LOL, awkward Vietnam propaganda video,1988 sea battle

[Aepsilons]

proof !?
LOL, proof from invader, like US's proof when they invade Iraq !?
And your mouth full with "fake", "Vietnamese propaganda", but there is:

Created by ottovonstierlitz (Wehrmacht) in Germany, May 2009

And look at how many maps draw by third party who recognize Paracel and (part of) Spartly were belongs to Vietnamese:

@Soryu ,

Prior to the Nguyen Dynasty, who had control of these islands?

 

[Rechoice]

@Soryu ,

Prior to the Nguyen Dynasty, who had control of these islands?

Nguyen Dynsty has been established the navy flotte with the name "Flotte control Hoang Sa and Truong Sa"

 

[kankan326]

study our history kid. Nguyen Dynsty has been established the Flotte navy with the name "Flotte control Hoang Sa and Truong Sa"

Islands is part of territory Vietnam.
View attachment 150383

Isn't this map fake or what? Even it's real. These dots are just the islands close to Vietnam coast. Which perfectly reflects Vietnamese navigation skill at that time.

 

[Soryu]

@Soryu ,

Prior to the Nguyen Dynasty, who had control of these islands?

Nguyễn Lords, the house which became Nguyễn Dynasty later, when they control Middle and southern part of Vietnam ( former Champa and Khmer lands) in early years of 17th century.

 

[Rechoice]

Isn't this map fake or what? Even it's real. These dots are just the islands close to Vietnam coast. Which perfectly reflects Vietnamese navigation skill at that time.

drawing is showed that Island is closer to coast line of Vietnam, it is to demonstration that the Islands belong to Vietnam. This is nature of our map.

 

[Aepsilons]

Nguyễn Lords, the house which became Nguyễn Dynasty later, when they control Middle and southern part of Vietnam ( former Champa and Khmer lands) in early years of 17th century.

Okay, thanks. So then it seems that the Vietnamese have some kind of historical basis to it.

 

[Soryu]

Isn't this map fake or what? Even it's real. These dots are just the islands close to Vietnam coast. Which perfectly reflects Vietnamese navigation skill at that time.

And you want to say your "so good" history evidence "Zheng He Voyage Map" like proof about Chinese's control with those Islands !?
Oh, look at your great map by Zheng He:

Is real world look like your map !?

You want ancient map correct like nowaday maps !???

 

[Rechoice]

Nguyễn Lords, the house which became Nguyễn Dynasty later, when they control Middle and southern part of Vietnam ( former Champa and Khmer lands) in early years of 17th century.

ols map stated that in 17th century. Hoang Sa is part of Quang Ngai Province

Tấm bản đồ do Đậu Bá Công Đạo vẽ từ thế kỷ XVII với dòng chữ "Bãi Cát vàng" - biểu thị quần đảo Trường Sa, Hoàng Sa do Chúa Nguyễn quản ly.

 

[kankan326]

And you want to say your "so good" history evidence "Zheng He Voyage Map" like proof about Chinese's control with those Islands !?
Oh, look at your great map by Zheng He:

View attachment 150399

Is real look like your map !?

You want acicent map correct like nowaday maps !???

Vietnamese like to post old maps. The water territory is a modern concept. Why you always looking for proofs from ancient maps? This is the most ridiculous thing from the beginning.

Chinese history in SCS is far more earlier than Zheng He era.

 

[Soryu]

Vietnamese like to post old maps. The water territory is a modern concept. Why you always looking for proofs from ancient maps? This is the most ridiculous thing from the beginning.

Chinese history in SCS is far more earlier than Zhen he era.

Yes, you're right, so what's your base to draw 9-10-11-dash-line (and change whenever you like )
Base on UNCLOS !? No.

Chinese history in SCS is far more earlier than Zhen he era.
So what !?
You have some activity on sea, travel through its and sea and islands belong to you !?

LOL, come on, it's all like many old topics about these issues, at the end, you Chinese alway saying this: "Our claim base on power", "We control it now, come to get it ..." bla bla bla ... so stop your boring propaganda trick.

 

[kankan326]

Yes, you're right, so what's your base to draw 9-10-11-dash-line (and change whenever you like )
Base on UNCLOS !? No.

Chinese history in SCS is far more earlier than Zhen he era.
So what !?
You have some activity on sea, travel through its and sea and islands belong to you !?

LOL, come on, it's all like many old topics about these issues, at the end, you Chinese alway saying this: "Our claim base on power", "We control it now, come to get it ..." bla bla bla ... so stop your boring propaganda.

Check my 12# reply.

 

[Soryu]

Check my 12# reply.

So This is official reason declared by PRC government !?
LOL, your trick failed again.
The Victory status mean you can draw anything whenever you like !?

Most things about proof of China about sovereignty on SCS which report by Chinese media was history record and evidence.
If it was real base of you, why alway bring on Pham Van Dong letter and history records at first !?

 

[kankan326]

So This is official reason declared by PRC government !?
LOL, your trick failed again.
The Victory status mean you can draw anything whenever you like !?

Most things about proof of China about sovereignty on SCS which report by Chinese media was history record and evidence.
If it was real base of you, why alway bring on Pham Van Dong letter and history records at first !?

We got enough. Except those ugly and rough maps and very likely fake tales, what you have?

From this photo, people would have an illusion that it was Vietnam who defeated Japan.

 

[Soryu]

We got enough. Except those ugly and rough maps and very likely fake tales, what you have?

From this photo, people would have an illusion that it was Vietnam who defeated Japan.

Why it related to Japan here, again !? I don't know where that map come from, but This is Vietnam claim on SCS:

Vietnam claims sovereignty over the islands based on history position and on the continental shelf principle. The ancient geographical map of Vietnam record Golden Sands Beach to indicate both the Paracel and Spratly Islands of Vietnam's territory since the beginning of the 17th century, Phu Bien Tap Luc In The scholar Le Quy Don, Hoang Sa and Truong Sa is defined in Quang Ngai. In the Đại Nam Thống Nhất Toàn Đồ, a map of Vietnam was completed in 1838, Spratly drawn under the territory of Vietnam. Vietnam has conducted several geographical and resources surveys on the islands. The results of the survey that has been recorded in the literature and history of Vietnam and published since the 17th century Furthermore, following an agreement signed with the Nguyen dynasty, France representing the interests of Vietnam to international affairs and enforced the sovereignty over the islands instead of Vietnam.

 

[AgentOrange]

Why do Viets call it a "massacre"? It's clearly a case of Vietnamese stupidity on display. They sent a bunch of Viet Congs armed with AK-47s against Chinese 30mm cannons. And then one of the little guys got trigger happy and fired at the Chinese ship. What did they think was going to happen?