Modi’s Popularity Soars as India Weathers the Pandemic
Recent polls have the prime minister’s approval ratings topping 80 or 90 percent. But the economic devastation from the coronavirus has yet to be reckoned with.
Watching Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s televised address in Amritsar, India, on Tuesday.Credit...Raminder Pal Singh/EPA, via Shutterstock
By Jeffrey Gettleman and Sameer Yasir
NEW DELHI — Just before the coronavirus arrived in India, Prime Minister Narendra Modi faced serious challenges, perhaps the biggest of his tenure.
Antigovernment protests roiled the country. Hindu-Muslim riots exploded in the capital just as President Trump was visiting. And India’s once-hot economy was slumping, shedding millions of jobs and casting a pall over the entire country.
Since then, as the world has been walloped by the coronavirus pandemic, many of these problems in India, especially the economic ones, have only gotten worse. But once again, India has rallied around Mr. Modi.
Recent opinion polls show that in the past few months Mr. Modi’s already high approval ratings have soared even higher, touching 80, even 90 percent. Unlike two of the populist leaders to whom he is often compared, President Trump and President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia, Mr. Modi seems to be thriving in this crisis.
The result, some analysts say, is that if India continues to ride out the coronavirus in decent form, he may emerge with an even stronger hand when he and his party press their Hindu-centric policies. Much as the brinkmanship with Pakistan last year helped strengthen his re-election campaign, the deadly pandemic is bringing many Indians to his side despite lingering concerns about his agenda.
Image
Police officers in Northeast Delhi in February, an area that saw clashes between Hindus and Muslims.Credit...Atul Loke for The New York Times
In times of national crisis, people tend to rally around the flag. Leaders across the world have enjoyed a coronavirus boost, though for many, it’s not expected to last.
Mr. Modi’s success, analysts say, may be more durable. He’s widely seen as a mobilizer, not a despot, which may explain why his nationwide stay-at-home lockdown, which he dropped on the country with four hours’ notice, has been largely obeyed. Even the softer, feel-good exercises he has insisted on, like asking Indians to stand in their doorways and clap at a certain time, or to light candles at another, have been followed by millions.
Still, it has not been a spotless performance. Mr. Modi’s government was caught off guard by the epic exodus of migrant workers pouring out of India’s cities, making long, desperate and sometimes fatal journeys. (On Saturday, more than 20 migrants were killed in a truck crash as they traveled home.) And many economists believe that the $260 billion relief package that Mr. Modi triumphantly announced this week, as he urged Indians to become more self-reliant, will hardly be enough.
But he never downplayed the virus threat or said India had capabilities it didn’t. And unlike in the United States, where partisan politics has gummed up the response and created great discord and even chaos, analysts say Mr. Modi has worked well with state-level officials across India, regardless of ideology.
The result is that the political landscape Mr. Modi, 69, has shaped over the past six years, since a surge in Hindu nationalism brought him to the top job in the world’s largest democracy, has only been shored up. He and his Bharatiya Janata Party, known as the B.J.P., dominate the airwaves. They move unchecked when implementing policies. The political opposition is practically invisible.
Image
A police officer checking the temperature of a commuter entering New Delhi from the neighboring state of Uttar Pradesh last month.Credit...Rebecca Conway for The New York Times
“Modi is faring better than many peers because he acted decisively, pre-emptively and relatively early by going for the world’s most stringent lockdown when corona cases were few in India,” said Sreeram Chaulia, dean of the Jindal School of International Affairs, outside of New Delhi. “His phrase ‘Jaan Hain to Jahaan Hain,’” which means the world exists only if you are alive, “struck a chord.”
Now comes the hard part.
This coming week, after nearly two months of lockdown, India’s economy is expected to open up. The economic wreckage will emerge more clearly, with countless millions out of work and spilling into the streets.
Food lines will grow. Businesses will struggle to reopen. Many people will run out of money. Virus infections will also likely surge: the slope of India’s graph has already risen as some lockdown rules have begun to ease. Mumbai, the commercial capital, is struggling to contain infections, and a few protests have broken out in other places.
But for a nation of 1.3 billion, the 82,000 reported coronavirus infections and 2,700 deaths is much lower per capita than many other countries, especially richer ones like the United States, Britain, Italy and Russia.
Though the virus picture here is especially hazy, because India is so big and it has performed fewer tests than many other nations, most independent health experts don’t believe that Mr. Modi’s government is hiding information.
What is clear is that many Indians feel thankful to him.
