MP BJP legislator wants Muslims barred from Garbha celebrations

[Hiptullha]

NOTHING WRONG IN THAT... NAVRATRI IS RELATED WITH HINDU ...I SAW MANY TIME WHAT MUSLIMS ARE DOING IN DURGA POOJA PANDAL.... IN ISLAM THOSE THINGS ARE BAN ....THEN WHY MUSLIM SHOULD BE ALLOWED IN THIS PREMISES ..THIS IS SAME LIKE NON-MUSLIM ARE NOT ALLOWED AT MAKKA MADINA...

Ironically, you come from the same group which makes claims that India is now a truly secular country which seeks to assimilate ALL Indians from every sect and creed.

 

[foxbat]

Ironically, you come from the same group which makes claims that India is now a truly secular country which seeks to assimilate ALL Indians from every sect and creed.

You have no clue about the meaning of a country being secular. It means that govt should not prefer or force one religious belief. Does not mean that Hindus or Muslims or Christians can not prefer having exclusivity in their religious events. Comprehension seems to be a big issue on this forum

 

[IndoCarib]

Many of my Muslim friends play Holi too. There is no ban on Muslims in Hindu festivals

 

[Hiptullha]

You have no clue about the meaning of a country being secular. It means that govt should not prefer or force one religious belief. Does not mean that Hindus or Muslims or Christians can not prefer having exclusivity in their religious events. Comprehension seems to be a big issue on this forum

That's the job of the religious authorities, right? A government seeking to bar other religious groups from a specific religious festival can be seen as a government interfering in religion.

 

[livingdead]

That's the job of the religious authorities, right? A government seeking to bar other religious groups from a specific religious festival can be seen as a government interfering in religion.

I dont think govt is capable of doing it.. . Its view of an individual MP.
On a scale of secularism (separation of church and state), I would say, India ranks among upper half .. although not as high as western democracies.
There is still quite a bit of unnecessary interference in religious affairs by state in India, although no clergy/church/religious leader has influence on govt.

 

[scholseys]

By reading this thread, it appears Hindu girls are easy or they prefer muslim men due to the Hindu men's appetite for rape. Banning muslims from an event will not do any good, love finds its way,

 

[foxbat]

That's the job of the religious authorities, right? A government seeking to bar other religious groups from a specific religious festival can be seen as a government interfering in religion.

If it comes as a govt regulation, certainly. But does not seem to be the case. An MLA can want anything, but unless it becomes a law, it does not have govt's writ behind it.

 

[Yeti]

Yes they should bring their cute sisters in hijabs along too I got a fetish for hot hijab chicks

 

[Hiptullha]

Look at your country then talk...

Deflection...last tactics of a dumb Indian troll.

 

[HariPrasad]

Ironically, you come from the same group which makes claims that India is now a truly secular country which seeks to assimilate ALL Indians from every sect and creed.

What do you mean by secular??

We respect the sentiment of others. Being a secular does not take away our right to choose the entry of people in our function at our money. DO you think that being secular will take away our basic rights?

 

[Arjunsingh]

Indian Muslim society, in general, continues to be repressive and conservative, and interaction between sexes is discouraged. Which is why deprived Muslim youth want to gatecrash wherever Hindu women are present.

 

[Spring Onion]

Muslim youths barred at garba venues in Godhra


VADODARA: Barely 10 days before the nine-day dance festival kicks off in Gujarat, a rightwing group that identifies itself as Hindu Asmita Heet Rakshak Samiti (HAHRS) has issued a diktat in Godhra that Muslim youths should not be allowed to enter garba venues in the town to counter 'love Jihad'.

The samiti claims that it issued the diktat as Muslim youths enter garba venues to lure Hindu girls.

On Saturday , VHP leader Dr Pravin Togadia had called for the same in Amreli and said that identity cards of every person should be checked."We will contact all garba organizers in Gujarat and across the country to request them to check the identity of all youths. Navratri is a religious festival and Muslims should not be allowed here," Togadia told TOI.

"Muslim boys luring Hindu girls at garba venues has always remained a problem in Godhra. If Muslims have problem with everything including singing `Vande Mataram', why should they be allowed at garba venues?" said Jaimin Shah, one of the leaders of HAHRS.

Some organizers have agreed to allow Muslim youths only if they are accompanied by their family. Accord ing to the samiti, they have also received support from major garba organizers in Godhra and formed a team of volunteers to stop Muslim youth.

"Around 1,500 members will keep a check at the venues," said Shah, adding that the group, which hasn't registered itself, is holding awareness meetings since over a fortnight.

"We won't allow any Muslim youth to our garba to avoid `love Jihad'," said P B Baria, organizer of Aadhya Shakti Garba Mahotsav, which draws a crowd of 35,000. "If they come with their families, they are disciplined. So, we will allow Muslim families inside the venue," he said.

"We don't want any kind of disturbance and hence we have agreed that we will not collect donation from Muslims nor issue passes," said K T Parikh, organizer of Maa Shakti Garba Group. "We, however have no means to check whether any Muslim or a Hindu is entering the garba venue."

Muslim youths barred at garba venues in Godhra - The Times of India

 

[mujhaidind]

Good decision. Some Muslim youth corrupted by Bollywood think its ok to dance in front of idols to get some girls.

 

[Spring Onion]

This was from a thread here - https://defence.pk/threads/mp-bjp-legislator-wants-muslims-barred-from-garbha-celebrations.333327/
These are private celebrations. The individual/group has the right to approve or disapprove anyone they wish to.

a rightwing group that identifies itself as Hindu Asmita Heet Rakshak Samiti (HAHRS) has issued a diktat in Godhra that Muslim youths should not be allowed to enter garba venues in the town to counter 'love Jihad'.

Source: Indian Muslim youths barred at garba venues in Godhra

 

[mujhaidind]

they will get the girls anyway by their good looks
you cant stop love jihad hahahahah

Yea I know. But garbha is like idol-worshipping. So they shouldn't celebrate it.