Muslims treated as second class citizens: SP

[Abhishek_]

And furthermore, it is not I who is complaining Genius.

It is the INDIAN MUSLIMS who are complaining.

Indian Muslims aren't complaining, they are voting. you familiar with the concept?

 

[Bang Galore]

He also questioned the government’s intentions for not hanging assassins of former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi and former chief minister of Punjab Beant Singh, while citing the hanging of Parliament attack convict Afzal Guru.
In a press conference held at his Nariman Point party office, Azmi said that political outfit from Punjab Akali Dal had openly stated that if assassins of Singh were hanged, the whole state would burn. The Tamil Nadu Assembly has passed a resolution demanding that the three killers of Gandhi should not be hanged. “If the same resolution was passed by Jammu and Kashmir Assembly, then Muslims are labelled as traitors,” he said.

This part I agree with. I see no logic in only hanging Afzal Guru but not these chaps. Killing a serving CM & a former PM also constitutes grave offenses against the Indian state. Same treatment must apply. I also disagree with Afzal Guru's execution taking place without allowing for an appeal against the non-granting of clemency. While strictly not necessary, if others like the assassins of RG & Beant Singh are allowed that even after the President has rejected the mercy petition, the same rule must apply to everyone. One cannot cherry pick in matters like this.

 

[KRAIT]

@Pakistanisage Dude, I know what M.A. Jinnah wanted. But there was no concept for religion based Prorata share of the population.

We wouldn't have allowed religion to be part of state. Secular India and no preferential treatment. It was your insecurity to live with Hindus.

I don't care what you want. I know the history and I know the present.

When people look at Pakistan, even BD people thinks that we are lucky to be separated from Pakistan.

 

[Abhishek_]

One of the rights was to have Assembly seats and Federal Govt. jobs in same proportion as their share of the Population.

with no regard to merit?? yea we do that for backward tribes here, it has had zero positive impact. btw it is best you do not bring the topic of partition; it deserves a separate thread, there are a few facts you are unaware of.

 

[Pakistanisage]

facepalm, PK was made all muslims of the indian subcontinent. oddly we still see people asking for asylum in india rather than PK. ironic

This is the result of the low class education you have received.

Pakistan was NOT made for ALL the MUSLIMS OF INDIA. Read History.

If Pakistan was made for all the muslims of India, then Muslims would have demanded greater piece of land to match their PRO-RATA share ( i.e. 35 to 40% of land), GENIUS.

 

[KRAIT]

This part I agree with. I see no logic in only hanging Afzal Guru but not these chaps. Killing a serving CM & a former PM also constitutes grave offenses against the Indian state. Same treatment must apply. I also disagree with Afzal Guru's execution taking place without allowing for an appeal against the non-granting of clemency. While strictly not necessary, if others like the assassins of RG & Beant Singh are allowed that even after the President has rejected the mercy petition, the same rule must apply to everyone. One cannot cherry pick in matters like this.

It was simply a political move. To downplay Hindu terror remark. I don't know why it took and still take so much time to hang these terrorists.

Politics in Sentencing and Punishment given by Judiciary should be removed.

 

[Bang Galore]

This is the result of the low class education you have received.

Look who's talking.

Pakistan was NOT made for ALL the MUSLIMS OF INDIA. Read History.

If Pakistan was made for all the muslims of India, then Muslims would have demanded greater piece of land to match their PRO-RATA share ( i.e. 35 to 40% of land), GENIUS.

Explain Pakistan then.

 

[Abhishek_]

This is the result of the low class education you have received.

Pakistan was NOT made for ALL the MUSLIMS OF INDIA. Read History.

If Pakistan was made for all the muslims of India, then Muslims would have demanded greater piece of land to match their PRO-RATA share ( i.e. 35 to 40% of land), GENIUS.

demands are rather easy to make. PK has been making several demands since 47. your point being?

 

[karan.1970]

they did and they got one. it is called land of the pure.

Actually, they got 2.. Dont forget Bangladesh

 

[Pakistanisage]

@Pakistanisage Dude, I know what M.A. Jinnah wanted. But there was no concept for religion based Prorata share of the population.

We wouldn't have allowed religion to be part of state. Secular India and no preferential treatment. It was your insecurity to live with Hindus.

I don't care what you want. I know the history and I know the present.

When people look at Pakistan, even BD people thinks that we are lucky to be separated from Pakistan.

Actually if you read the fourteen point demand made by Jinnah, they were quite straight forward and fair. Here they are:


Fourteen Points of Jinnah - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Bang Galore]

It was simply a political move. To downplay Hindu terror remark. I don't know why it took and still take so much time to hang these terrorists.

Nail on the head. That should not be the reason....saving the backside of an incompetent HM.. Afzal Guru's execution must not have been a political football, the same rules should have applied.

Politics in Sentencing and Punishment given by Judiciary should be removed.

I agree. Presidential pardons must be disposed off in a reasonable time frame & executions for those denied it must be swiftly carried out.

 

[Abhishek_]

Actually if you read the fourteen point demand made by Jinnah, they were quite straight forward and fair. Here they are:


Fourteen Points of Jinnah - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article may contain improper references to self-published sources. Please help improve it by removing references to unreliable sources, where they are used inappropriately. (March 2012)

I request again, partition deserves a separate thread. let's not discuss it here.

 

[Bang Galore]

Actually if you read the fourteen point demand made by Jinnah, they were quite straight forward and fair. Here they are:


Fourteen Points of Jinnah - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

That is irrelevant. The INC didn't agree & most of us support that decision even today. We are discussing what happened thereafter.

 

[Abingdonboy]

The remaining 200 Indian Muslims will soon demand a separate piece of Land. Infact if they are given their per capita share of land, that might solve Hindus " Muslim Problem".

Pakistanis need to stop thinking like this.



Have a watch:

 

[karan.1970]

The remaining 200 Indian Muslims will soon demand a separate piece of Land. Infact if they are given their per capita share of land, that might solve Hindus " Muslim Problem".

I think Pakistan has a bigger Muslim problem than India