Image
Migrant workers walking back toward their hometowns along a national highway on the outskirts of Mumbai last week.Credit...Atul Loke for The New York Times
“Had it not been for this man, hospitals and mortuaries in the country would have run out of space,” said Vrushali Khadse Shet, a human resources manager for a shipbuilding company in Goa. “His skill of delivering a message to the lowest strata of society worked and we have been saved till now.”
Opinion polls indicate that much of India feels the same way. Morning Consult, an American firm that does online surveys in several countries, showed Mr. Modi outperforming other world leaders. His popularity is gauged at 80 percent, far above Mr. Trump, Mr. Putin, Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany, Prime Minister Boris Johnson of Britain and several others.
Another poll, in the Times of India, a leading newspaper, showed that 93.5 percent of those surveyed felt Mr. Modi was handling the virus crisis effectively.
Of course, the Indians who have suffered the most under the lockdown — like migrant laborers — were probably not part of these surveys. Many migrants interviewed in the past few days have pleaded for him to end the lockdown and were not so enthusiastic about his decisions.
For this next phase as the lockdown changes, Mr. Modi is relying more on the chief ministers of every state. That might seem consultative and more democratic, but analysts say it’s also a tactic to spread the risk. If things don’t go so smoothly in the coming weeks as the economic pain really begins to bite, well, Mr. Modi’s argument will go, it’s not all my fault.
Image
Mumbai during the nationwide lockdown in April.Credit...Atul Loke for The New York Times
Scholars expect him and the B.J.P. to keep pushing divisive policies that cater to Hindu nationalists in India’s Hindu majority. Those moves have come at the expense of India’s minority Muslim community, which has already suffered enormous setbacks under Mr. Modi.
“The only constraints on him would have to come from abroad,” said Sumit Ganguly, an Indian studies professor at Indiana University. “The guardrails of most of India’s democratic institutions have been breached with the B.J.P.’s battering rams.”
But Mr. Modi has seen his runaway popularity stalled before, over economic concerns. The nation is lining up behind him right now, but the economic devastation from the coronavirus has yet to be reckoned with.
For years, Mr. Modi has won crucial support from moderates and the middle class by projecting himself as India’s “economic messiah,” said Sumantra Bose, a political scientist at the London School of Economics.
And if the economy can’t pull itself out of a nose dive, Mr. Bose added, “the messiah may be hoist with his own petard.”
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/16/world/asia/coronavirus-modi-india.html
Recent polls have the prime minister’s approval ratings topping 80 or 90 percent. But the economic devastation from the coronavirus has yet to be reckoned with.
Watching Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s televised address in Amritsar, India, on Tuesday.Credit...Raminder Pal Singh/EPA, via Shutterstock
By Jeffrey Gettleman and Sameer Yasir
- May 16, 2020
NEW DELHI — Just before the coronavirus arrived in India, Prime Minister Narendra Modi faced serious challenges, perhaps the biggest of his tenure.
Antigovernment protests roiled the country. Hindu-Muslim riots exploded in the capital just as President Trump was visiting. And India’s once-hot economy was slumping, shedding millions of jobs and casting a pall over the entire country.
Since then, as the world has been walloped by the coronavirus pandemic, many of these problems in India, especially the economic ones, have only gotten worse. But once again, India has rallied around Mr. Modi.
Recent opinion polls show that in the past few months Mr. Modi’s already high approval ratings have soared even higher, touching 80, even 90 percent. Unlike two of the populist leaders to whom he is often compared, President Trump and President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia, Mr. Modi seems to be thriving in this crisis.
The result, some analysts say, is that if India continues to ride out the coronavirus in decent form, he may emerge with an even stronger hand when he and his party press their Hindu-centric policies. Much as the brinkmanship with Pakistan last year helped strengthen his re-election campaign, the deadly pandemic is bringing many Indians to his side despite lingering concerns about his agenda.
Image
Police officers in Northeast Delhi in February, an area that saw clashes between Hindus and Muslims.Credit...Atul Loke for The New York Times
In times of national crisis, people tend to rally around the flag. Leaders across the world have enjoyed a coronavirus boost, though for many, it’s not expected to last.
Mr. Modi’s success, analysts say, may be more durable. He’s widely seen as a mobilizer, not a despot, which may explain why his nationwide stay-at-home lockdown, which he dropped on the country with four hours’ notice, has been largely obeyed. Even the softer, feel-good exercises he has insisted on, like asking Indians to stand in their doorways and clap at a certain time, or to light candles at another, have been followed by millions.
