Middle east countries boycotting Indian consumer goods for Insulting the Prophet of Islam

[Novus ordu seclorum]

Also Hadiths and other later days invention like ijma and kiyas made things more complicated and turned Islam into heavily ritualistic religion from deen aka complete guidance of life!

That's the reason people take bribes and make Masjid with it and visit Mecca for Hajj and society call the noble men!

My question is , is performing Hajj with Haram money allowed? If you make Masjid with the money you looted by corruption , will Allah accept your namaz there?

What's the point of finding halal food shop outside Muslim majority countries where you will spend haram money?

All are meaningless.

Purpose of religion is not to create a utopia on earth. Heaven is the utopia in the next world. In this life, there is individual responsibility and accountability.

39-41 Indeed, We sent down to you the Book for the people in truth. So whoever is guided - it is for [the benefit of] his soul; and whoever goes astray only goes astray to its detriment. And you are not a manager over them.

 

[VikingRaider]

Purpose of religion is not to create a utopia on earth. Heaven is the utopia in the next world. In this life, there is individual responsibility and accountability.

39-41 Indeed, We sent down to you the Book for the people in truth. So whoever is guided - it is for [the benefit of] his soul; and whoever goes astray only goes astray to its detriment. And you are not a manager over them.

Not managing them. Just trying to defend my position ( according to quran) that is frowned in our society. Shared opinions because showing the flaw that are being practiced in our society, that is against Quran , but they are practocing in the name of Quran and Islam, and making atmosphere poisonous!

 

[Novus ordu seclorum]

Not managing them. Just trying to defend my position ( according to quran) that is frowned in our society. Shared opinions because showing the flaw that are being practiced in our society, that is against Quran , but they are practocing in the name of Quran and Islam, and making atmosphere poisonous!

Quran calls itself Furqan [the Criterion]. We expect people to follow the moral standard set in the Quran. This applies to believers and non-believers, all are judged by the same standard, if not in this world, then on Judgement Day.

 

[Rushd Alam]

Attacking my faith is ad hominem fallacy. Your purpose should be the truth. For a Muslim, Quran is supreme. I understand the reverence you have for Hadith, but many Hadith contradict the Quran and the Prophet's character. There is a Hadith that depicts the Prophet as a suicidal lunatic who would go every morning, same time, same place to jump off a cliff and every time Angel Jibreel would appear and calm him down.

Rather than making erratic claims that hadith contradicts quran, why dont you give examples. State the hadits that contradict quran.

What is your qualification to make claims as such?

I havent seen any scholars ever question sahih bukhari. Only keyboard scholars like you would confuse people.

Hadith rejectors are such funny creatures, hope allah guides you to stay away from their fitna.




I know the answer any ways.

 

[Rushd Alam]

Answer:



Imam Bukhari records in his Sahih (hadith no 6982) from Aisha RA that when the Prophet AS first encountered the Angel Jibreel (AS) in the Hira cave and rushed home his heart was racing and he was somewhat fearful. However it does not say he thought he had ‘met a demon’, rather he was naturally fearful for himself as he had never encountered something like that before. And Khadija RA consoled him and assured him that Allah would take care of him due to his good character and generosity and support for all around him.



Many narrations in the Sirah literature do not meet the hadith criteria of authenticity (sihah)



The allegation that the Prophet AS tried to commit suicide is a reference to some reports that he was extremely sad at the long gap in revelation coming to him after the initial revelation at cave Hira. After which it is reported that he had tried to climb the mountain to throw himself off in despair but when he tried to do that the Angel Jibreel appeared and said “say, O Muhammad! You are indeed Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) in truth” whereupon his heart would become quiet and he would calm down and would return home. This is mentioned as part of the longer hadith (no. 6982) recorded by Bukhari on the authority of Aisha RA in the chapter of Interpretation of Dreams (Kitab al-Ta’bir).



However, this part of the narration which describes the alleged attempted suicide is not actually reported by Aisha as part of her narration. It is one of the narrators (al-Zuhri) who adds this to the hadith text by prefacing it with “according to what has reached us..”(fi ma balaghana). So Zuhri who is a narrator of this hadith of Aisha RA has added this part and has not mentioned the chain of narrators, meaning who he heard this from, he simply says “according to what has reached us” for this part. In other words, he didn’t hear this part from his teacher who narrated the hadith of Aisha RA. As we know when a report is narrated without naming the narrators in the chain then this will not be counted as a sahih narration because the narrators are unknown. Therefore this part of the narration, that alleges the suicide, is weak and not part of the hadith text narrated by Aisha. Zuhri heard this from other teachers and/or narrators whom he hasn’t named.



Imam Bukhari has recorded this hadith in full including Zuhri’s addition because his collection was really for scholars of hadith who would understand and be alerted to this fact. Or he included showing people that this part of Zuhris addition is not part of the main Hadith.



Imam Muslim and others have recorded the same hadith of Aisha RA but without the addition of Zuhri as it is not part of the hadith. Therefore the reports alleging the attempted suicide of the Prophet AS are not sound or true.

 

[bharat62]

Middle east countries boycotting Indian consumer goods for Insulting the Prophet of Islam

Things are under control now .

 

[Novus ordu seclorum]

Rather than making erratic claims that hadith contradicts quran, why dont you give examples. State the hadits that contradict quran.

What is your qualification to make claims as such?

I havent seen any scholars ever question sahih bukhari. Only keyboard scholars like you would confuse people.

Hadith rejectors are such funny creatures, hope allah guides you to stay away from their fitna.




I know the answer any ways.

Don't make false claims. I had reverence for Hadith till I read them and went through faith crisis. Muslims world over would be drinking camel urine if we followed Hadith. Can't be calling Hadith Sahih when they are not. Your boss MBS admitted it.

 

[Rushd Alam]

Don't make false claims. I had reverence for Hadith till I read them and went through faith crisis. Muslims world over would be drinking camel urine if we followed Hadith. Can't be calling Hadith Sahih when they are not. Your boss MBS admitted it.

Funny, such ignorance you have regarding Hadith, now I have no doubt about your intellect. And since when MBS became a cleric of islam.

 

[Chat SAMOSA]

Whatcha talkin' about Willis?

Indians buying things ?!?

With money ??

This is news to me.

Here in Little India of LA, maximum Kharida-wala customer (dekhney wala nahi) are all Bangladeshis and Pakistanis.

Indians don't buy Jack-$hit.

Indians would rather save ten rupees to buy something from India and ship it to LA in personal luggage.

Even stupid things like mithai.

Even assuming you're right , it's their business what and where they buy. Why does that bug you ?

 

[FuturePAF]

Whatcha talkin' about Willis?

Indians buying things ?!?

With money ??

This is news to me.

Here in Little India of LA, maximum Kharida-wala customer (dekhney wala nahi) are all Bangladeshis and Pakistanis.

Indians don't buy Jack-$hit.

Indians would rather save ten rupees to buy something from India and ship it to LA in personal luggage.

Even stupid things like mithai.

What part(s) of LA/Southern California is now considered Little India, Little Bangladesh and Little Pakistan?

 

[Turingsage]

India’s Exports To GCC Countries Grew By 44% In 2021-22: FIEO​

The GCC was established in May 1981. Its members are Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar and the UAE

Press Trust of India

UPDATED: 21 SEP 2022 3:40 PM
Indian exports to the six Gulf Cooperation Council countries grew by 44 per cent to about USD 43.9 billion in 2021-22 fiscal year compared to previous fiscal's USD 27.8 billion with the UAE leading the trade with a remarkable 68 per cent growth, according to an apex trade promotion body.
Exports to the UAE, India’s second-largest trading partner and largest in terms of exports, surged to $28 billion in the past fiscal year that ended on March 31, 2022, from USD 16.7 billion in the 2021 fiscal, according to the Federation of Indian Export Organisations (FIEO), the apex body of India's export promotion councils.
The GCC was established in May 1981. Its members are Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar and the UAE.
In a statement at the niche expo, Super Sourcing Dubai (SSD), co-located with Propaper Dubai 2022 at Festival Arena, Dubai Festival City, top FIEO officials said paper and allied products exports to the GCC touched USD 638 million in 2021 with the UAE taking a major share in the trade at USD 386 million.
“Our exports performance in the GCC in FY 2021-22 has been marvellous. Apart from the UAE, our exports to Saudi Arabia grew by 49 per cent, Oman by 33 per cent, Qatar by 43 per cent, Kuwait by 17 per cent and exports to Bahrain increased by 70 per cent,” said Ajay Sahai, Director-General and CEO of FIEO.
In the case of the paper industry, India has a 16 per cent market share in GCC and the target is to corner a 25 per cent market share by 2027 with the signing of Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA) with other Gulf countries.
India and the UAE signed the CEPA in February this year which came into force on May 1 2022. The cumulative demand for paper and allied products in the GCC market is estimated to be over USD 3.8 billion.
“We see a lot of opportunities for Indian companies post signing of CEPA with the UAE and are sure that participation in the SSD with such a large contingent, perhaps the biggest after Dubai Expo from India, will give a boost to our trade further,” Sahai said, adding that the export prospects will further scale up since zero-duty access for Indian products to the UAE is expected to expand over 5-10 years to 97 per cent of UAE tariff lines, or 99 per cent of Indian exports by value.

India’s Exports To GCC Countries Grew By 44% In 2021-22: FIEO

The GCC was established in May 1981. Its members are Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar and the UAE

www.outlookindia.com

​

 

[VikingRaider]

Funny, such ignorance you have regarding Hadith, now I have no doubt about your intellect. And since when MBS became a cleric of islam.

MBS isn't a cleric,neither ummaya and Abbasid kings were ( yes kings , as no one was chaliph after Rashidun) !

Read ,"খিলাফত ও রাজতন্ত্র" of Maulana Maududi.

You will see the nasty , disgusting behavior of so called Muslims of that era!

These kings played role on Hadith collectors.

There is a reason why Qawmis hate Maududi! Because although he is Maulana he speaks the truth about some so called sahabas as well!

Qawmis are hypocrites by default , because they are responsible for imposing lots of burdens on people alongside salafis!

 

[Bilal9]

What part(s) of LA/Southern California is now considered Little India, Little Bangladesh and Little Pakistan?

Parts of Artesia in LA is considered Little India.

Little India Village - Artesia, CA

10 reviews of Little India Village "I love coming here. I love shopping at cottage art, I love the market, and LOVE the food! I seriously can spend all day here."

www.yelp.com

Parts of Vermont area in central LA is considered Little Bangladesh which was designated in 2010. There are shops in there, but mostly serving expat and refugee lower middle class folks who live in the vicinity. Scant parking, as is normal in LA central areas.

Little Bangladesh, Los Angeles - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Little Bangladesh – Welcome to Little Bangladesh

littlebangladesh.org

There is no specific areas that are considered Little Pakistan - though Pakistani brothers here may know. Pakistani/Bangladeshi restaurants and shopping is spread all around areas in Little India as well.

THE BEST 10 Pakistani Restaurants in LOS ANGELES, CA - Last Updated July 2024 - Yelp

Best Pakistani in Los Angeles, CA - Biriyani Kabob House, Al-Noor, Chargha House, Shor, Zam Zam Foods, Halal Biriyani Kabob House, Al Watan Halal Restaurant, Paratta, Famous Tandoori, Tawakal Halal Tandoori Restaurant

www.yelp.com

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My favorites among Pakistani restaurants in greater LA,

Shahnawaz (Artesia) - https://www.facebook.com/ShahnawazHalalTandoori/

Khan Saab (Fullerton) - https://www.yelp.com/biz/khan-saab-desi-craft-kitchen-fullerton

Bundoo Khan (Fullerton - this place started in Karachi back in the day as a take-away food-truck, now its a franchise chain. Great informal eatery) - https://bundookhanusa.com/

 

[HydraChess]

Whatcha talkin' about Willis?

Indians buying things ?!?

With money ??

This is news to me.

Here in Little India of LA, maximum Kharida-wala customer (dekhney wala nahi) are all Bangladeshis and Pakistanis.

Indians don't buy Jack-$hit.

Indians would rather save ten rupees to buy something from India and ship it to LA in personal luggage.

Even stupid things like mithai.

You DO know that Indian's household income in USA is much much higher than you can ever dream of.

 

[Novus ordu seclorum]

Funny, such ignorance you have regarding Hadith, now I have no doubt about your intellect. And since when MBS became a cleric of islam.

Clerics are not infallible. Thanks to God, Islam is not a religion of clerics with monopoly over interpretation and understanding.

Saudi official cleric below.

The idea of Trinity also came from clerics and Quran warns us not to give them too much authority.

Quran 9-31 They have taken their scholars and monks as lords besides Allah, and [also] the Messiah, the son of Mary. And they were not commanded except to worship one God; there is no deity except Him.