Icarus
RETIRED MOD
- Joined
- Sep 23, 2009
- Messages
- 9,040
- Reaction score
- 78
- Country
- Location
i did not not say the army only allows muslims only, you misinterprated my quote
Oh, sorry, I meant to quote someone else and got your post by mistake.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
i did not not say the army only allows muslims only, you misinterprated my quote
no problemOh, sorry, I meant to quote someone else and got your post by mistake.
Question: What is your message to entire Pakistani nation?
Dr. Mimpal Singh: I have a sincere advice to all Pakistanis, to understand and realize your individual responsibilities. We have an ancient habit to blame our government and our politicians but before blaming anyone else, we should have to realize the fact that what we actually have given to our country.
Secondly, I also request all my Pakistani brothers and sisters to educate their children which is really mandatory for complete awareness in our society and I believe that 75% of our problems can be resolved with this single step.
Sometimes, you make very illogical statements.Actually, there are plenty of Christians already inside Pakistan's military and other institutions. Some of the prestigious schools and hospitals are actually Christian / Church owned (St. Mary's, St. Peters, UCH, etc). I've been to events there through these organizations a long time ago.
But generally speaking, more minorities should join the armed forced. Its their country. In fact, there should be a quota set by the government to recruit at the least 20-30% of minorities.
Ya Ali Madad is also shouted by majority of Sunnis."Allahu Akbar" is the standard war cry of the Army but there are a number of other variations. Many Regiments with history have their own Ep Ep, Kai Kai, Haidri, Powindah are just some of the more famous ones. There is no set criteria that soldiers are bound to shout a particular phrase in battle, Shia soldiers prefer to say Ya Ali Madad but I have never seen or heard someone being reprimanded for it. The same extends for non-Muslims as well. Christians usually use the word Allah so Christian soldiers shout Allahu Akbar as well.
There was a famous incident during Kargil war,where Mujahid company of Grenadiers Regiment confused the enemy in Kargil,incidentally they had the same war cry Allah Hu Akbar.That has more to do with the fact that:
1. Hindus and Sikhs represent a very small fraction of the population.
2. Hindus are mostly associated with the medical profession in Pakistan whereas Sikhs usually choose to pursue business.
"Allahu Akbar" is the standard war cry of the Army but there are a number of other variations. Many Regiments with history have their own Ep Ep, Kai Kai, Haidri, Powindah are just some of the more famous ones. There is no set criteria that soldiers are bound to shout a particular phrase in battle, Shia soldiers prefer to say Ya Ali Madad but I have never seen or heard someone being reprimanded for it. The same extends for non-Muslims as well. Christians usually use the word Allah so Christian soldiers shout Allahu Akbar as well.
The military serves an Islamic Republic but is an inherently secular institution. There are strict standards of discipline that must be met and no one would dare challenge them, in a regiment the men live, sleep and fight together so it doesn't matter what god they believe in, there are stronger bonds of camaraderie between them.
Ya Ali Madad is also shouted by majority of Sunnis.
"Nara-e-Haidri, Ya Ali!" is as common as "Nara-e-Takbir, Allah hu Akbar" as far as I have seen. Everyone's into it.It was the most common phrase before Zia set "Allahu Akbar" as the standard, it has returned since but has yet to become as popular as it was in its heyday.
From what I know, Ya in Arabic is used only for the living as in YaAllah. Assuming the military comprises mostly of Sunnis, how come Ya Ali is a popular phrase?It was the most common phrase before Zia set "Allahu Akbar" as the standard, it has returned since but has yet to become as popular as it was in its heyday.
"Nara-e-Haidri, Ya Ali!" is as common as "Nara-e-Takbir, Allah hu Akbar" as far as I have seen. Everyone's into it.
From what I know, Ya in Arabic is used only for the living as in YaAllah. Assuming the military comprises mostly of Sunnis, how come Ya Ali is a popular phrase?
Because majority of sunnis are shouting this slogan since the beginning of Islam.From what I know, Ya in Arabic is used only for the living as in YaAllah. Assuming the military comprises mostly of Sunnis, how come Ya Ali is a popular phrase?
Because majority of sunnis are shouting this slogan since the beginning of Islam.