Naseeruddin Shah says he fears for his children in India of today

[HariPrasad]

Leeches prasad.
Leeches.

Send him back to Iran

We can't send him back. However if he voluntarily goes, we shall give him a warm farewell with a request not to come back.

 

[Men in Green]

Yes he is right and he is always welcomed in pak

apne ghar leja esko phr. he is not welcomed. theeka nhi le rkha Pakistan ne har kisi ka.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

The you will have to change your thoughts sometime.

Marad massacre 2003

Insert obscure incident here...

While Hindutva Lynch mobs under BJP are daily news.

Aamir Khan and Naseeruddin Shah have been to Pakistan many times and are good friends with many Pakistani actors, scholars, and politicians.

It is not the first time for them.

They don’t share your hate of Pakistan.

 

[Tom M]

Insert obscure incident here...

While Hindutva Lynch mobs under BJP are daily news.

Aamir Khan and Naseeruddin Shah have been to Pakistan many times and are good friends with many Pakistani actors, scholars, and politicians.

It is not the first time for them.

They don’t share your hate of Pakistan.

OBSCURE incident ?? That may be the reason why the lower court had sentenced accused for and the Kerala High Court had asked the CBI to investigate the case in detail. Huh ?? I can provide you even more such incidents. Not only Muslim but by others as well.

The fact is we have enough religious filth, fundamentalists in every available religion. And it is not just specific to India, its a curse of our subcontinent. If some b@stards lynch people in India, similar guys blew themselves among other minorities or their religious gathering/place of worship in Pakistan. So do you thing you are better off ??

It seems like you are preconceived with the Idea that I have a hatred towards Pakistan to begin with. The problem is simply cherry picking few such incidents and generalising it on a population of 1.3 Billion.

And if I go by that very same logic what should Pakistan be called in general ?? A terrorist Nation??

But sorry I won't stoop to that level because I not that stupid to generalise few incidents on a whole nation. To put it simple. I'm not stupid unlike some of the members in PDF.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

OBSCURE incident ?? That may be the reason why the lower court had sentenced accused for and the Kerala High Court had asked the CBI to investigate the case in detail. Huh ?? I can provide you even more such incidents. Not only Muslim but by others as well.

The fact is we have enough religious filth, fundamentalists in every available religion. And it is not just specific to India, its a curse of our subcontinent. If some b@stards lynch people in India, similar guys blew themselves among other minorities or their religious gathering/place of worship in Pakistan. So do you thing you are better off ??

It seems like you are preconceived with the Idea that I have a hatred towards Pakistan to begin with. The problem is simply cherry picking few such incidents and generalising it on a population of 1.3 Billion.

And if I go by that very same logic what should Pakistan be called in general ?? A terrorist Nation??

But sorry I won't stoop to that level because I not that stupid to generalise few incidents on a whole nation. To put it simple. I'm not stupid unlike some of the members in PDF.

Your government, military, and judicial system is actively promoting that mindset at the expense of Indian Muslims.

 

[prashantazazel]

Any Muslim Lynch mobs?

I didn’t think so.

Forming violent mobs on religious issues is common in both communities.
Both groups have killed for interfaith marriages.
Both groups have killed when they felt their faith was insulted.
An example - in Kerala, a Muslim group chopped off the hands of a professor who mentioned your prophet in a mathematics based question paper. There are several more.

Of course, these days the mobs are mainly Hindus. I agree with that.

 

[Surya 1]

Your government, military, and judicial system is actively promoting that mindset at the expense of Indian Muslims.

Let's see, if Nassiruddin .Shah migrates to Pakistan, what you say will be truth.

 

[KAMDEV]

Actor Naseeruddin Shah says that he is worried for children in today's India. He's worried because he imagines a situation where his children may be surrounded by an angry mob and asked: "Are you Hindu or Muslim?"

"My children will have no answer," Naseeruddin Shah says, "Because we chose not to give a religious education to our children."


Naseeruddin Shah also says that there is a "poison" that has spread in the Indian society. "It will be very difficult to capture this djinn [genie] back into the bottle."

"There is complete impunity for those who take the law into their own hands," Naseeruddin says. "We have already witnessed that the death of a cow has more significance [in today's India] than that of a police officer."

Naseeruddin was referring to the recent Bulandshahr violence in which a police officer was killed by a mob. The violence was sparked by the discovery of cow carcasses.

The Uttar Pradesh Police has arrested three people in connection with the alleged cow slaughter. The policeman's killers remain free.

Naseeruddin Shah's comments were put online by Karwan-e-Mohabbat India (Caravan of Love), a travelling activist collective that is focussed on highlight and combating instances of hate crimes and lynching.


I am angry and I believe every right-thinking man must be angry and must not fear
- Naseeruddin Shah
"I was given a religious education...But Ratna [Pathak Shah, Naseeruddin's wife] did not get any religious education...[And] we chose not to give a religious education to our children," Naseeruddin says.

Naseeruddin adds that he believes "good and evil have nothing to do with religion" and so his children were not brought up in a religious environment.

"So I fear for my children...Because if a mob gathers around them and asks them are you a Hindu or Muslim, they will not have any answer...Because they have no religion," Naseeruddin says, before signing off with: "I am angry and I believe every right-thinking man must be angry and must not fear."

'LOW THINKING'

Expectedly, sharp reactions came in from political quarters to Naseeruddin Shah's comments.

Shiv Sena MP Arvind Sawant called Naseeruddin's statement "a blunder" and said that he "deplores" the actor's comments.

"If his kids are caught in a mob they should say they are Hindustani (Indians) Why are they scared?" Sawant questioned.

Naseeruddin Shah's statement shows his low thinking
- RSS ideologue Rakesh Sinha
Rajya Sabha MP and Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh ideologue Rakesh Sinha too reacted to Naseeruddin Shah's comments.

"Nasiruddin Shah [sic] should first ask Rohingyas to leave Hindustan as according to him India is unsafe for him and his family," Sinha said in a tweet before suggesting that Shah was becoming part of a "sinister design of anti cil [civil] society propaganda".

"His statement shows his low thinking," Sinha also said.


Source: India today

RSS goons are trying to make india a hindu nation , we will not let it happen.

Yes he is right and he is always welcomed in pak

ha ha ha ............he will never ever think about it even in dream . he is a secular human and a proud indian .

 

[PakSarzameen5823]

Naseeruddin Shah is welcome in Pakistan, and so is Aamir Khan.

Ew no, I don't want them infecting our society. We've already been contaminated enough as it is from others within us, we don't need these weirdos coming in on top of that.

 

[KAMDEV]

Ew no, I don't want them infecting our society. We've already been contaminated enough as it is from others within us, we don't need these weirdos coming in on top of that.

ha ha ha ...........you can't afford them .

 

[PakSarzameen5823]

you can't afford them

We have a GDP of about 300 billion USD, which is more than what Bill Gates makes in a year. I'm pretty sure we could afford one measly b-rate actor.

 

[KAMDEV]

Any Muslim Lynch mobs?

I didn’t think so.

muslim lynch mob ? no .
but in muslim dominated areas mobs dominate and support illegal activities .even killing .

We have a GDP of about 300 billion USD, which is more than what Bill Gates makes in a year. I'm pretty sure we could afford one measly b-rate actor.

you can't . just send them invitation they know you can't afford , they will not accept your invitation.

 

[PakSarzameen5823]

they will not accept your invitation.

I (and plenty of other Pakistanis) don't want to give them one in the first place. Like I said, we could do with less pollution in our country.

 

[KAMDEV]

I (and plenty of other Pakistanis) don't want to give them one in the first place. Like I said, we could do with less pollution in our country.

i know pakistanis are enviornment friendly nation.

 

[PakSarzameen5823]

i know pakistanis are enviornment friendly nation.

Well, we did plant quite a few trees in KPK.