Muslim girl in Mumbai wins Gita contest- Incredible India!!

[I.R.A]

What does your religion say about those who have either accepted the invitation or were born into the religion in the first instance, but eventually decide its not for them and want to follow another school of thought? Or not follow anything at all?

Do you invite him (or her) back?

Do you know name of the person who firmly believed and knew in his heart that the message Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) has brought is true, but still won't accept it?

What are your religions views on others who also believe in inviting you to their side by conveying their message to you? Is it a quid pro quo? Do you listen and then decide to move or politely refuse depending on your level of conviction?

Explain the manner of invitation, there is always a difference between exploiting someone because of his helplessness and simply letting him know what you want to convey to him without any exploitation or material reward involved.

 

[doppelganger]

Do you know name of the person who firmly believed and knew in his heart that the message Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) has brought is true, but still won't accept it?

I know a few. Who are Muslim only by birth.

I hope you are not going to ask me to name them here now .....

Explain the manner of invitation, there is always a difference between exploiting someone because of his helplessness and simply letting him know what you want to convey to him without any exploitation or material reward involved.

A christian padre coming into your home and asking you to convert to Christianity.

 

[I.R.A]

I know a few. Who are Muslim only by birth.

I hope you are not going to ask me to name them here now .....

I am talking about historical personality, a relative of Prophet (PBUH), not about atheists of today.

A christian padre coming into your home and asking you to convert to Christianity.

Okay I will offer him the tea. So.................

 

[doppelganger]

I am talking about historical personality, a relative of Prophet (PBUH), not about atheists of today.

Are you saying only blood relatives and contemporaries of you prophet are true Muslims? How about you?

Okay I will offer him the tea. So.................

Will you listen to his message? Will you give it serious thought? Will you put yourself in a position to make a choice?

 

[I.R.A]

Are you saying only blood relatives and contemporaries of you prophet are true Muslims? How about you?

Awwwww forget it. Post your original question once again and I will answer simply.

Will you listen to his message? Will you give it serious thought? Will you put yourself in a position to make a choice?

I would know more about Jesus than what he would try to tell me. So a cup of tea. And a little discussion about his welfare activities and best wishes would serve him right I guess.

 

[doppelganger]

I would know more about Jesus than what he would try to tell me.

You are presuming here. No?

So a cup of tea. And a little discussion about his welfare activities and best wishes would serve him right I guess.

Why does he need to be served right?

He is doing his job as a good Christian, as you are as a good Muslim. No?

 

[I.R.A]

You are presuming here. No?

No. Being a Muslim I have to believe in all Prophets which total in number to nearly 124,000, so he won't be telling me something new which I don't know already.

Why does he need to be served right?

He is doing his job as a good Christian, as you are as a good Muslim. No?

I think I would respect a guest and serve him right, without discriminating whether he is Muslim, Christian or Hindu or whosoever.

What did you expect I would take out my AK-47 and beat the shit out of that guy..................

 

[doppelganger]

No. Being a Muslim I have to believe in all Prophets which total in number to nearly 124,000, so he won't be telling me something new which I don't know already.

Ya, but he specializes in Jesus. For you he is only one of the prophets. Hence my skepticism regarding your claim.

I think I would respect a guest and serve him right, without discriminating whether he is Muslim, Christian or Hindu or whosoever.

Oh ok.I guess we are both using "serve him right" in different ways then.

What did you expect I would take out my AK-47 and beat the shit out of that guy..................

No, not you personally.

But a lot of blood has flown between your two religions over centuries because not all from both these religions are as chilled out as you.

Prosetylizing religions by their very nature are not chilled out. They preach superiority of views. Otherwise why would you try to spread your message to others? Working on the assumption that everyone already has a message in life.

 

[I.R.A]

Ya, but he specializes in Jesus. For you he is only one of the prophets. Hence my skepticism regarding your claim.

Lalay its not medicine where you specialise in a field. Hadio ka doctor tay joro ka doctor. I have enough information about Jesus and know what I need to know.

No, not you personally.

But a lot of blood has flown between your two religions over centuries because not all from both these religions are as chilled out as you.

More will..

Prosetylizing religions by their very nature are not chilled out. They preach superiority of views. Otherwise why would you try to spread your message to others? Working on the assumption that everyone already has a message in life.

I told you once why I need to let you know. Its not about numbers game its about my own personal salvation and to safeguard myself that I did what was expected of me and what I could, so no ignorant that day can point to me and say he knew me and he never told me.

 

[doppelganger]

I told you once why I need to let you know. Its not about numbers game its about my own personal salvation and to safeguard myself that I did what was expected of me and what I could, so no ignorant that day can point to me and say he knew me and he never told me.

I remember.

But you are supposed to spread the message for your salvation only sounds like (to my Dharmic mind) a higher form (God or his messengers) recruiting evangelists (soul reapers) on His behalf.

Works like multilevel marketing. I recruit 5. Each of them recruit 5 each. Each of those 5 recruit another 5. And so it follows.

Assuming Christianity and Islam are almost sister faiths (minus some divergences), especially Catholic Christianity and Islam, why would you try to pass your message to each other, or fight each other so much? Why not call a truce on concentrate your energies on enlightening us Pagans instead?

Why does a Christian girl have to convert to Islam before she marries a Muslim boy?

 

[I.R.A]

I remember.

But you are supposed to spread the message for your salvation only sounds like (to my Dharmic mind) a higher form (God or his messengers) recruiting evangelists (soul reapers) on His behalf.

Works like multilevel marketing. I recruit 5. Each of them recruit 5 each. Each of those 5 recruit another 5. And so it follows.

You got it all wrong. It’s all opposite to what you are assuming. Do you think the ONE who created everything needs my services to raise his army? The concept is eternal reward and eternal punishment. Not the numbers.

Assuming Christianity and Islam are almost sister faiths (minus some divergences), especially Catholic Christianity and Islam, why would you try to *** your message to each other, or fight each other so much? Why not call a truce on concentrate your energies on enlightening us Pagans instead?

Why does a Christian girl have to convert to Islam before she marries a Muslim boy?

No these two faiths were, but not any more. Believing in Oneness of the God is key, a person who believes in more than One is a Mushrik simple.

 

[doppelganger]

You got it all wrong. It’s all opposite to what you are assuming. Do you think the ONE who created everything needs my services to raise his army? The concept is eternal reward and eternal punishment. Not the numbers.

No these two faiths were, but not any more. Believing in Oneness of the God is key, a person who believes in more than One is a Mushrik simple.

I am getting bored of religious talk Imran, no offense.

Btw, thank you for not talking about cricket.

 

[timetravel]

What the girl said is what she learnt from Gita.

Read Gita, it never mentions about Hindus or Non Hindus. It can/should be read/followed by every Human.

 

[livingdead]

What the girl said is what she learnt from Gita.

Read Gita, it never mentions about Hindus or Non Hindus. It can/should be read/followed by every Human.

author of gita did not know about muslims and christians...
no word hindu in bible and quran too... for same reason.

 

[timetravel]

author of gita did not know about muslims and christians...
no word hindu in bible and quran too... for same reason.

Quran: Muslims and Non Muslims. believers and Non believers

Bible: Also talks about Christians.

This causes hatred and division between people. You can see different treatment is meted out to Muslims and Non Muslims in Quran. It divided people and makes its followers extremely intolerant of the Non Muslims.