khanz
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2007
- Messages
- 4,514
- Reaction score
- 1
OMG you are really grasping at straws here ! why don't you just go a step further claim prophet Muhammed (PBUH) as the first Pakistani ? There wouldn't have been Islam or Ummayad caliphate and therefore ultimately no Pakistan without him either.
Bin Qasim was not nor any of his ancestors born within the land mass that is now Pakistan, nobody in history ever referred to him as Pakistani and nor did he invade with the Idea to spread Islam and establish a future homeland for Muslims on the Indian sub-continent nor he invented the two-nation theory .
He only conquered Sindh and small part of Punjab but the population of what is now modern day Pakistan at the time of his victory was still Majority Hindu/Buddhist. Islam spread over time from Sufis as well as many further invasions from other Muslim empires over a long period of time.
If that is the case why not give up Pakistan's claim to IVC how can IVC be pakistani when Bin Qasim was the first Pakistani yet he came thousands of years after it ? Sorry You can't have both.
Imagine if some Israeli members claimed Lord Balfour as the "first Israeli" you guys would be tearing into them
Bin Qasim was not nor any of his ancestors born within the land mass that is now Pakistan, nobody in history ever referred to him as Pakistani and nor did he invade with the Idea to spread Islam and establish a future homeland for Muslims on the Indian sub-continent nor he invented the two-nation theory .
He only conquered Sindh and small part of Punjab but the population of what is now modern day Pakistan at the time of his victory was still Majority Hindu/Buddhist. Islam spread over time from Sufis as well as many further invasions from other Muslim empires over a long period of time.
If that is the case why not give up Pakistan's claim to IVC how can IVC be pakistani when Bin Qasim was the first Pakistani yet he came thousands of years after it ? Sorry You can't have both.
Imagine if some Israeli members claimed Lord Balfour as the "first Israeli" you guys would be tearing into them