Lch vs WZ-10 vs Z-19

[kurup]

I always enjoy these comparisons, regardless if the Lch is a prototype or not.

I believe Lch is perhaps more comparable to the Z-19 in weight class and roles, but I think the Z-19 is rather superior in almost all aspects.

Z19 is a joke in front of LCH . Z19 is not even a orginal attack helicopter . It is a scout helicopter .

When comparing Z19 and LCH , Z19 is inferior to LCH in every account .

I think at least you should compare WZ10 with Apache 64.

True , WZ10 is a heavy attack helicopter . You cannot compare it to a light attack helicopter like LCH .

 

[Srinivas]

I know these machines are made for diffrent work.I also know that lch is still in prototypes.
But still on compilation and the onfo.available about all 3 machines ..how will we rank all 3 of them ??

Why are you asking chinese about their Russian designed attck helicopeters, They don't know anything about them .


Russia Built Chinese Z10 Helicopter - Business Insider

No need to compare India attack helis to russian designed chinese helicopters

 

[Anurag Rathore]

Why are you asking chinese about their Russian designed attck helicopeters, They don't know anything about them .


Russia Built Chinese Z10 Helicopter - Business Insider

No need to compare India attack helis to russian designed chinese helicopters

opps more apropriately copied from russia
assembled and painted in china

 

[Abingdonboy]

My 2 cents:

 

[Killswitch]

Wait for a war to happen. The only comparison that matters is performance on the battlefield. What we say on the forums doesnt change much.

 

[sardar1987]

I think we all are discounting a very simple fact-NUMBERS

Numbers matter and in this case the chinese are way ahead of us.

1)We may laugh at even f-35 but do we know that usa is planning induction of about 1800 f-35!!So whatever shortcomings they may have they will cover up in numbers and overwhelm the opposition

2)Similarly we laugh at chinese j-10,j-11,j-15 etc.While they may not be(or maybe) world class fighters chinese are producing those at such a feverish pace that it just won't matter when time comes,they will be fielded in hundreds or maybe even thousands(not quite)

3)Same is the story with helicopters.The numbers are a spoiler for india.For every one of lch built they are gonna make at leat 3-4 helicopters.

 

[by78]

I think we all are discounting a very simple fact-NUMBERS

Numbers matter and in this case the chinese are way ahead of us.

1)We may laugh at even f-35 but do we know that usa is planning induction of about 1800 f-35!!So whatever shortcomings they may have they will cover up in numbers and overwhelm the opposition

2)Similarly we laugh at chinese j-10,j-11,j-15 etc.While they may not be(or maybe) world class fighters chinese are producing those at such a feverish pace that it just won't matter when time comes,they will be fielded in hundreds or maybe even thousands(not quite)

3)Same is the story with helicopters.The numbers are a spoiler for india.For every one of lch built they are gonna make at leat 3-4 helicopters.

You are quite right. Although with the Indian economic crisis and the coming collapse of the Indian military budget, the Chinese are going to enjoy even greater advantages in numbers.

I suspect two years from now, this forum will be rather deserted compared to today.

 

[sardar1987]

You are quite right. Although with the Indian economic crisis and the coming collapse of the Indian military budget, the Chinese are going to enjoy even greater advantages in numbers.

I suspect two years from now, this forum will be rather deserted compared to today.

Even u are wrong.....economy is not collapsing as such,,,investors have lost trust in this govt and are taking the money out and investing in US.This trend will continue till general election next year and after that dependent upon new govt to steer the ship.....,,,and after a couple of years and some reforms the economy will be back on track.cheers

 

[by78]

Even u are wrong.....economy is not collapsing as such,,,investors have lost trust in this govt and are taking the money out and investing in US.This trend will continue till general election next year and after that dependent upon new govt to steer the ship.....,,,and after a couple of years and some reforms the economy will be back on track.cheers

I don't make optimistic assumptions. I don't assume things will return to 'normal'. Many countries in fact don't recover after a crisis. Argentina being a prime example of that.

Until India improves her HDI scores, there will be no sustainable bounce back. This time, it really is over.

 

[faithfulguy]

I don't make optimistic assumptions. I don't assume things will return to 'normal'. Many countries in fact don't recover after a crisis. Argentina being a prime example of that.

Until India improves her HDI scores, there will be no sustainable bounce back. This time, it really is over.

How about if India choose to join the British Union and make the queen of England their Monarch. Would that help?

 

[armchairPrivate]

^^^^

The UK is pretty sick themselves. Plus The British are racist.

When HK was about to be revered to China, The British changed their citizenship law to exclude the HK people from holding British passport, so the HKers couldn't stay in UK.

Same thing would be done to the Indians if they go with England.

 

[faithfulguy]

^^^^

The UK is pretty sick themselves. Plus The British are racist.

When HK was about to be revered to China, The British changed their citizenship law to exclude the HK people from holding British passport, so the HKers could stay in UK.

Same thing would be done to the Indians if they go with England.

I'm sure the Brits would treat the tech support guys like crap. But the Indians are still better off under that arrangement than continue the way things are going.

that is when you are between a rock and hard place.

 

[armchairPrivate]

^^^

Well it is true that.

There will be a a toilet construction boom in the UK then.

 

[Luftwaffe]

Z19 is a joke in front of LCH . Z19 is not even a orginal attack helicopter . It is a scout helicopter .

When comparing Z19 and LCH , Z19 is inferior to LCH in every account .

Z-19 is not inferior to LCH the role is different but it is an open platform, it can perform like AH-1 twin Engine variant with machine gun an optional can be installed, for export market it would be one hell of a low cost Gunship. It can be used as both scout and regular gunship.

@Abingdonboy, you can put your charitable 2 cent back in your pocket Z-10 is deployed, by the time LCH come to the scene Z-10 would be undergoing or would have complete modernization to Block II, personally I find LCH a good gunship as it is home made it comes with alot of advantages but it is as of now not yet comparable to Z-10 one will enter from prototyping to production and the other has been operation and slated for upgrades/modernization.

 

[Flat_Top56]

Why are you asking chinese about their Russian designed attck helicopeters, They don't know anything about them .


Russia Built Chinese Z10 Helicopter - Business Insider

No need to compare India attack helis to russian designed chinese helicopters

Probably so... And your heli??