Green Arrow
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2014
- Messages
- 3,808
- Reaction score
- 5
- Country
- Location
Muslim majority areas are not just Kashmir valley, more like Chenab formula is best one.
What was Chenab formula?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Muslim majority areas are not just Kashmir valley, more like Chenab formula is best one.
So you're telling me innocent civilians are fair game? The mothers of Kanun Posh Pora didn't fire a single bullet, neither were they complicit in any crime against the Indian State - they were simple villagers.
We're not talking about those that are complicit in what you'd descibe as terror, or what I'd describe as terror. We're talking about Indian Society not caring about innocent civilians - innocent Kashmiris - who were raped.
brother listen
India spend $39 billion in IoK out of $298 billion total budget, so stop living in lala land and visit India some time. Bharat is shit poor country unfortunately
IoK does not deserve so much extra money with population of just 7 million out of 1300 million. We don't care and are happy with our Kashmir. We know IoK will be burden on us because they don't offer any economic advantage. With G-B Pakistan at least have border with China and have cut off India from central asia.
Its time Indian said good bye to IoK, not all but just majority muslim areas.
Did Kashmir people ever cared when people in Tibet are raped , murdered and occupited by the occupier force China?Do you Kashmir separatish show any mercy when your terrorist killed innocent life of Mumbai on 11/26? Do you have any sympathy for the person who are raped your so called freedom fighter terrorist in Mumbai on 11/26?
So if you do not care about any one except your own interests, then why would you expect that you will care for you?....
Indians should stop worrying about Kashmir and look torwards Assam
We will take all muslim majority areas of IoK, not just Kashmir valley.
Als
Okay, so all the Kashmiri people are fair game. And Kashmiris aren't Indians - because, you say, we act as a collective against India.
first ..............show me in the Budget where it says 39 billion is marked for only Kashmir.
next thing ..........I live in Gurdaspur ( just 6kms away from Indo-Pak Border) ............I know how much poor India is .
The point I am saying is that India has maintained active Army in Kashmir since 1990...........that time Indian economy was a mess .............but these days income of Govt. has increased many folds..........while expenditure in Kashmir remained same as army personals remained same.....( u got the point)........if needed .........India can increase the active army in Kashmir .......money wont be a issue here.
Next point , I my self belong to minority in India and havent faced any problem in any where .........i still cant figure out what issue is with muslims in Kashmir???
I'm Kashmiri, I have more of a right to that land than you. Actually, Kashmir belongs equally to all whom inhabit it. I don't know why you're trying to caricature me as some sort of extremist.
Als
Okay, so all the Kashmiri people are fair game. And Kashmiris aren't Indians - because, you say, we act as a collective against India.
The point is that Kashmiris don't claim Tibet as part of Kashmir. India claims Kashmir as part of India. Then why doesn't it treat atrocities against Kashmiris equally?
Answer me this: is every single Kashmiri guilty of "seperatism"?
are you from Indian side or pakistan?I'm Kashmiri, I have more of a right to that land than you. Actually, Kashmir belongs equally to all whom inhabit it. I don't know why you're trying to caricature me as some sort of extremist.
The fact you Indians serve as loyal apologists for the massacre, rape and torture of thousands of Kashmiris by the Indian Army only shows you don't see Kashmiris as equals.
You all jump up and down crying when a woman in Dehli is raped, but what about the villages of mothers in Kashmir? Aren't they as Indian?
What was Chenab formula?
There is nothing called ratonality when we are debating about separtism..For me, the land of Kashmir and the people who belive in India are my people...Rest of the people although they stay in my nation but does not belive on my nationhood, i am not bothered about them...I claim Kashmir part of India for them who stand with me...This is the same way like as you are not worried about Tibetians ..so i am least bothered about any Non Indian people who are having any issues with any one..For me any people living in Kashmir who shout anti Indian slogan, is not Indian responsibility to treat him with respect...He needs to be treated like other anti national people..
Nationalism sir, nationalism. And its own survival. Why else do you think India is holding on to this wasteland?
That doesn't make it ethically right. The nation-state must serve the needs of those whom it identifies as its people, not vice-versa.
A stretch from reality. India is an aspiring power and at this stage would be in no position to give up land, no matter the cost. That is a nation-state for you, the same Russia does to Chechnya, another wasteland and a complete liability.
What India can at least try to provide is a democratic framework wherein issues of the people can be solved. That is the best bet: compromise.
Out of curiosity, to which side of LoC do you belong?