What's new

Majority of Pakistanis View US as Enemy

Fighter488

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Dec 5, 2009
Messages
1,050
Reaction score
0
Poll: Majority of Pakistanis View US as Enemy


A new opinion poll indicates that roughly six in 10 Pakistanis view the United States as an enemy, oppose the war in Afghanistan and are becoming less concerned about the threat of the Taliban and al-Qaida.

The survey, released by the U.S.-based Pew Research Center this week, shows that despite intense U.S. outreach and billions of dollars in aid, Pakistanis remain extremely skeptical of Washington's intentions.

Negative image

America's overall image remains very negative in Pakistan, says the center's president Andrew Kohut.

"Along with the Turks and Egyptians, Pakistanis give the United States the lowest ratings of the 20 countries that we polled,'" said Kohut. "And President Obama's famous global popularity does not extend to Pakistan. And when we ask people questions about the United States more specifically, a majority say they consider the United States an enemy of Pakistan, not an ally of Pakistan."

Mistrust linked to relations with India

Kohut adds some of that mistrust stems from Washington's close relationship with India, which 53 percent of survey respondents said is Pakistan's biggest threat.

"The serious concerns that Pakistanis have about the United States co-exist with, and are related to, the deep worries that Pakistanis have about India. In fact, Pakistanis are more worried about the external threat of India than they are worried about the internal threat of extremist groups," Kohut said.

History also plays a role in Washington's troubled relationship with Islamabad.

During the 1980s, the United States worked with Pakistan to support Afghan guerilla fighters battling the Soviet army. After the Afghans successfully expelled Soviet forces, the U.S. support abruptly ended.

Rebuilding trust

U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates said in a news conference Thursday that Washington is still rebuilding the trust that was lost in the years that followed.

"One of the challenges the U.S. has faced in both Afghanistan and Pakistan is that they vividly remember us walking out in 1989 and being left to deal with their own security situation on their own. The notion that, under those circumstances and not knowing whether they could count on us to be there, the notion that they would hedge in one way or another is not a surprise," Gates said.

Washington has pledged $7.5 billion in aid to Islamabad over the next five years to try to win the support of civilians who are suspicious of the U.S. fight against militants in Pakistan, and the U.S.-led war in neighboring Afghanistan.

But despite massive amounts of foreign aid, the Pew Research poll shows only 17 percent of Pakistani respondents have a favorable view of America, and just 11 percent view it as a partner.

Opposition to Afghan war

Moreover, the survey shows Pakistanis widely oppose the U.S.-led war in Afghanistan, and only a quarter of respondents think it would be bad for their country if the Taliban regained control of Afghanistan.

"There is a sharp decline in concern that extremists would take over the country compared to attitudes in 2009," said Pew president Andrew Kohut. "Worries about the threat of the Taliban were less extensive, and there was much less concern about al-Qaida than there was in 2009."

Pakistan has waged its own fight against Taliban militants who continue to carry out a wave of suicide attacks on soft targets in Pakistan. Despite military operations against Islamic extremists in Swat Valley and South Waziristan, Washington and Kabul both say Islamabad should do more to fight terrorism.

According to the Pew poll, few Pakistanis are happy with the situation in their country. Of the 2,000 adults interviewed last April, 84 percent said they are dissatisfied with the state of their nation. And just 20 percent had a positive view of their president, Asif Ali Zardari. The grim ratings were driven by widespread concerns about terrorism, crime, political corruption, a weak economy and the ongoing dispute with India over Kashmir.


Poll: Majority of Pakistanis View US as Enemy | News | English
 
.
.
AoA

Sir, it's a very flawed article.

Did it ever occur to the author that most Pakistanis (on the ‘street’, not merely the ones sitting comfortably in AC & Land Cruiser) have negative views towards some of the foreign policy of the U.S.? We aren’t alone, I have seen polls even conducted in countries like UK, Turkey, France, Italy --- in all those countries there was anti-American sentiment existing – not because the whole world loves to hate Americans. No, it’s because of the foreign policy. Whether its U.S. role (inaction and one sidedness) on israil-Palestine conflict; Iraq invasion; policy in Afghanistan; etc. --- there are some people who view it as imperialism, bullying, and being self-centered. I think the Aafia Siddiqui incident alone had a very detrimental impact on perception of the U.S.


The best way the U.S. can win more support and friendship with the people here is to view the relationship on an eye to eye level; to recognize our needs and our concerns; and to view the relationship with Pakistan as a genuine one, not a transactional one where we are just using eachother to achieve certain goals.

