Muhajir Province Map

[truthseer]

you dont have a border with junagadh. JG was hindu majority, had land border with india and so belongs to india. and its a very small piece of land. the ruler of JG took all the wealth and went to pak anyways, thats why Pak did not follow up on JG

too bad the owner of the land the king gave it to india. If you can accept the partition plan of the British who were the ruler of india, then you should also have no prob with the plan of the ruler of kashmir and kashmir was not even part of british India so you guys have no claim on it.

Please tell me you're not serious.
Also:
you dont have a big border with Kashmir. Kashmir was Muslim majority, had land border with Pakistan and so belongs to Pakistan. and its a very small piece of land. the ruler of Kashmir took all the wealth and went to Inida anyways

Your point being?

 

[RazPaK]

Lolz bharti hypocrisy at it's best.

 

[SamranAli]

can muhajir stop calling themselves muhajir and calling them sindhi if they are in sindh or punjabi if in punjab so simple call you pakistani we hav lost Bengal due to these problems. From last 4 years these crisis are high becoz of poverty and dirty mind of ppp.

 

[shelly]

Who taught you that crap ?

Just because we came from Bihar to live in Pakistan , means we had to annex Bihar to Pakistan ?

So you can forcibly steal the land if you have a border ? ... Is that what you mean ? Kashmir was Muslim majority and so ?

But its ruler gave it to us. we have the pay-pa !

 

[Secur]

I don't want any of your money. I'm just saying that it would have been better if your forefathers stayed back in their ancestral land and fought for the independence of their land from hindus and annexed it to Pakistan. Maybe then you would have been given more respect today in Pakistan. Why did you come empty handed? You should have brought gifts with you if you wanted to stay.

And I really don't understand why you people are getting so sensitive about my posts. I didn't say anything racist, just stating facts. And sorry to burst your bubble but Jinnah was not a Mohajir, he was born in Karachi, he was not a migrant (mohajir).

STFU ! I dont even know how mods here are tolerating your stupid racist posts ... 2NT never called for every single province or state which had even a small number of Muslims to be annexed into Pakistan ! Our Forefathers actually fought for this land unlike your's who gained Pakistan whilst doing relatively nothing ! We left everything behind and migrated to Pakistan ! What gifts should we have brought ? Listen bastard ! We have already migrated 2 times and this time we ai'nt going nowhere ... Things can get really ugly if you guys continue like that ...

Who came empty handed ? We brought wealth and expertise with us ! If all migrants leave Karachi today , we will see how long can Pakistan its economy ... Remember , we provide 70%+ tax revenue to Pakistan

 

[truthseer]

can muhajir stop calling themselves muhajir and calling them sindhi if they are in sindh or punjabi if in punjab so simple call you pakistani we hav lost Bengal due to these problems. From last 4 years these crisis are high becoz of poverty and dirty mind of ppp.

Even Sindhis still call themselves Sindhis and they call us Sindhis too so why can't we call ourselves Sindhi? In fact, in Karachi, no one uses the word Mohajir any more. At most, people use their actual ethnicity and most just call themselves Sindhi or Pakistani

 

[Secur]

But its ruler gave it to us. we have the pay-pa !

So did the Junagadh one ? So ?

 

[truthseer]

But its ruler gave it to us. we have the pay-pa !

Same for Hyderabad and Junagarh

 

[shelly]

Please tell me you're not serious.
Also:
you dont have a big border with Kashmir. Kashmir was Muslim majority, had land border with Pakistan and so belongs to Pakistan. and its a very small piece of land. the ruler of Kashmir took all the wealth and went to Inida anyways

Your point being?

thre are 3 things for states not under British govt and not ranked in any order ..
a. ruler's choice
b. religious orientation
c. land border
so if you ahve 2/3 its yours.

for JG = India 2 , Pak 1
for hyderabad = India 2 , Pak 1

Kashmir = India 1 , Pak 1 and 1 neutral (land border)

so Pak and India are sharing Kashmir (P0K and JnK). I think its fair and we should make LoC as the border.

So did the Junagadh one ? So ?

but JG was hindu majority

Same for Hyderabad and Junagarh

Hyd = hindu + no border

wiki:
"Although the states were theoretically free to choose, Earl Mountbatten stated that "geographic compulsions" meant that most of them would choose India. Mountbatten took the position that only states that shared a common border with Pakistan should choose to accede to it, but he had no power to impose this point of view on the states.

"

 

[Burger Boy]

too bad the owner of the land the king gave it to india. If you can accept the partition plan of the British who were the ruler of india, then you should also have no prob with the plan of the ruler of kashmir and kashmir was not even part of british India so you guys have no claim on it.


no you think they want to join pakistan. i am saying they dont want to join. with the help of a small minority troublemakers pak sends its jhadis to india. if kasmiris wanted to join pak, they would have also moved liket the mohajirs, the fact they satyed on shows that they support india.

Typical Bharti double standard.

If that's the case then Junagarh is Pakistan, Goa is still part of Portugal, and Hyderabad should be an independent state.

 

[RazPaK]

STFU ! I dont even know how mods here are tolerating your stupid racist posts ... 2NT never called for every single province or state which had even a small number of Muslims to be annexed into Pakistan ! Our Forefathers actually fought for this land unlike your's who gained Pakistan whilst doing relatively nothing ! We left everything behind and migrated to Pakistan ! What gifts should we have brought ? Listen bastard ! We have already migrated 2 times and this time we ai'nt going nowhere ... Things can get really ugly if you guys continue like that ...

Who came empty handed ? We brought wealth and expertise with us ! If all migrants leave Karachi today , we will see how long can Pakistan its economy ... Remember , we provide 70%+ tax revenue to Pakistan

Chill out dude.

There are some Punjabi people whose family had been killed during partion.


Cough Cough*

 

[shelly]

india doesnt want land. it needs good qualtiy people like the mohajirs.

I recommend that people who left india who should return home to mother india the most secular and secure nation for all.

Typical Bharti double standard.

If that's the case then Junagarh is Pakistan, Goa is still part of Portugal, and Hyderabad should be an independent state.

read post 191

 

[Burger Boy]

"But moreover we gave away 25% of land to 15% of muslims. "

Um......what?

 

[truthseer]

thre are 3 things for states not under British govt and not ranked in any order ..
a. ruler's choice
b. religious orientation
c. land border
so if you ahve 2/3 its yours.

Interesting

for JG = India 2 , Pak 1
for hyderabad = India 2 , Pak 1

Kashmir = India 1 , Pak 1 and 1 neutral (land border)

India has a pretty small border to Kashmir, not a huge one, so it's technically, 1 and a half for India and two for Pakistan

so Pak and India are sharing Kashmir (P0K and JnK). I think its fair and we should make LoC as the border.

No, the people's wishes should be taken

And I also want to mention Firdosepur and Gudraspur since without those, India would have no border to Kashmir at all and 2 out of 3 applies there too

 

[shelly]

will they get free gau jal?

people get what they want in india if they work for it.. and i say 'people' not hind/mslim/sik etc