Mamata throws open challenge to Modi

[thesolar65]

.....imagine a WWE type fight between Mamata and Modi......who do you think would win?...

Modi ka dadhi woh khich legi, but Mamata with her legs up will not be a pleasant sight!! She has to wear a pajama. Agar Mamata ka bas chalega toh woh Modi ko choke kar degi. Even if Modi slams the floor three times, she will try to finish him!!....

 

[scorpionx]

Her hubris has reached dangerous levels now and openly challenging the head of the government of India like this cannot be ignored. She doesn't seem interested in pursuing the development agenda in either her state or India as a whole and is instead disrupting such efforts.

I understand the judiciary is apolitical and it's not as though Modi can do anything personally against her in a democracy that India is but this is getting out of hand now.

She is a very minuscule challenge to Modi or Amit Shah's political smartness. CPI M was a regimented party with strong hierarchical power structure. Her party does not have such any and it is fragile against slightest opposing political movements. So, I believe in the coming elections in 2015 we will see some interesting results.

 

[Abingdonboy]

She is a very minuscule challenge to Modi or Amit Shah's political smartness. CPI M was a regimented party with strong hierarchical power structure. Her party does not have such any and it is fragile against slightest opposing political movements. So, I believe in the coming elections in 2015 we will see some interesting results.

I'm more interested in seeing her prosecuted for her wrongdoing. It's said she has been letting anti-national elements into India and operate out of WB, the NIA is conducting an investigation into this AFAIK. It was claimed there was definitive proof to link her to such activities. All such traitors need to be prosecuted in India I don't care simply about her losing political office, that is not enough.

 

[Bang Galore]

I'm more interested in seeing her prosecuted for her wrongdoing. It's said she has been letting anti-national elements into India and operate out of WB, the NIA is conducting an investigation into this AFAIK. It was claimed there was definitive proof to link her to such activities. All such traitors need to be prosecuted in India I don't care simply about her losing political office, that is not enough.

Won't happen.

 

[Abingdonboy]

Won't happen.

This is what I fear also....

 

[dray]

@DRAY @scorpionx @Roybot @Skull and Bones and other west bengalis

Her wish will be fulfilled, but not so soon, usko tadpa tadpa ke dheere dheere slow motion mein jail bheja jayega.

She questioned "Kunal chor (thief), Tumpai (Srinjoy) chor, Madan chor, Mukul chor, ami chor (am I a thief)?
Now, Kunal is in jail, Tumpai (Srinjoy) is in jail, Madan is in jail, guess who are next in line?

Facebook is flooded with posts about this, in typical Bengali style; some examples below!


সংশয় ছিল না আগাগোড়া,
বলেছিলে সবই চক্রান্ত,
মনগড়া....

তবুও আধো ঘুমে দিশাহারা,
পিয়ালী কি আজও দেয় সাড়া?
এনে কানের কাছে মুখ,
সহানুভুতির আলতো চুক চুক...

" মদন, জেলে আছো? "
-------------------------------------------------------------------

ইকির মিকির স্ক্যাম চিকির
স্ক্যামের টাকা বদ হজম
জেলে গেল দা মদন।
দা মদনের চেলাগুলো
দুওরে বসে দুয়ো দিল
ঠগ বাছতে হলো বেলা
সিবিয়াইয়ের এক ঠ্যালা
ঠ্যালার নামই বাবাজী
বাকিগুলোও কি পাজী
বেরোবে সব কথা,
কান টানলে মাথা!
--------------------------------------------------------------------

ডাক এসেছে ডাক এসেছে,
লঙ্কাভাগের কালনেমি।
মিছিল আছে হাঁটতে হবে
নন্দন থেকে অ্যাকাডেমি।
ঋণ শোধবার দিন এসেছে,
যা পেয়েছি এতদিনে।
বুদ্ধিজীবি বুদ্ধি কোথায়?
সব বেচেছি নীল কিনে।
মাথা কবেই গেছে ঝুঁকে,
শিরদাঁড়াটাও বাঁকলো আজ।
কেউ বা পালায়, কেউ বা লুকায়
অজুহাত বাইরে কাজ!
তবু ক্রমে হবেই প্রকাশ,
তোষামোদের সাতকাহন।
বুঝছিনা এ কিসের মিছিল!
প্রতিবাদ না পদলেহন!!!
---------------------------------------------------------------------

