I have questions for administrators of the forum here.
1. Why Indians are allowed to drag and open threads for bashing other members of forum here.
2. Why admins become apologetic when Indians challenge their moderation.
If you want to have a fair board then why you are biased towards Pakistani members when they post such threads but let the Indians carry on.
There are alot of BS posted by Indians here.
If something is BS which Zaid Hamid said then Indians should come up with logical replies but they always post oneliner BS without any logic.
They also abused Munshi many times therefore they should also be advised not to post more rubish.
I have handed out infractions and warnings to several Indian members for attacking Munshi needlessly, and have deleted several posts taunting him or attacking him, far more than get reported.
And the above is what needs to happen more - report the posts that are personal attacks.
Secondly, the thread you refer to started off by questioning Munshi's sources and contributors in his book. That is not an invalid line of argument and is not a personal attack.
That said, I thought the arguments made to discredit Munshi's sources were very weak, essentially some unknown guy stating that Munshi's well known contributors were 'analysts, not journalists'. That was a very simple argument to refute if you were supporting Munshi sahib, had it been done with civility and rationally.
The thread was closed when the moderators checked it (and we are not on 24/7, so we can only get to things when we do log on, and we do not read each thread or post) and found that it had degraded to nonsense and personal attacks.
On your second point - I do not see moderators becoming 'apologetic' when their moderation is challenged. We will offer an explanation or two, if we choose, and beyond that we have banned members for not dropping the subject and continuing to question moderator decisions.
That we have both Indian and Pakistani members complain about our moderation is perhaps indicative of the fact that our moderation is relatively evenhanded.
I think some Pakistani members have to not be so comfortable with the idea that this is a Pakistani forum, and therefore they can get away with posting half-assed rebuttals. Do your work, read, find sources supporting your PoV, and then post your post refuting an Indian argument.
All of the information you need is at your fingertips on the WWW, but too many Pakistanis don't bother to research whatever they are commenting on because they are too comfortable with this being a Pakistani forum.
Read books - buy them or check them out at the library, and ask the senior members for recommendations on subjects interesting to you and become more informed and knowledgeable.
One last thing, just because some guy takes an anti_India position does not mean that we just jump on his bandwagon and accept and defend everything he says.
