Muzaffarnagar woman seeks abortion after being raped at gunpoint by her father-in-law... but clerics

[Sahasranama]

Whats happened to society ?
We have become worse than animals

Are you saying Rape has started only in this century and only in this society ?

 

[third eye]

Are you saying Rape has started only in this century and only in this society ?

No

A father in law raping his Son's wife is what I was referring to .

He is expected to give his life for the honour & safe custody of his daughter - in - law not rape her.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

No

A father in law raping his Son's wife is what I was referring to .

He is expected to give his life for the honour & safe custody of his daughter - in - law not rape her.

This has a historic precedent. I won't elaborate that.

 

[Sahasranama]

No
A father in law raping his Son's wife is what I was referring to .
He is expected to give his life for the honour & safe custody of his daughter - in - law not rape her.

I think there are law breakers in every society and in every century. This is not a new phenomena.

 

[third eye]

I think there are law breakers in every society and in every century. This is not a new phenomena.

That still makes them inhuman

New or old does not matter

 

[Sahasranama]

That still makes them inhuman
New or old does not matter

Which is why in earlier times we used to called them Asura or Rakshasa. Remember Ravan ? ....stealing other man's wife.

 

[amygdaloideum]

uniform civil code,anyone?

 

[SarthakGanguly]

uniform civil code,anyone?

Thou art communal.

 

[Maravan]

Mulayam singh yadav supports the panchayat decision. He must be the biggest ba$tard in politics, he may have a bad eye on dimple yadav, its good for akilesh to be careful.

 

[abjktu]

Two reasons.
One is they think that if they unleash a protest against this they will suppressed by hardliners within the community even within their family.
Second is they are silently allowing shit like this as their fate.

Hardliners are there in every community..be it Hindu,Christian or Islam..They may have political support,money and goonda gangs..but still they are only very very few in numbers..Once we get united and act against these religious vultures..pinne ivanonnum orikkalum thala pokoolla..

 

[Maravan]

Even if other women are not victims, they are aware of this ruling. They are aware of what Sharia says. Why are they not protesting ? ....the obvious conclusion is that they are okey with such laws. Same goes for muslim men too.

Why are you asking me why she should or should not consider anything ? ask her.

My question to you is, will you leave your wife to your father just like that if such thing happens to ur wife?as per sharia. Dont take it personal, just for an argument.

This woman is just the spark against this law, just like malala of pakistan against taliban. Other women aren't speaking against taliban like malala, does it make you think other women are ok with taliban rule except malala?

 

[Sahasranama]

My question to you is, will you leave your wife to your father just like that if such thing happens to ur wife?as per sharia. Dont take it personal, just for an argument.

This woman is just the spark against this law, just like malala of pakistan against taliban. Other women aren't speaking against taliban like malala, does it make you think other women are ok with taliban rule except malala?

I don't follow sharia.

If you don't speak up against anything then the general rule of thumb is that you support it.

 

[livingdead]

uniform civil code,anyone?

Enough of these Kangaroo courts, India needs Uniform Civil Code ASAP.

rape comes under criminal case, which is uniform already in India.. do you see separate criminal law for muslims or christians?

 

[Indrani]

That maybe true, but how does such medievel thinking tie in with modern laws which states that this is a clear cut case of rape.

It is Islamic law. Equal weightage is given to Sunnah (Prophet's lifestyle) as the Quran.

 

[Sahasranama]

rape comes under criminal case, which is uniform already in India.. do you see separate criminal law for muslims or christians?

If there was no separate law and court, why did the victim go to the sharia court ?

Why did the panchayat not directly file an FIR and get the FIL arrested ?