KSA never asked for Ground Troops

[truthseeker2010]

Why would that be " STUPID " ?

Our Saudi Brothers know that it would a considered an " Honour " by any Pakistani to be asked to help defend Makkah and Medina, the holiest of the holy cities for all Muslims.

i in no manner intended to dishonor anyone sir, i was just saying that why is everybody thinking that the holy mosques would be attacked in this civil conflict of yemen, both sides fightining there are muslims and are well aware of the importance of those places. Now you tell me is pak army going there for defending the mosques(from whom?) I was referring that the saudi's want pak army for their ground offensive rather than protecting holy mosques.

 

[Rakan.SA]

i agree but it we be union of few islamic countries not all . dream will be truth if iran saudi become like mermen-france after WW2 west learn this lesson after two world wars and we should learn without it look at it bro from Afghanistan to morocco whats going on is between Muslims and unless we solve major issues on tables we will remain like what we are even worse .

sorry i didnt understand what you meant.
im saying if the countries that are participating in the coalition started something out of this event its enough. we all have common interests we all have strategic locations. we can form something that will benefit also the ppl economically not just militarily.

i in no manner intended to dishonor anyone sir, i was just saying that why is everybody thinking that the holy mosques would be attacked in this civil conflict of yemen, both sides fightining there are muslims and are well aware of the importance of those places. Now you tell me is pak army going there for defending the mosques(from whom?) I was referring that the saudi's want pak army for their ground offensive rather than protecting holy mosques.

go back to my comment number 33 please
iran already attacked makka and madina. and every year they try to make problems.

 

[Lord ZeN]

When you don't know something please keep quite. Pakistan will fight along with KSA forces in defence of Saudi Arabia not only Pakistan but pretty much entire Armed Forces of Muslim world will fight you can in some delusion if you want but this is the fact

Are you sure ?

 

[Husnainshah]

we should all unite economically and military to fight terrorism and any threats from any country so we can stay busy building our countries and serving our ppl and investing in them. imagine if this coalition did that ? the outcome could be amazing. we can start a anti terrorist office between the countries of the coalition and share help and info and finance.
a lot of good things can come out of it.

That's just wishful thinking, pal. To begin with, there is no such thing as Muslim countries. There's Wahhabi Countries, Shi'ite Countries, Secular Countries. Muslims of one sect hate Muslims of other sects more than they hate Non-Muslims - I'm a witness to that. Every country has it's fair share of adventurous ambitions including Pakistan. Young people like yourself are inept of handling their emotions but the fact remains - Muslims can't unite, Period.

 

[Rakan.SA]

That's just wishful thinking, pal. To begin with, there is no such thing as Muslim countries. There's Wahhabi Countries, Shi'ite Countries, Secular Countries. Muslims of one sect hate Muslims of other sects more than they hate Non-Muslims - I'm a witness to that. Every country has it's fair share of adventurous ambitions including Pakistan. Young people like yourself are inept of handling their emotions but the fact remains - Muslims can't unite, Period.

first of all the countries of this coalition are already working together so you dont know what the hell you are talking about.
the GCC is already working together and the GCC already has special relations with morocco jordan and egypt. so the only 2 countries that need to join is pakistan and sudan. so basically it already exist!! it would be smart to think before you comment.
and there is no such thing as wahhabi. im saudi i never met a wahhabi. please if you know where this secret cult is hiding let me know.
handle my emotions!! LOL

 

[Husnainshah]

You do realize there's Non-Arab and Non African Muslim Countries(so called) too, don't ya?
Besides, I wasn't talking about a coalition merely on a piece of paper. Deny it and I'll follow with a long post.
As for that secret cult, ask over 60,000 dead Pakistanis' families.

 

[Thorough Pro]

Iran sponsored scums

Question ... Defending Makkah and Madinah from ... !?

 

[SOHEIL]

Iran sponsored scums

 

[KingMamba]

It's a symbolic gesture, and this wouldn't be the first time. When Iraq invaded Kuwait, Pakistani forces were deployed in case Iraq tried to take the holy cities.

I have no problem with Pakistan defending the holy cities but one would think if the Saudi King is going to use the title Khadim al Haramain Sharif he should do it himself.

it already started in pakistan my friend. they have sleeping cells.. il bet my life on it

Last time they activated sleepers in Pakistan they were all culled.

 

[raptor22]

i in no manner intended to dishonor anyone sir, i was just saying that why is everybody thinking that the holy mosques would be attacked in this civil conflict of yemen, both sides fightining there are muslims and are well aware of the importance of those places. Now you tell me is pak army going there for defending the mosques(from whom?) I was referring that the saudi's want pak army for their ground offensive rather than protecting holy mosques.

They need Pakistani troops to defend Mecca and Medina against evil Iranians , didn't you know that ?? ...
Actually Saudis are in charge to do so that's why they sent troops to Bahrain, that's why they helped to topple elected president in Egypt, that's why they are against president of Syria and have been sending weapons and money there and now supporting president in Yemen by bombing Yemeni people.

 

[That Guy]

more like unwanted.... Saddam is a potent enemy, its fine that pakistani forces were dployed but houthis are going to invade Makkah and Madinah after killing KSA's troops !!!! is a Big JOke

Like I said, symbolic. Damage control, in case the Saudis get pissed off. Still, the Saudis suffered heavy casualties the last time they went against the Houthis, they're likely looking to Pakistan precisely because of this reason.

Defence minister is saying they want jets and ships. As long as there are no boots on ground, it should be acceptable to military, so as to keep KSA "happy".
Otherwise i don't think Pak gets military aid from KSA. It is mostly civilian aid, and i think its the civilian leadership, that is pushing for military intervention. So as to abide by the "duty of defending the territorial sovereignty of KSA". Someone please ask these leaders from where the hell do they have the threat of overrunning the desert. The yemenese are fighting their internal war, and they have not given a slightest of hint of going beyond their borders.
Now if they want pak to get involved in ground invasion to over through someone they don't like. Then the more pak stay away from this political tug of war, the better.

It's not the Houthis that KSA is worried about, it's Iran. The fear is that if the Houthis come to power completely unopposed, Iran would have a launching pad to conduct a military offensive through a friendly Yemen, if a war ever occurs between the two. Right now, the Iranians have no direct path to launch any military invasion of the kingdom, they would if Yemen has a Iran friendly Shia government.

sir everyone in this country knows today we are being fed up that we can't live without foreign aid.After our particiption into 1991 Gulf War KSA helped us a lot and after decade TTP showed up that help after 1991 was used to only promote there religious agenda.

Pakistan can live perfectly fine without foreign aid, as foreign aid makes up less than 1% of Pakistani GDP, and even budget wise is quite small.

I understand the fear of KSA's involvement in Pakistan, as I've already said that I too am always suspicious, but we need to look at this as a cost benefit view. The costs of rejecting KSA are huge, as practically the entire Arab world downgrade it's relationship with Pakistan, letting Indian influence grow there unopposed. This would have tremendous negative implications for Pakistan's economy, along with military relations with foreign nations. Pakistan would be viewed as unreliable, and weak, both of which Pakistan simply cannot afford.

 

[pakdefender]

Our Army is a volunteer Army , nobody gets drafted into anything. In such like situation the military can ask volunteers for deployment to KSA , which can include defending Makkah and Madina and any additional operations that may have to be done into Yemen and create an overseas force specifically for this purpose , as it is done for UN deployments.
What ever the military does , I have trust that they will do it the right way.

 

[Whirling_dervesh]

we are already working together in fighting them. saudi intelligence is working very closely with Pakistan on this issue for many many years now! decades!

I mean boots on the ground

 

[Rakan.SA]

I mean boots on the ground

they got boots spies you name it. its not something you see in the news.

 

[Sine Nomine]

I understand the fear of KSA's involvement in Pakistan, as I've already said that I too am always suspicious, but we need to look at this as a cost benefit view. The costs of rejecting KSA are huge, as practically the entire Arab world downgrade it's relationship with Pakistan, letting Indian influence grow there unopposed. This would have tremendous negative implications for Pakistan's economy, along with military relations with foreign nations. Pakistan would be viewed as unreliable, and weak, both of which Pakistan simply cannot afford.

Sir if Arabs dump us who is going to help them against Iran and Israel.India will not go against them in any condition,Pakistan has little to loose in that case but they will loose a lot.