I can understand if Americans have some negative views towards Pakistan. Same way, it should be understandable if America (not Americans) is perceived negatively by Pakistanis.

But I have a huge problem with labeling America and Americans an ‘’enemy.’’ That is preposterous.









p.s. if I could be handed the mic during a session @ U.S. Congress, first thing I would lobby for is for America to STOP giving Pakistan govt. aid money. Give us market access, but for God’s sakes do not spoil these politicians. When will they get their acts together? Very critical and historic times we are going through.
 
.
The best way the U.S. can win more support and friendship with the people here is to view the relationship on an eye to eye level; to recognize our needs and our concerns -
In my opinion, all these things can happen, yet not promote a better U.S.-Pakistan relationship.

- view the relationship with Pakistan as a genuine one, not a transactional one where we are just using eachother to achieve certain goals.
Expand on this, please.

...I would lobby for is for America to STOP giving Pakistan govt. aid money. Give us market access, but for God’s sakes do not spoil these politicians.
Would you rather that the Pakistani government collect more taxes from its citizenry?
 
. . .
In my opinion, all these things can happen, yet not promote a better U.S.-Pakistan relationship.

i disagree.....it's a good start; but best way is to work more on people to people level. Work with the people on the street, in the rural areas, not just the big cities; not just the big names.

Even building a hospital or a school that was destroyed by terrorists, that can make a difference. In fairness to the U.S. they have done such initiatives, they just dont go so much reported.

Expand on this, please.

oh commonnn Suleyman! You know what I'm talking about :)


Would you rather that the Pakistani government collect more taxes from its citizenry?

BINGO --- absolutely, 10,000% correct.

but this will require more internal effort, a collective one. In nowhere in the world do services or any benefits come for free. Govt. needs to act, and people of all economic backgrounds need to chip in.

It is the industrialists, landowners and politicians who are most guilty of not meeting their ''national obligations''

but thats a wholleeeee other subject.



To reiterate very broadly what i said earlier --Pakistani masses dont view America as an enemy. Just some of the foreign policy of the U.S.

give a Visa and a ticket to almost any Pakistani and i'm sure they'd love to visit the U.S. or even settle there for better employment possibilities. So then?
 
.
its so obvious, those u couldnt get a clue, drone attacks, that bush statement to throw us into stone age if v dont cooperate, and that hilary threatening us??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????, US blessing our enemy india, giving it nuke tech while rejecting their best allies?????????????????
 
.
AoA

Sir, it's a very flawed article.

Did it ever occur to the author that most Pakistanis (on the ‘street’, not merely the ones sitting comfortably in AC & Land Cruiser) have negative views towards some of the foreign policy of the U.S.? We aren’t alone, I have seen polls even conducted in countries like UK, Turkey, France, Italy --- in all those countries there was anti-American sentiment existing – not because the whole world loves to hate Americans. No, it’s because of the foreign policy. Whether its U.S. role (inaction and one sidedness) on israil-Palestine conflict; Iraq invasion; policy in Afghanistan; etc. --- there are some people who view it as imperialism, bullying, and being self-centered. I think the Aafia Siddiqui incident alone had a very detrimental impact on perception of the U.S.


The best way the U.S. can win more support and friendship with the people here is to view the relationship on an eye to eye level; to recognize our needs and our concerns; and to view the relationship with Pakistan as a genuine one, not a transactional one where we are just using eachother to achieve certain goals.

I can understand if Americans have some negative views towards Pakistan. Same way, it should be understandable if America (not Americans) is perceived negatively by Pakistanis.

But I have a huge problem with labeling America and Americans an ‘’enemy.’’ That is preposterous.









p.s. if I could be handed the mic during a session @ U.S. Congress, first thing I would lobby for is for America to STOP giving Pakistan govt. aid money. Give us market access, but for God’s sakes do not spoil these politicians. When will they get their acts together? Very critical and historic times we are going through.

To start with I also dis-agree with the article. It is a flawed peice of article, intentionally or un-intentionally.

I am talking about the bold part here. We hear these words and sentiments so many times from Pakistani populace that it is loosing its shean and mean now. Why every-time some thing hapen in Pakistan this argument/fear/confession is repeated?

Why Pakistanis do not DO SOMETHING to get these EVER-CHANGING-HISTORIC-TIMES syndrome? Why there is no stability in Pakistan? Who is responsible for this mess? Who is going to bring back the lost paradise for Pakistan?

There are so many answered questions here.
 
. .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom