What's new

Metro rail stops at air force red signal

Zabaniyah

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 24, 2011
Messages
14,925
Reaction score
7
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
Bijoy Sarani link seen as risky for security; financier Jica upset; meeting adjourned for today

2011-09-13__ft08.jpg


M Abul Kalam Azad

Construction of the much anticipated metro rail looks uncertain as the government might bring another modification in its alignment in the face of the air force's objection to the current alignment running across Bijoy Sarani.

Japan International Cooperation Agency (Jica), keen to provide 80 percent of the $1.8 billion project cost as a soft loan, hinted to the communications ministry in February that it might not even give the fund if the alignment is modified again, said the ministry sources.

Jica already accepted a modification earlier, after it had completed feasibility study on a proposed alignment, and told the government that it will not accept further modification.

Although experts told top air force officials that the current elevated alignment across Bijoy Sarani will not hamper air traffic to and from Tejgaon Old Airport close by, air force officials do not agree with them. The airport is currently used by the air force and army aviation.

The air force has been pressing to move the current alignment to Khamar Bari from the Bijoy Sarani-Crescent Lake crossing, saying if the metro rail runs across Bijoy Sarani, it will cause serious problems in emergencies or war situations.

Experts earlier carried out an extensive study on the current route alignment and put it in the 20-year-long Strategic Transport Plan for Dhaka city. Cabinet approved the alignment on March 8 this year.

According to the original plan of the government, construction of the metro rail also known as Mass Rapid Transit (MRT)-6 was supposed to start this year and be completed in three years.

Under the circumstances, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina sat for a meeting with experts, ministers, and air force officials at the cabinet division of Bangladesh Secretariat yesterday to find a solution.

Dr SM Saleuddin, additional executive director of Dhaka Transport Coordination Board, gave a presentation on the current route. Prof Shamsul Hoque of the civil engineering department of Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology gave another presentation on the route's Bijoy Sarani point.

Prof Jamilur Reza Chowdhury, Finance Minister AMA Muhith, Communications Minister Syed Abul Hossain, and Air Marshal Shah Mohammad Ziaur Rahman discussed the problem.

"We could not resolve the problem today, but will sit again tomorrow for a solution," Prof Jamilur told The Daily Star after the meeting.

Jica representatives have been invited to today's meeting for persuading them to accept another modification, if that becomes necessary.

Prof Jamilur also said Japan might not accept further change in the alignment, and that might put the metro rail construction in an uncertainty.

Meeting sources said the prime minister hinted that she looks at the air force's demand as a minor modification, and might not have any objection to it. She wants to keep Tejgaon Old Airport operational, they added.

The metro rail to be constructed from Uttara Third Phase to Sayedabad is crucial, as it will transport around 60,000 passengers in an hour during peak time from one corner of the capital to the other, says the Jica study.

It was the government who first delayed the progress of the project by modifying the alignment on February 1 this year for its conflict with Gulistan-Jatrabari flyover.

According to that modification the metro rail route from Uttara Third Phase to Teachers Students Centre (TSC) of Dhaka University via Pallabi, Farmgate, and Sonargaon Hotel will remain unchanged. But from TSC, the route will be diverted towards Curzon Hall, National Press Club, Bangladesh Bank, up to Kamalapur Railway Station.

The route from TSC was supposed to touch Central Shaheed Minar, Fulbaria, Gulistan, and Tikatuli before reaching Sayedabad in the original plan.

Jica expressed disappointment over the last modification as well, since every alignment modification requires new feasibility study on the new section.

JICA GIVES DEADLINE
A Jica delegation meeting Communications Minister Syed Abul Hossain in his office yesterday asked him to give the final decision about the route within this month.

"We will take a decision after learning about the government's position on the alignment," one member of the delegation said, requesting anonymity.

He said Jica will be very disappointed if the government brings further modification in the alignment.

Jica Director Tomohide Ichiguchi, who led the four-member delegation, said his country will be able to provide the fund by January next year if Bangladesh clarifies its position within a month.

The communications minister said the metro rail project will be delayed if the alignment is modified again. "The loan sanction process of Jica will also be delayed by one year," he added.

Source: Metro rail stops at air force red signal
 
Related article:
Now Louis Kahn's JS masterpiece at stake

So, who's in control of the country's affairs? The military or the government? It just shows that Hasina and her cahoots barely have control over anything. Even given that loyalists are placed in key positions. Pathetic...

As far as the military is concerned, those cantonments should get back to civilians. The traffic in Dhaka is already very bad. I don't know as to what extent is the old airport is being used. I understand that the BAF has limited infrastructure. People say that the old airport is nothing but only helicopters land. Most of the BAF's fighter jets fly around the coastal regions, as well as around the current airport near Uttara (I just saw a bunch of MiGs passing overhead).

I don't know, but this matter needs to be addressed with respect to national security as well as the welfare of the nation's common citizens. The Phokir's League can't even do that.
 
BAF has airport there.. There are hangars... Helicopters in dhaka operate from this area..... This metro rail design will hamper their privacy for sure.. So 1st relocate their airport... I think objection made by BAF is valid here
 
BAF has airport there.. There are hangers... Helicopters in dhaka operate from this area..... This metro rail design will hamper their privacy for sure.. So 1st relocate their airport... I think objection made by BAF is valid here

Or put up some giant as barricades? Seems like a simple enough solution. I think Bangalore Metro had similar issue.
 
Didnt they think all of that in advance?? Indian government is one of the worst project planners!
 
Didnt they think all of that in advance?? Indian government is one of the worst project planners!

Where in any of the posts above do you find the word Indian Govt ? If not then obviously in your haste to find fault with India you have surmised this relates to India.

It could if Dhaka was in India , but it isnt .

The Air Force in discussion is BAF not IAF and the city in question is Dhaka.
 
Zabanya

Cantonments are always a ripe fruit for the realtors because they are well laid out.

They are well laid out, not because the military should be given perks and privileges, but for a very practical reason.

If the military units were located cheek by jowl with civilian houses, then the security can be jeopardised as also the troops could become a nuisance to the civilians wherein there would be discipline problems and the respect that the military should have from the nation would be lost.

That apart, when a war looms, the troops and equipment like tanks, artillery, missiles, engineer and plant equipment all have to be moved fast to the military siding (at railway stations) or airfields so that they can speedily reach their operational location, be in position in a military manner and poised to take on the enemy as per plan once the war starts (this movement is called mobilisation).

Imagine, the military units were in congested areas as is found in cities or even small suburban towns. They would take a whole lot of time to move through the congested roads and would be delayed and even unprepared in their operational location when the balloon goes up.

Therefore, maybe there are good reasons why Cantonments are not given up to accommodate the urban pressures of the civilian population.
 
Japan is our financial donor since independence... I am so grateful to this nation... They have no self interest helping BD.. China is a friend but Japan is like Saviour. . .
 
Didnt they think all of that in advance?? Indian government is one of the worst project planners!

Forgive me. but that statement without any backup appears to be merely a gut reaction of prima facie, the unintelligent.

Do be good enough as to explain a wee bit more to be intelligent to enlighten the general public like me.
 
Cantonments are always a ripe fruit for the realtors because they are well laid out.

They are well laid out, not because the military should be given perks and privileges, but for a very practical reason.

If the military units were located cheek by jowl with civilian houses, then the security can be jeopardised as also the troops could become a nuisance to the civilians wherein there would be discipline problems and the respect that the military should have from the nation would be lost.

That apart, when a war looms, the troops and equipment like tanks, artillery, missiles, engineer and plant equipment all have to be moved fast to the military siding (at railway stations) or airfields so that they can speedily reach their operational location, be in position in a military manner and poised to take on the enemy as per plan once the war starts (this movement is called mobilisation).

Imagine, the military units were in congested areas as is found in cities or even small suburban towns. They would take a whole lot of time to move through the congested roads and would be delayed and even unprepared in their operational location when the balloon goes up.

Therefore, maybe there are good reasons why Cantonments are not given up to accommodate the urban pressures of the civilian population.

Yeah this is an important factor in wartime. Such as free streets of israel during yom kippur facilated them to quickly mobilize... But all the cantonments (dhk ctg) are situated in the heart of the cities in Bangladesh... Maybe Urban warfare tactics is adopted by BD army..

p.s. Dhaka cantonment has seperate road that opens outside north of dhaka and a rail station is within the cantonment....
 
Back
Top Bottom