Still, it has not been a spotless performance. Mr. Modi’s government was caught off guard by the epic exodus of migrant workers pouring out of India’s cities, making long, desperate and sometimes fatal journeys. (On Saturday, more than 20 migrants were killed in a truck crash as they traveled home.) And many economists believe that the $260 billion relief package that Mr. Modi triumphantly announced this week, as he urged Indians to become more self-reliant, will hardly be enough.
But he never downplayed the virus threat or said India had capabilities it didn’t. And unlike in the United States, where partisan politics has gummed up the response and created great discord and even chaos, analysts say Mr. Modi has worked well with state-level officials across India, regardless of ideology.
The result is that the political landscape Mr. Modi, 69, has shaped over the past six years, since a surge in Hindu nationalism brought him to the top job in the world’s largest democracy, has only been shored up. He and his Bharatiya Janata Party, known as the B.J.P., dominate the airwaves. They move unchecked when implementing policies. The political opposition is practically invisible.
Image
A police officer checking the temperature of a commuter entering New Delhi from the neighboring state of Uttar Pradesh last month.Credit...Rebecca Conway for The New York Times
“Modi is faring better than many peers because he acted decisively, pre-emptively and relatively early by going for the world’s most stringent lockdown when corona cases were few in India,” said Sreeram Chaulia, dean of the Jindal School of International Affairs, outside of New Delhi. “His phrase ‘Jaan Hain to Jahaan Hain,’” which means the world exists only if you are alive, “struck a chord.”
Now comes the hard part.
This coming week, after nearly two months of lockdown, India’s economy is expected to open up. The economic wreckage will emerge more clearly, with countless millions out of work and spilling into the streets.
Food lines will grow. Businesses will struggle to reopen. Many people will run out of money. Virus infections will also likely surge: the slope of India’s graph has already risen as some lockdown rules have begun to ease. Mumbai, the commercial capital, is struggling to contain infections, and a few protests have broken out in other places.
But for a nation of 1.3 billion, the 82,000 reported coronavirus infections and 2,700 deaths is much lower per capita than many other countries, especially richer ones like the United States, Britain, Italy and Russia.
Though the virus picture here is especially hazy, because India is so big and it has performed fewer tests than many other nations, most independent health experts don’t believe that Mr. Modi’s government is hiding information.
What is clear is that many Indians feel thankful to him.
Image
Migrant workers walking back toward their hometowns along a national highway on the outskirts of Mumbai last week.Credit...Atul Loke for The New York Times
“Had it not been for this man, hospitals and mortuaries in the country would have run out of space,” said Vrushali Khadse Shet, a human resources manager for a shipbuilding company in Goa. “His skill of delivering a message to the lowest strata of society worked and we have been saved till now.”
Opinion polls indicate that much of India feels the same way. Morning Consult, an American firm that does online surveys in several countries, showed Mr. Modi outperforming other world leaders. His popularity is gauged at 80 percent, far above Mr. Trump, Mr. Putin, Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany, Prime Minister Boris Johnson of Britain and several others.
Another poll, in the Times of India, a leading newspaper, showed that 93.5 percent of those surveyed felt Mr. Modi was handling the virus crisis effectively.
Of course, the Indians who have suffered the most under the lockdown — like migrant laborers — were probably not part of these surveys. Many migrants interviewed in the past few days have pleaded for him to end the lockdown and were not so enthusiastic about his decisions.
For this next phase as the lockdown changes, Mr. Modi is relying more on the chief ministers of every state. That might seem consultative and more democratic, but analysts say it’s also a tactic to spread the risk. If things don’t go so smoothly in the coming weeks as the economic pain really begins to bite, well, Mr. Modi’s argument will go, it’s not all my fault.
Image
Mumbai during the nationwide lockdown in April.Credit...Atul Loke for The New York Times
Scholars expect him and the B.J.P. to keep pushing divisive policies that cater to Hindu nationalists in India’s Hindu majority. Those moves have come at the expense of India’s minority Muslim community, which has already suffered enormous setbacks under Mr. Modi.
“The only constraints on him would have to come from abroad,” said Sumit Ganguly, an Indian studies professor at Indiana University. “The guardrails of most of India’s democratic institutions have been breached with the B.J.P.’s battering rams.”
But Mr. Modi has seen his runaway popularity stalled before, over economic concerns. The nation is lining up behind him right now, but the economic devastation from the coronavirus has yet to be reckoned with.
For years, Mr. Modi has won crucial support from moderates and the middle class by projecting himself as India’s “economic messiah,” said Sumantra Bose, a political scientist at the London School of Economics.
And if the economy can’t pull itself out of a nose dive, Mr. Bose added, “the messiah may be hoist with his own petard.”
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/16/world/asia/coronavirus-modi-india.html
Last edited:
