Lahore blast facilitator's house razed in Bajaur; father, brothers arrested

[Samurai_assassin]

What will happen to this man? Death penalty?

 

[Azlan]

Thats incorrect .. if brother and father are innocent then there should be no punishment for them ... however the facilitator should be killed by hanging on the same place where the bomb blast happened ...

Make him example ... kill him by torture .. but dont punish his fathers or brothers for his crime .. thats in justice ... it is also prohibited in Islam ...

_____________________________________________
How about make him sit on the same weight Bomb and then Booming it

 

[Kompromat]

Collective punishment is wrong.

 

[Lahorie]

And the Quran clearly says: "And no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another."

What a confused nation!

This is the rule set for Judgement Day. Don't try to apply it wrongly.

this collective law should be removed... why punish for an other's crime..

This punishment will act as deterrence against committing acts of terrorism against the state. The perpetrators / abettors will know that if they destroy the families of other, their own families will also face the same fate & family heads will keep an eye on their dependents for any illegal activity.

Collective punishment is wrong.

Maybe true but the families of perpetrators & abettors should also taste the same medicine as the families of the victims does. Set a few examples and the law will act as deterrence against suicide attacks & terrorism.

 

[Indika]

the administration can take the community or family members of the perpetrator to task and punish them under a collective responsibility clause.

Nonsense, how is family responsible for individuals actions. Uncivilized and unlawful action, state is terrorizing the innocent family.

 

[Samurai_assassin]

I truly hope Pakistan will never assist or come to the aid of Afghsnistan in its need. Nearly 40 years of providing assistance to Afghans and this is what Pak gets in return.

 

[The Accountant]

_____________________________________________
How about make him sit on the same weight Bomb and then Booming it

Good idea but i thin it will be too quick and easy death ... we can innovate by using small bombs on small parts detonating them one by one and letting him feel the pain ...

 

[MultaniGuy]

I hope the authorities capture the terrorists.

 

[Samurai_assassin]

Good idea but i thin it will be too quick and easy death ... we can innovate by using small bombs on small parts detonating them one by one and letting him feel the pain ...

Too extreme, let him sit in a small cell with no interaction. His mind will deteriorate rapidly and he will become mentally insane. Let him harm himself in the process.

 

[AmnaR]

Taken straight from the Israeli playbook in terms of dealing with terrorists.

The families are also punished. They say they do it to try to make terrorists think twice about what they're doing..I'm not sure it makes any difference.

Exactly. Army has been doing this for a while in Tribal areas as well... I think it'll create more terrorists...

In Israel it works because they also have excellent intelligence, the bastards of mossad are everywhere.. plus SO MANY checkposts.... Life is hell for palestinians

 

[Areesh]

Sad. Should have razed the house when father and the brothers were inside it.

In Israel it works because they also have excellent intelligence, the bastards of mossad are everywhere.. plus SO MANY checkposts.... Life is hell for palestinians

Stop comparing Pakistan with Israel.

I can only wish my country can be like Mossad and Israel.

 

[PDF]

Frontier Crimes Regulations......inhumane, unjust and un-ISlamic.....enough said...

 

[AmnaR]

Sad. Should have razed the house when father and the brothers were inside it.



Stop comparing Pakistan with Israel.

I can only wish my country can be like Mossad and Israel.

Lols. You are a joke sir. First line you say father n brother should have been killed just because they are related to a terrorist (they might be innocent. terrorist usually run away from home to get training etc and live in madrassas etc).

Then you say, stop comparing Pakistan to Israel. Lols. :The measures were taken in accordance with the Frontier Crimes Regulations' (FCR) territorial responsibility clause, which states that for any mishap, the administration can take the community or family members of the perpetrator to task and punish them under a collective responsibility clause.
The same law (with a different name) is used in Israel. Both are illegal under Islam and Geneva conventions.

Lastly, you wish they were similar. There are more paradoxes in your post than hairs on Trump

EDIT: Fun Fact. Do you know Pakistani Intelligence Agencies (along with many middle eastern countries) use Israeli softwares for counter terrorist operations?

 

[Areesh]

Frontier Crimes Regulations......inhumane, unjust and un-ISlamic.....enough said...

UnIslamic may be.

But nothing inhumane and unjust in demolishing a mud house that belonged to someone who facilitated mass murder of innocents.

 

[AmnaR]

I truly hope Pakistan will never assist or come to the aid of Afghsnistan in its need. Nearly 40 years of providing assistance to Afghans and this is what Pak gets in return.

Thats because finally when it mattered, we supported the wrong guys.. We supported India loving terrorists (aka Northern Alliance... many TTP members love northern alliance) and American puppet government... We used the ax on our own foot.