't, then repealing it by the same President and Parliament is not illegal. If it is, then we corrected an old mistake.
 
. .
in a democracy, even constitution can be amended
All is possible in India. Naturally! As per India's constitution, if JnK's constituent assembly had recommended the abrogation of article 370, then Governor bhai would have had the authority to do so. However, this constituent assembly was dissolved (to clarify, this specific entity dissolved in 1957) - what to do? Hmm. Governor bhai has overcome this dilemma and followed your advice and just changed the constitution! What a wonderful timeless solution!

"The order was issued using the third clause of Article 370, which authorised the President of India to declare the article inoperative with exceptions and modifications, if recommended by the (non-existent) state constituent assembly to do so.[30] To circumvent the legal issue of the non-existent state constituent assembly, the President used the Clause (I) of Article 370, which conferred him with the power to modify the Indian Constitution on subjects related to Jammu and Kashmir. So he first added a new clause to Article 367, which deals with interpretation of the Constitution. He replaced the phrase 'Constituent Assembly of the State' with 'Legislative Assembly of the State'.[41][42] Since the state legislative assembly has been suspended, the order says that any reference to the legislative assembly will be construed as a reference to the Governor of Jammu and Kashmir.[41][30] The governor is an appointee of the Central government. Therefore, the Indian Parliament now functions for the state legislative assembly.[30]"

"On August 5, 2019, the president of India issued the Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 2019, C.O. 272, pursuant to article 370(1) of the Constitution of India. Constitutional lawyer Gautam Bhatia states that this “constitutes the basis for everything that follows.” The order stipulates that, with the “concurrence of the Government of State of Jammu and Kashmir,” “[a]ll the provisions of the Constitution, as amended from time to time, shall apply in relation to the State of Jammu and Kashmir.” Moreover, since the government could not directly rely on article 370(3) to abrogate other articles, it sought to use its powers under article 370(1) to amend article 367, the interpretation clause of the Constitution, so that references to “Government of the State [Jammu and Kashmir]” in article 370 would be construed as the governor of Jammu and Kashmir (§ 2), and the expression “Constituent Assembly of the State” in article 370(3) will be read as referring to the current legislative assembly of Kashmir. "

So, because the specific constituent assembly doesn't exist to give me the recommendations needed, let's change that to any "current legislative assembly"....and let's also change "government of the state" (because we just dissolved that too) to be construed as the "governor of JnK", who - surprise surprise - happens to be me. And I can do all this without any consent from the elected representatives of JnK.

Governor bhai can modify modify modify. Kya zabardasst cheez hain yeh constitution and democracy.
which does not require a legislative assembly to dissolve a government
Again, dissolution of the parliament is not the issue. It's wot u done while the parliament was suspended. A legislative assembly recommendation WAS INDEED needed to annul the constitution (see above) - but in India, no problem, governor bhai makes up rules as he bobbles along.
 
.
The recent DDC polls has seen the redrawing of political lines and the emergence of a new leadership — from a law student in North Kashmir to a dentist in the South, a school teacher in Jammu to the wife of a seasoned politician in Kashmir. The Indian Express in Jammu tell some of their stories.

View attachment 702888
Safeena Baig, Irfan Hafeez Lone, Minha Lateef, Asim Qureshi. (From left to right)


The recent DDC polls, the first democratic exercise in J&K since the Centre’s August 5 move, has seen the redrawing of political lines and the emergence of a new leadership — from a law student in North Kashmir to a dentist in the South, a school teacher in Jammu to the wife of a seasoned politician in Kashmir. The Indian Express in Jammu tell some of their stories.

Shabir Ahmad Lone, 45, PAGD (NC)
Rohama, Baramulla

A National Conference worker since 1999, Lone was among the mainstream politicians arrested and booked under the Public Safety Act in the aftermath of the constitutional changes to J&K. He spent six months in Srinagar Central Jail, before the UT administration quashed his detention.

“This win is an opportunity to strengthen the PAGD’s position so that we can take on the challenge of restoring J&K’s special status,” he said.

Lone defeated J&K Apni Party candidate Zahoor Ahmad Mir, who too was booked under PSA, by over 1,500 votes.
FIRST ON HIS LIST: “The last time these roads were paved was in 2014. That will be my first priority.”


