Must watch : Ambassador Rustam Shah spelling the beans on Pakistan's games in Afghanistan

[TMA]

Can't have it both ways, you did what you did because it was in your interests, you even sold Afghans when it was in your interests. Afghanistan would still be a shithole, being run by your proxies if not for the US intervention. So when its all interests on your side then it is all interests in our side.

Anyways call us whatever want, wont make a difference ?

But always remember why Pakistan interfered into Afghanistan: it was Afghanistan which was the aggressor and drew first blood against Pakistan. Pak-Afghan history does not commence in 1979. All Pakistan did was a response. And she gave a befitting response.

So the onus is on Afghanistan to change her attitude towards Pakistan in concrete terms and for Pakistan to measure if this is enough. (I doubt this will happen with NATO being "hosted").

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

questions:
1) were chinese ready for this observing duty?
2) was US ready to give china a role in afghanistan?
3) did afghan government have control over whole afghanistan for chines to move and see freely as the indian won't visit them in their hotels?
4) US officials already had talked on indian involvement in anti pakistan activities. why don't the afghans listen to the major power in their country?

Fair enough, since you have raised your demands here is a couple of the Afghan side.

- handover Afghan Talis,including Haqqani and stop all their support infrastructure and stop graduating anti afghan elements in your madrassas. Haqqani madrassas are acting like yale and stanford in Pakistan
- stop screwing around with the transit routes, this is an agreed right of the landlocked country
- Afghanistan will have relations with India like any other country does, you cant dictate that. but Gurrantee will be given that Afghan soil wont be used against Pakistan.
- Afghan refugees are already returning.

Sounds good to you ?
-

answer first point: pakistan had already cleared north waziristan of all terrorists including haqqanis. there isn't any haqqani network structure in pakistan. haqqanis are killed in drone strikes in afghanistan recently clearly showing where they belong to. they can't control 40% afghanistan by sitting in pakistan. haqqani madrassas are educational institutions where afghans are not allowed to take admissions. its our government official policy.
answer point 2: its afghanistan who do aggressive acts like burning pakistan flags, attacking pakistani constructions at gates, stopping pakistani goods from reaching central asia. afghanistan had been given full acess to sea as per transit trade agreement and one way access to india without any agreement as a special gesture.
answer point 3: pakistan don't have any problems with india in afghanistan but there are still indian run terrorists camps in afghanistan for insurgency in balochistan. we got problem with this kind of indian presence. how could afghanistan give guarantee to pakistan when they can't even secure kabul?
answer point 3: afghanistan refugess returned during last year is 74000 out of more 4 million. most of them came back because of incompetence of afghansitan security forces to provide safe and peaceful afghanistan o them.

 

[Max]

I watched the video and he is complaining about dual policies of Pakistan against Taliban.. he was basically saying that we left Taliban after 2001, we did very bad with Mullah Zaeef and Afia siddiqi, thats why we are facing bomb blasts.. ?

So he is asking us to be firm on supporting Taliban? @A-Team

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

Fair enough, since you have raised your demands here is a couple of the Afghan side.

- handover Afghan Talis,including Haqqani and stop all their support infrastructure and stop graduating anti afghan elements in your madrassas. Haqqani madrassas are acting like yale and stanford in Pakistan

they have presence on both sides of the Durand Line. If you want us to blindly mass murder tribal Pakhtuns then you're out of your mind. Years ago they were your heros when they took on the Soviets

- stop screwing around with the transit routes, this is an agreed right of the landlocked country

we only "screw around" when ANA opens fire on our border posts or when they misbehave -- 2 weeks ago our national flag was burned and that INFURIATED us

the routes are also closed when where is actionable intelligence about potential cross-border terrorist strikes but these are bilateral issues we can sort out if there's maturity

- Afghanistan will have relations with India like any other country does, you cant dictate that. but Gurrantee will be given that Afghan soil wont be used against Pakistan.

Pakistan never said Afghanistan cant have relations with India. It's your internal affair and none of our business. But we do have a right to dis-allow indian goods from entering our territory.

And I pray we can have a guarantee about india not using Afghan soil for nefarious purposes. As an Islamic Republic it's your duty to ensure that, just like I am vocal that no elements from Pakistan should be involved in anything that involves Afghan civilians being killed

Sounds good to you ?
-

if I could buy you dinner after a handshake and light a cigar with you i would