সমস্ত দিনের শেষে শিশিরের শব্দের মতন
সিবিআই আসে; অবৈধ টাকার গন্ধ মুছে ফেলে কাক;
সারদার সব রঙ নিভে গেলে ভাউচার করে আয়োজন
তখন সত্যের তরে প্রমাণ ও সাক্ষী সব রঙে ঝিলমিল;
সব চোর জেলে আসে-সব তৃণ- ফুরায় এ-জীবনের সব লেনদেন;
থাকে শুধু অন্ধকার, মুখোমুখি বসিবার সুদীপ্ত সেন।
----------------------------------------------------------------------

বিধানসভায় পার্থ চট্টোপাধ্যায় তার বক্তৃতার সময় এক গল্প বললেন...."“এক বাবা তার তিন ছেলেকে ১০০টাকা করে দিয়ে বলল যে এমন কিছুকিনে আনো যাতে ঘরটা পুরো ভর্তি হয়ে যায়।.
# ১ম_ছেলে ১০০ টাকার খড় কিনে আনলকিন্তু ঘর পুরোপুরি ভর্তি করতে পারলনা।.
# ২য়_ছেলে ১০০ টাকারতুলা কিনে আনল কিন্তু সেও ঘরপুরোপুরি ভর্তি করতে পারল না।.
# ৩য়_ছেলে৫টাকা দিয়ে একটা মোমবাতি কিনে আনলএবং রুমের মাঝে জ্বালাল। এতে পুরো ঘরসম্পূর্ণ আলোতে ভর্তি হয়ে গেলো।
“.পার্থ চট্টোপাধ্যায় আরওবলতে লাগলেন যে “আমাদেরমুখ্যমন্ত্রী হচ্ছেন ৩য় ছেলের মতো।যেদিন থেকে তিনি দায়িত্ব নিয়েছেনএই রাজ্য উন্নতির আলোতে পূর্ণহয়ে গিয়েছে।”..
পিছন থেকে আওয়াজ আসলোঃ
“সেটাতো ঠিকই আছে, কিন্তু বাকি ৯৫ টাকা গেলো কোথায়????”
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[scorpionx]

I'm more interested in seeing her prosecuted for her wrongdoing. It's said she has been letting anti-national elements into India and operate out of WB, the NIA is conducting an investigation into this AFAIK. It was claimed there was definitive proof to link her to such activities. All such traitors need to be prosecuted in India I don't care simply about her losing political office, that is not enough.

Honestly speaking there is still no evidence of any direct link up between Mamata and Jamaat Ul Mujahidin Bangladesh. Jamaat Ul Islami has been given political asylum here for decades for votebank politics in the bordering area, there is no doubt about that. Mamata did the same and she did oppose LBA and Teesta deal which put India-Bangladesh relation in much disarray and Hasina did find herself into troubled water in domestic Bangladeshi politics due to that. But Bannerjee will knowingly plan to assassinate Hasina is little difficult for me to believe. One of her MP is under interrogation and only future can tell what her role was in this whole case.

 

[Bang Galore]

She is a very minuscule challenge to Modi or Amit Shah's political smartness. CPI M was a regimented party with strong hierarchical power structure. Her party does not have such any and it is fragile against slightest opposing political movements. So, I believe in the coming elections in 2015 we will see some interesting results.

TMC is a unidimensional party, i.e it knows only one way to react to any situation. However their big advantage is the continuing decimation of CPM, another party that simply does not know what to do out of power having never faced that situation before. That pretty much makes TMC the only choice for the minorities (odd support to the BJP not withstanding) giving her a huge block of support unconcerned about governance issues. Can still be beaten but will take some doing.

This is what I fear also....

Better to defeat her politically than make a martyr of her.

 

[JanjaWeed]

She is a very minuscule challenge to Modi or Amit Shah's political smartness. CPI M was a regimented party with strong hierarchical power structure. Her party does not have such any and it is fragile against slightest opposing political movements. So, I believe in the coming elections in 2015 we will see some interesting results.

Looks like she is going for broke by declaring all out war against Modi & the govt. One more wicket of Mukul Roy.. she is as good as done! She is still relying on the politics of protest.. which has got her this far. But.. I don't think it will work this time around as the people she is protesting against are not confined to WB.. & have nothing to lose in Bengal. If any.. it's Mamta didi who has maximum to lose in this fight!

 

[Bang Galore]

Looks like she is going for broke .....

She always goes for broke....on everything. Like she went after Tata. She does only stop & go...

 

[scorpionx]

TMC is a unidimensional party, i.e it knows only one way to react to any situation. However their big advantage is the continuing decimation of CPM, another party that simply does not know what to do out of power having never faced that situation before. That pretty much makes TMC the only choice for the minorities (odd support to the BJP not withstanding) giving her a huge block of support unconcerned about governance issues. Can still be beaten but will take some doing.

True. But 2010 has shown that a massive political monolith can be removed with a single stroke (last assembly election before that was quite in favor of the left) of violent agitation. The left always enjoyed around 50% voting percentage through out their rule but TMC's voting percentage roams around 40%. Also, the communal card will not make much difference I guess. People at the ground level are smarter and knows political safeguard is not much needed for the minorities here. Cadres are mostly opportunists and recent victory of BJP in a Muslim majority area like Basirhat proves that TMC can not rely on 'minority votebank' any more.

Looks like she is going for broke by declaring all out war against Modi & the govt. One more wicket of Mukul Roy.. she is as good as done! She is still relying on the politics of protest.. which has got her this far. But.. I don't think it will work this time around as the people she is protesting against are not confined to WB.. & have nothing to lose in Bengal. If any.. it's Mamta didi who has maximum to lose in this fight!

Mukul Roy was the first accused in this whole issue. He managed the financial aspects of the party and he is going to face plenty of bouncers next year. Bannerjee is relying on her instincts now and it is going to lead her straight to the pit.

 

[Bang Galore]

True. But 2010 has shown that a massive political monolith can be removed with a single stroke (last assembly election before that was quite in favor of the left) of violent agitation. The left always enjoyed around 50% voting percentage through out their rule but TMC's voting percentage roams around 40%. Also, the communal card will not make much difference I guess. People at the ground level are smarter and knows political safeguard is not much needed for the minorities. Cadres are mostly opportunists and recent victory of BJP in a Muslim majority area like Basirhat proves that TMC can not rely on 'minority votebank' any more.

Will defer to your superior understanding of the ground situation.

 

[jha]

Open Challenge..? Hmm... Very interesting days ahead. Reports of TMC MLAs planning to join BJP have already started coming. She is obviously getting jittery. This opposition is unlike CPM and is willing to play a lengthy game. Her ministers will keep getting arrested every 3-4 months giving CBI ample time to build strong case against each individual. All she can do is announce such rallies in protest with number of people decreasing in each one.

It seems she has stopped listening to Mukul Roy as well and is trying to prop up her nephew as No. 2. Any such step is bound to have unfavorable consequences and same is being reflected in all her recent actions.

 

[JanjaWeed]

She always goes for broke....on everything. Like she went after Tata.

She had a lot to gain politically in Bengal with that fight! Even though the fight was against Tata, her actual target was the sitting govt in Kolkata!

She does only stop & go...

Give her a reason.. she will even protest against protests!

 

[Bang Galore]

She had a lot to gain politically in Bengal with that fight! Even though the fight was against Tata, her actual target was the sitting govt in Kolkata!

True but she kept fighting even after winning elections. What I meant was she cannot separate the agitational positioning from the actual act of governing.