IRFAN HAFEEZ LONE, 40, Independent
Sangrama, North Kashmir

In the winter of 2007, Irfan Hafeez Lone, then a law student at Kashmir University, staged a sit-in at Jantar Mantar to seek compensation for the losses suffered by J&K under the Indus Water Treaty, marking the beginning of his political activism. Thirteen years and two unsuccessful electoral attempts later, he finally managed to defeat a former legislator, Shoaib Nabi Lone, who was fighting on a J&K Apni Party ticket.

View attachment 702889

A regular panellist on national television, Lone’s first brush with public life began early when, as a child, he would accompany his father Hafizullah Lone, a prominent activist, to meetings and rallies. In 1991, at the height of Kashmir’s days of militancy, when Lone was barely 12 years old, his father was gunned down by unidentified people at his village Wagub.

While in college, Lone would use Right to Information to ask questions of the government. He has also campaigned for industry status to Kashmir’s apple business.

In 2008, after his graduation, Lone unsuccessfully contested the 2008 and 2014 Assembly elections from Sangrama.

“The goodwill my family has earned and my own work on the ground have paid off,” he says. “Now it is my turn to fight for the people, for their political rights, for the special status. I have many differences with the NC and PDP but on the Gupkar declaration, we are on the same page”.

Lone hopes his victory will inspire others. “Activists usually fail in electoral politics — be is Yogendra Yadav, Medha Patkar or Irom Sharmila. But my win as an Independent candidate should encourage many others.”

FIRST ON HIS LIST: Widening of the Srinagar-Baramulla highway. “It has become a death trap,” he says.

SAFEENA BAIG, 47, Independent
Wagoora, North Kashmir

In 2018, Safeena Baig was appointed president of the PDP’s women’s wing. Behind her sudden emergence were her years of political experience as a backstage manager for her husband Muzaffar Hussain Baig, a founding member and patron of the PDP who resigned from the party days before the DDC polls.

While Baig accused the party of not consulting him before leaders of the People’s Alliance for Gupkar Declaration (PAGD) finalised the seat-sharing deal, many believe he was not happy as the seat Safeena wanted to contest went to the National Conference. But Safeena denies this.

“Members of the civil society came to Baig sahib and said we should contest from there. Baig sahib had made a commitment to them and that was why I contested the polls,” she says.

View attachment 702890
Safeena Baig

A lawyer, Safeena graduated from Aligarh Muslim University. But being

the wife of a politician, it was hard to escape politics.

Wagoora saw a tough triangular contest between Safeena, PAGD candidate Shaheena Begum and Apni Party’s Nasreena Firdous (mother of former legislator Shoiab Lone).

But when the results were declared, Safeena had secured a comfortable lead over the PAGD candidate by 1,491 votes.

While she has not formally quit the PDP, she says, “My politics is linked to Baig sahib. Any decision on my future would be also linked to him.”

FIRST ON HER LIST: The constituency has several far-off areas and she hopes to start improving road connectivity.

Minha Lateef, BJP, 22
Kakapora II, Pulwama

The 22-year-old contested and won the Kakapora II territorial constituency, giving the BJP a rare win in South Kashmir. A third-year law student, she is keen to finish her graduation while also ensuring that the basic developmental demands of her constituency are met. “I wanted to make sure I have a background that can support my career in public service,” she says.

View attachment 702891
Minha Lateef

Her father, Lateef Bhat, is a BJP Pradesh unit functionary. With Kakapora one of the seats reserved for women, Bhat urged his daughter to contest. Mihna secured a 14-vote lead, defeating her closest opponent, PDP’s Ruqaya Bano.

FIRST ON HER LIST: Metalled roads for her village, Kakapora

HARBAKSH SINGH, 41, PDP
Tral, South Kashmir

A social worker and a qualified dentist, Dr Singh was elected as a DDC member from Tral, a separatist stronghold in South Kashmir’s Pulwama.

In fact, the mostly Muslim voters of Tral had voted in two Sikh candidates to the Pulwama DDC. “Kashmiriyat is all about communal harmony,” says Singh.

Son of a school teacher, Singh joined the Government Dental College in Srinagar for his graduation. It was here that he had his first brush with student politics. After being associated with the Congress’s student outfit, the National Students Union of India, Singh soon became state general secretary of the Youth Congress.

In 2011, Singh joined PDP as general secretary of the party’s youth wing. “I switched to a regional party because you had access to the leadership — you could meet Mehboobaji whenever you wanted,” he says.



Singh hopes the DDC win will help him serve people better. “Earlier, when people came to me with their problems, I would try and help them, but having to deal with the bureaucracy was frustrating,” he says. “But now that people have voted me to the DDC, I will fight for them.”

FIRST ON HIS LIST: Removing “commission culture”. Also, better electricity and safe drinking water for villages in his constituency.

Peer Shahbaz Ahmad, 31, Independent
Verinag, Anantnag

A former sarpanch from Kapran and a former block president of the Congress, Shahbaz says it is the work he did as chairman of the Block Development Council over the last two years that propelled him to a win in the District Council. However, his decision to contest meant he had to go against his party.

Ahmad says though he had been a ground worker of the Congress for long, “yet, the party gave the ticket to a candidate who has never worked on the ground here”.

View attachment 702892
Peer Shahbaz Ahmad

Ahmad eventually defeated Pradesh Congress chief G A Mir’s son, Naseer Ahmad Mir, who fell short by 630 votes.

“I have worked for the development of the area over the last couple of years and people do see that,” Ahmad added.

FIRST ON HIS LIST: “About 80,000 people of the area depend on a single branch of the J&K Bank in Anantnag. I hope to get a branch of the bank closer to the village.”

Shazia Kouser, 33, Independent
Budhal Old A, Rajouri

Kouser resigned from her job as a government school teacher in Jammu city’s Sunjwan area to contest the DDC polls. She defeated the NC’s Shaheen Akhtar by a margin of 2,446 votes, relegating her aunt and wife of former minister Zulfikar Choudhary (J&K Apni Party), Zubeda Begum, to third place.

“People reached out to my husband Javed Iqbal, who is chairman of Budhal Old Block Development Council, to field someone from the family after the DDC constituency was reserved for women… For me, this is an opportunity to serve people living in these tough terrains. I have made it clear to my husband that I will not sit at home and allow male members of the family to work in my place,” says Kouser who holds a Masters’ in microbiology.

View attachment 702893
Shazia Kouser

Ensuring children of her constituency get to schools is among her priorities. “The government scheme of having a primary school every 3 km and a middle school every 8 km exists only on paper. Even today, there are children in the constituency who have never been to schools,” says Kouser, who has shifted her daughter, a Class 2 student, from a school in Jammu city to one in Rajouri to ensure that she is available to her constituents at all times.

FIRST ON HER LIST: Kouser says her first focus will be to ensure road connectivity. “There are villages where people trek for nearly three to four hours to get to the nearest motorable roads,” she says.

Asim Qureshi, 45, National Conference
Gundna, Doda

The advocate defeated former minister and vice-president of BJP’s J&K unit Shakti Raj Parihar. Qureshi says he will focus on development and promote communal harmony.

“Villages don’t have road connectivity… The constituency has 15 panchayats under it and only two dispensaries… Schools don’t have adequate teaching staff,” he says

View attachment 702894
Asim Qureshi

However, adds Qureshi, the success of his plans will depend on “how the government behaves”. “Let’s see if they allow the DDCs to work and allocate funds to it. People are not happy over the way things happened on August 5, 2019 (when Article 370 was revoked),’’ he says.

FIRST ON HIS LIST: Qureshi wants to bring road connectivity to his constituency


Dr Manohar Singh, 68, PDP
Nowshera, Rajouri

A physician, Singh polled 10,579 votes and won the Nowshera constituency, a BJP bastion and native place of J&K BJP president and former MLA Ravinder Raina. His win on a PDP ticket assumes significance in light of the BJP’s extensive campaign in the region, including visits by Union Ministers.

“There had been no development in Nowshera despite it being a border area. People living along the LoC face Pakistani shelling every day. They get injured, even killed, and their houses are damaged, but nobody cares for them,” says Singh, who retired from government service eight years ago and now has his own medicine practice in Nowshera town.

“In the 2014 Assembly elections, the present BJP president Ravinder Raina got elected due to the Modi wave, but he did not visit the people here after that,” he adds.

Singh says he was sure of winning because there was already a lot of discontentment among people and “no BJP wave in the constituency”.

FIRST ON HIS LIST: As a DDC member, he says, my role will be to ensure power supply, better healthcare, and more safety measures in the constituency

Kumari Shaveta, 30, BJP
Keerian Gandyal, Kathua

A homeopathY practitioner, she defeated former MLA and Dogra Swabhiman Sangathan Party candidate Kanta Andotra by a margin of 1,675 votes.

“I hail from Jagatpur village. It is only one km away from the highway at Lakhanpur, but there is no road connectivity. Last year, when I got married and moved out, I also had to walk to get anywhere… That’s when I decided to contest the polls,” she says.

Shaveta believes the DDC polls will highlight issues of rural areas and also help bridge the gap between Jammu and Kashmir. “The two divisions have always accused each other of taking away the major share of development funds. Now that both have an equal number of DDC constituencies, there will be real change on the ground,” she adds.

FIRST ON HER LIST: Shaveta says while campaigning she found that there were very few government dispensaries in her area. Ensuring better healthcare will be her priority.


Indian democracy 💪🇮🇳 !
Either road infrastructure is highly poor or the article is tilted towards small backward constituencies.
 
.
Either road infrastructure is highly poor or the article is tilted towards small backward constituencies.
Democracy, the smallest villages get representatives and build them roads.. these were DDC (District Development Council) polls
 
.
All is possible in India. Naturally! As per India's constitution, if JnK's constituent assembly had recommended the abrogation of article 370, then Governor bhai would have had the authority to do so. However, this constituent assembly was dissolved (to clarify, this specific entity dissolved in 1957) - what to do? Hmm. Governor bhai has overcome this dilemma and followed your advice and just changed the constitution! What a wonderful timeless solution!

"The order was issued using the third clause of Article 370, which authorised the President of India to declare the article inoperative with exceptions and modifications, if recommended by the (non-existent) state constituent assembly to do so.[30] To circumvent the legal issue of the non-existent state constituent assembly, the President used the Clause (I) of Article 370, which conferred him with the power to modify the Indian Constitution on subjects related to Jammu and Kashmir. So he first added a new clause to Article 367, which deals with interpretation of the Constitution. He replaced the phrase 'Constituent Assembly of the State' with 'Legislative Assembly of the State'.[41][42] Since the state legislative assembly has been suspended, the order says that any reference to the legislative assembly will be construed as a reference to the Governor of Jammu and Kashmir.[41][30] The governor is an appointee of the Central government. Therefore, the Indian Parliament now functions for the state legislative assembly.[30]"

"On August 5, 2019, the president of India issued the Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 2019, C.O. 272, pursuant to article 370(1) of the Constitution of India. Constitutional lawyer Gautam Bhatia states that this “constitutes the basis for everything that follows.” The order stipulates that, with the “concurrence of the Government of State of Jammu and Kashmir,” “[a]ll the provisions of the Constitution, as amended from time to time, shall apply in relation to the State of Jammu and Kashmir.” Moreover, since the government could not directly rely on article 370(3) to abrogate other articles, it sought to use its powers under article 370(1) to amend article 367, the interpretation clause of the Constitution, so that references to “Government of the State [Jammu and Kashmir]” in article 370 would be construed as the governor of Jammu and Kashmir (§ 2), and the expression “Constituent Assembly of the State” in article 370(3) will be read as referring to the current legislative assembly of Kashmir. "

So, because the specific constituent assembly doesn't exist to give me the recommendations needed, let's change that to any "current legislative assembly"....and let's also change "government of the state" (because we just dissolved that too) to be construed as the "governor of JnK", who - surprise surprise - happens to be me. And I can do all this without any consent from the elected representatives of JnK.

Governor bhai can modify modify modify. Kya zabardasst cheez hain yeh constitution and democracy.
LOL, dude, while your deep interest in Indian constitution is appreciated, the basic simple fact-of-the-matter is, its a book which can be amended.

The book itself has provisions for its own amendments. Its not a "divine revelation" cast in stone, got it?

Who can amend it and when, that also is taken care of.

And there are clauses & contents which can be "interpreted" in different ways.

And even after all of the above, if someone still has grievance, he can approach the courts.

Of-course for you everything is sham except that light which shone on your ancestors, but don't assume that the same light has shone on all others. Spare the kafirs at least.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom