Nani Hub has released video of Zubair Omar for disobedience

[doorstar]

Rajput. yours?

rajput (son of rajah) is not an ethnic group. it was a non-hereditary title for royal servants and officials. gradually, the Rajputs emerged as a social class comprising people from all sorts of ethnic/caste/qaum/zaat and geographical backgrounds.

 

[El Sidd]

rajput (son of rajah) is not an ethnic group. it was a non-hereditary title for royal servants and officials. gradually, the Rajputs emerged as a social class comprising people from all sorts of ethnic/caste/qaum/zaat and geographical backgrounds.

Punjab is an administrative unit not an ethnicity.

 

[M. Sarmad]

what are you on about? does your punjabi-ism feel betrayed? why don't you start by travelling to other parts of punjab and kill all those who speak against lohar? if you are so offended by what i said??

Well, my friend, it's never a good idea to say bad things about or mock an entire region or ethnic group on public forums. Online hatred fuels division

 

[Path-Finder]

rajput (son of rajah) is not an ethnic group. it was a non-hereditary title for royal servants and officials. gradually, the Rajputs emerged as a social class comprising people from all sorts of ethnic/caste/qaum/zaat and geographical backgrounds.

it was sarcasm...............I made another sarcastic post after that one. see if you can spot it!

 

[M. Sarmad]

Punjab is an administrative unit not an ethnicity.

'Punjabi' is an ethnicity, though besides Punjabis many non-Punjabis also live in Punjab, the administrative unit

 

[doorstar]

Punjab is an administrative unit not an ethnicity.

debatable but definitely a linguistic group

 

[El Sidd]

'Punjabi' is an ethnicity, though besides Punjabis many non-Punjabis also live in Punjab, the administrative unit

People who live in administrative unit called Punjab are called Punjabis.

 

[Path-Finder]

Well, my friend, it's never a good idea to say bad things about or mock an entire region or ethnic group on public forums. Online hatred fuels division

if you are soooooooo offended then that is a 'you' problem! See I dont give a f about being punjabi. I care more about Pakistaniat. if you are soooooooo worked up then that means you are punjabi more than Pakistani.

 

[El Sidd]

but deffo a linguistic group

this is for linguists to academically debate and define.

 

[M. Sarmad]

People who live in administrative unit called Punjab are called Punjabis.

'Punjabi' can be used as both, a demonym or an ethnonym.

if you are soooooooo offended then that is a 'you' problem! See I dont give a f about being punjabi. I care more about Pakistaniat. if you are soooooooo worked up then that means you are punjabi more than Pakistani.

You identify yourself as a Potohari, not a Punjabi .. You not giving a f about 'Punjabi' is borderline racism

 

[El Sidd]

'Punjabi' can be used as both, a demonym or an ethnonym.

that's like saying Sindh needs provincial autonomy to protect the Sindhi civilisation.

I have family who have lived in Lahore for half a century. I call them Punjabis but those who live next door to them don't call them Punjabis. Can you tell me the reason why?

Similarly my 2 next door neighbours in Sindh belonging to KPK and Punjab refuse their Sindhi identity or even Karachi identity. Can you tell the reason why?

It's not all plain simple black and white.

 

[M. Sarmad]

I have family who have lived in Lahore for half a century. I call them Punjabis but those who live next door to them don't call them Punjabis. Can you tell me the reason why?

Similarly my 2 next door neighbours in Sindh belonging to KPK and Punjab refuse their Sindhi identity or even Karachi identity. Can you tell the reason why?

It's not all plain simple black and white.

You use word 'Punjabi' for them as demonym, those who don't call them Punjabis use the word as 'ethnonym'. Same for non-Sindhis living in Sindh. It's really that simple

 

[El Sidd]

You use word 'Punjabi' for them as demonym, those who don't call them Punjabis use the word as 'ethnonym'. Same for non-Sindhis living in Sindh. It's really that simple

Of course it is. That's why thousands have died in ethnic fueled violence in the country.

 

[Maula Jatt]

if you are soooooooo offended then that is a 'you' problem! See I dont give a f about being punjabi. I care more about Pakistaniat. if you are soooooooo worked up then that means you are punjabi more than Pakistani.

so you care so much about "Pakistaniyat" you'll talk shit about certain cites cause you feel like it and when they respond you start questioning their Pakistaniyat with this absolutely stupid argument "you are soooooooo worked up then that means you are punjabi more than Pakistani."

what in the actual F

 

[Path-Finder]

so you care so much about "Pakistaniyat" you'll talk shit about certain cites cause you feel like it and when they respond you start questioning their Pakistaniyat with this absolutely stupid argument "you are soooooooo worked up then that means you are punjabi more than Pakistani."

what in the actual F

why are you so offended over what people in Pakistan say about loharis? why are your panties in a twist?